HomeMy WebLinkAboutCC - March 16, 2010
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CJ.ANDOVER.MN.US
Regular City Council Meeting - Tuesday, March 16, 20 I 0
Call to Order-7:00 p.m.
Pledge of Allegiance
Presentation - Federal Cartridge Co./Hawkridge Park
Resident Forum
Agenda Approval
1. Approval of Minutes (3/2/10 Regular)
Consent Items
2. Approve Payment of Claims - Finance
3. Approve Resolution Rejecting Bids/I 0-3/20 1 0 Crack Sealing - Engineering
4. Award Bids/10-4/2010 Seal Coating - Engineering
5. Award Bid/10-5/2010 Pavement Markings - Engineering
6. Approve Resolution Accepting Donation/Federal Cartridge Co./Hawkridge Park/Bleacher/09-18-
Engineering
7. Approve Resolution Denying Conditional Use Permit/Clear Wireless LLC/Andover Lions Park - Planning
Discussion Items
8. Anoka County Sheriff's Department Monthly Report - Sheriff
9. Public Hearing/Consider Authorizing Application/20 10 DNR Natural and Scenic Area Grant Program-
Planning
10. Consider City Code Amendment/Adding Section 9-13 & Amending Sections of Title 12/Wind Turbines-
Planning
11. Approve Appointment/Coon Creek Watershed District Vacancies - Engineering
Staff Items
12. Schedule EDA Meeting- Administration
13. Schedule April W orkshop- Administration
14. Administrator's Report - Administration
Mayor/Council Input
Adjournment
(0
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and City Council
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
FROM: Michelle Hartner, Deputy City Cler
SUBJECT: Approval of Minutes
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
The following minutes were provided by TimeSaver for City Council approval:
March 2, 2010 Regular Meeting
DISCUSSION
The minutes are attached for your review.
ACTION REOUIRED
The City Council is requested to approve the above minutes.
Respectfully submitted,
(1~1Jw.'f/tPrh~
Michelle Hartner
Deputy City Clerk
Attach: Minutes
I
2
3
4
5
6 REGULAR ANDOVER CITY COUNCIL MEETING - MARCH 2,2010
7 MINUTES
8
9
10 The Regular Bi-Monthly Meeting of the Andover City Council was called to order by Mayor Mike
11 Gamache, March 2,2010,7:00 p.m., at the Andover City Hall, 1685 Crosstown Boulevard NW,
12 Andover, Minnesota.
13
14 Councilmembers present: Sheri Bukkila, Don Jacobson, Mike Knight, Julie Trude
15 Councilmember absent: None
16 Also present: City Attorney, Scott Baumgartner
17 Director of Public Works/City Engineer, Dave Berkowitz
18 City Administrator, Jim Dickinson
19 Community Development Director, Will Neumeister
20 City Planner, Courtney Bednarz
21 Others
22
23
24 PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
25
26
27 RESIDENT FORUM
28
29 No one wished to address the Council.
30
31 AGENDA APPROVAL
32
33 Additional information for Item 6 and Item 8.
34
35 Motion by Trude, Seconded by Jacobson, to approve the Agenda as amended above. Motion carried
36 unanimously.
37
38
39 APPROVAL OF MINUTES
40
41 February 16,2010, Regular Meeting: Correct as written.
42
43 Motion by Trude, Seconded by Jacobson, to approve the minutes as indicated above. Motion carried
44 unanimously.
45
46 February 16, 2010, Closed Session Meeting: Correct as amended.
47
48 Councilmember Jacobson stated on page one, line 43 before the word "circumference" insert the
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 2
I word "pipe". At the end ofline 46 and 47, Mr. Berkowitz made a statement and he did not think the
2 minutes met the intent. Mr. Dickinson indicated it did meet the intent.
3
4 Councilmember Jacobson asked on Page 2, line 4, after $35,000 he questioned the rest ofthe line.
5 Councilmember Trude stated the appraised value is missing. Mr. Dickinson stated it should state
6 "25% of the market value"
7
8 Councilmember Jacobson stated at the end ofline 10 instead of "my" it should be "Mr." and at the
9 end ofline 12, scratch "bid does" and insert "higher bids".
10
11 Motion by Jacobson, Seconded by Trude, to approve the minutes as indicated above. Motion carried
12 unanimously.
13
14 February 17,2010, Workshop Meeting: Correct as written.
15
16 Motion by Jacobson, Seconded by Trude, to approve the minutes as indicated above. Motion carried
17 unanimously.
18
19
20 CONSENT ITEMS
21
22 Item 2 Approval of Claims
23 Item 3 Approve Plans & Specs/Order Advertisement for Bids/09-22/Bunker Lake Blvd.
24 NW Frontage Road/Jay Street Realignment (See Resolution R022-10)
25 Item 4 Consider Approval Application for Exempt Permit/National Wild Turkey
26 Federation
27 Item 5 Debt Service Payment
28
29 Motion by Knight, Seconded by Bukkila, approval ofthe Consent Agenda as read. Motion carried
30 unanimously.
31
32
33 CONSIDER CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT/ANDOVER LIONS PARK/CLEAR WIRELESS
34 LLC
35
36 Mr. Bednarz explained Clear Wireless, LLC is seeking to locate a 120 foot tall tower and wireless
37 internet array within Andover Lions Park. A conditional use permit is required to locate an antenna
38 above 35 feet in height.
39
40 Mr. Bednarz reviewed the information with the Council.
41
42 Councilmember Trude reviewed the legal obligations that the City needs to follow. City Attorney
43 Baumgartner agreed.
44
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 3
I Mayor Gamache stated under zoning district regulations 9-12-5 item A, residential zoning districts,
2 B-public land, it indicates that when the City Council determines that the tower will not adversely
3 affect the use of the park or neighboring properties, it is one ofthe review criteria, another review
4 criteria is item C, the effect on values of property and scenic views in the surrounding area. There
5 does not seem to be a real legal point they can stand on and it seems to be in the eye ofthe beholder.
6 City Attorney Baumgartner stated the review criteria was somewhat subjective in its application but
7 then again as discussed before it is almost impossible to be all inclusive of all potential scenarios that
8 would arise, so unfortunately there has to be some subjective interpretation of the code and he
9 thought this was one example of it.
10
11 Mayor Gamache stated this has been through the Planning Commission and Park and Recreation
12 Commission. At the Planning Commission they actually asked for a different location within the
13 park. Mr. Dave Hagen representing Clear Wireless, thought the Planning Commission left the
14 location open as far as approval but deferred to the City Planner in regard to that.
15
16 Councilmember Jacobson stated while watching the Park Commission meeting he noticed a point
17 was made about lightening strikes and the potential impact to the natural gas pipe in the area and
18 thought this was a valid point and he asked staff to contact Northern Natural Gas and Centerpoint
19 Energy and staff has indicated each company did not have a problem with the tower going up.
20 Northern Natural Gas stated it had no history of anything near its pipeline being struck by lightning
21 and causing a pipeline failure. Centerpoint Energy stated the same thing and that they take this into
22 consideration when they build the pipelines, they do not have a concern with the tower acting as a
23 lightening rod and exploding the pipelines.
24
25 Mr. Berkowitz reviewed the letters from Northern Natural Gas and Centerpoint Energy and stated the
26 companies would want to review the design criteria. He stated this is normal and staff works with
27 other agencies on the design criteria before the installation of towers.
28
29 Mr. Kean Ponde representing Clear Wireless site engineering reviewed possible interference of this
30 service and the FCC requirements with the Council. He also reviewed the application maps with the
31 audience explaining where there will be possible coverage lapses in the area ifthe tower were to be
32 moved to different locations in the park.
33
34 Councilmember Trude asked what happens to the tower if this service does not work. Mr. Dickinson
35 explained there is a provision within the license that the provider put up security that if the company
36 would leave, the City has the ability to remove the pole/tower ifthe provider does not.
37
38 Councilmember Knight stated this tower is 120 feet tall and is taller than the other towers approved
39 and he wondered why that was. Mr. Ponde stated in order to supply service to the desired service
40 area they need to make the tower higher to provide the same coverage to everyone.
41
42 Councilmember Jacobson asked if there is any technical reason why the tower cannot be moved from
43 where proposed to closer to Bunker Lake Boulevard. Mr. Ponde stated if the pole is moved there
44 will be a coverage hole. All ofthe different tower sites are connected and if moved there may not be
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 4
I a line of sight and the tower may not work.
2 Councilmember Bukkila asked what the minimum height would be to attain the full signal strength.
3 Mr. Ponde stated they need 120 feet for the tower to cover the desired service area and to
4 communicate with the other sites.
5
6 Mr. Ponde reviewed with the Council the reasons for the height of the tower along with the reasons
7 why the tower cannot be moved further to the south.
8
9 Mayor Gamache asked if the Park Commission made a motion as to where the tower should be
10 placed. Mr. Ted Butler, Park Commission Chair, stated the motion ended up recommending denial
11 of the CUP at this park but they did talk about alternate locations.
12
13 Mr. Butler stated none of the members of the Park Commission loves the idea of placing poles in
14 their parks. He thought the role of the commission was to provide input in balancing the potential
15 benefits as well as the potential drawbacks on all ofthese wireless poles they have been looking at
16 over the months. He stated he is not speaking on behalf of the Park Commission Members. He
17 stated he voted nay against the denial because he thought their role as a Park Commission is to focus
18 on the park issues and whether on a net benefit basis this would be a good thing for that park and the
19 park system as a whole. A lot ofthe discussion ended up revolving around whether Clear Wireless
20 could have achieved their objectives by collocating on the existing tower along Hanson Boulevard.
21 He did not feel their role was to evaluate the technology infrastructure needs of Clear Wireless.
22
23 Mr. Butler stated Andover Lions Park is somewhat more problematic park than some of the other
24 ones they have looked at. He stated the playable area of the park is somewhat smaller than other
25 parks they have reviewed. He stated at the Park Commission meeting he recommended they use the
26 northern location proposed and since then he visited the park and has reconsidered. He thought the
27 best place would be the southwest area ofthe park.
28
29 Mr. Butler reviewed the Park Commission discussion regarding placement of the tower in the park.
30
31 Mayor Gamache stated the layout of this park is different than that of other parks and makes this
32 difficult for placement of a tower. He stated Lions Park would not have been a park the Council
33 would probably have wanted to be included in the City Code for areas to allow towers to be placed.
34 He thought the Council was looking more at the larger square parks in the City with large chunks of
35 land. He stated Lions Park does not have the large area to place a tower. He stated another concern
36 is the City is not there to help a business make money.
37
38 Motion by Gamache, Seconded by Bukkila, to deny the conditional use permit request for a
39 wireless internet antenna installation for Clear Wireless, LLC, 13960 Palm Street NW, with the
40 following reasons: That granting this conditional use permit will have an adverse affect on the
41 values ofthe property and the scenic views in the surrounding area due to the layout of this
42 unique park.
43
44 Councilmember Trude asked why this would adversely affect the value of property, she asked for
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 5
I an explanation on what that was based on. Mayor Gamache stated it is based on the fact that they
2 have taken testimony from individuals at the Planning and Zoning Commission that they feel that
3 while the train track is a part of living in that area they did not think that having a 120 foot pole
4 directly out their back window would be a positive. He thought this also adversely affected their
5 park because it would be placed next to the trail and would adversely affect the value of the trail
6 and if the tower were to fall it could fall directly onto the trail.
7
8 Councilmember Trude wondered ifthe applicant could respond to that comment because she
9 heard that comment too and they do try to get these away from residents view. She understood
10 some homes would see it and some will not and currently people see the County antenna flashing
11 all the time, including herself. She thought she will probably see this tower out her back window
12 and the next one in Shadowbrook Park East out her front window but she thought this is not
13 about helping a business make money, it is about a goal the community has which is to be a
14 progressive modern community that has amenities that families need and the City has a lot of
15 home based businesses than most cities and services like this are seen as essential. She thought
16 that a home selling in a community that has 4G wireless service will have more value than a
17 community that does not, so there are always those tradeoffs. She has a hard time flatly throwing
18 these out indicating this part oftown does not need wireless and felt there is an alternative. She
19 thought they could move the tower within the park and most of them are concerned about putting
20 the tower somewhere that it is not in plain sight. She stated she cannot support this motion and is
21 not sure the property values would be negatively valued.
22
23 Mr. Hagen stated he knew a study was done on the impact oftowers installed in communities
24 and it indicated there is no impact on property values of those types of towers nearby residential.
25
26 Councilmember Jacobson stated they did hear testimony by people indicating it would decrease
27 their property values; he did not see anything to back it up and did not think it should be included
28 in the motion. He wondered if the Mayor had anything to support his motion. Mayor Gamache
29 stated he did not and could remove the part about adversely affecting the values ofthe property
30 from the motion.
31
32 Councilmember Bukkila stated over the course ofthe weekend she had the opportunity to go to
33 the park twice and took a look at the layout in the lower portion of the park and she felt there is
34 already enough down there with the railroad and pipeline flags and to the north after the tree line
35 there is a break and it was so quiet and she did not want to disturb that by having a tower located
36 there. She felt this would be a disruption and break in the view.
37
38 Councilmember Knight stated he has had a lot of requests from residents wondering when they
39 would be getting Wi-Fi. He had a problem with the location because it is too close to someone's
40 home. He would like to table this to look at some other places, such as the County land to see if
41 they would accept the pole along the tracks on Bunker Lake Boulevard. He would prefer this be
42 tabled in order to talk to the County. Mayor Gamache stated he would not have a problem with
43 this but felt they needed to either approve or deny this. Mr. Dickinson agreed and thought values
44 of property should be removed from the motion and the Council should rely on the adverse affect
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 6
I on scemc VIews.
2 Mayor Gamache stated he is going to remove the adverse affect on property values from his
3 motion and instead include that the reason for denial would be because it would adversely affect
4 the scenic views in the area because it is so close to a large number of homes. The proposed
5 location interferes with the play space in the park.
6
7 Councilmember Jacobson asked if it was technically impossible to put the tower down on the
8 south side of the park and could it be placed across Bunker Lake Boulevard and into the County
9 Park. He wondered if they looked at the possibility of doing this and if so, what did they find.
10 Mr. Ponde stated if they tried to move the tower there will be some coverage holes on the north
11 edge of the desired coverage area. He stated technically they could make this work but there will
12 be some coverage holes.
13
14 Councilmember Bukkila asked ifthere was a cut offto the service and is it in Andover. Is there a
15 border to the area that they are able to successfully service. Mr. Dickinson stated they are
16 looking at 161 st A venue as the furthest north they could reach.
17
18 The Council discussed area coverage if the tower was moved to the County property.
19
20 Mayor Gamache stated he would remove the property values part of the motion and change it to
21 read".. . have an adverse affect on scenic views because it is so close to a large number of homes
22 in the surrounding area due to the layout of this park." Councilmember Bukkila agreed with the
23 change.
24
25 Councilmember Trude thought they needed another condition that has to do with the use ofthe
26 park because she thought moving it to the south would work but it does impede the play space in
27 the park and she thought that was part of the balancing. The proposed location interferes with
28 the play spaces of the park. Mayor Gamache stated he added"... due to the layout of this park"
29 for that reason.
30
31 Mr. Hagen stated they do have a significant investment of preparing a plan and drawings for this
32 site and time is important to them as they work towards a launch midyear. They would prefer to
33 get approval of the south location in the park to a denial but they would prefer they vote it up or
34 down rather than table it for future considerations.
35
36 Councilmember Knight stated he agrees with everything being discussed but there is a need for
37 Wi-Pi in the City and where he lives he pays triple for internet than what this will be so if they
38 could manage to move this to a site that is somewhat more acceptable will put them in much
39 better shape.
40
41 Mrs. Kim Sevaria, 13820 Sycamore Street, stated their home butts up to Lions Park ball field
42 area and she thought the area is too small to have the tower placed in the southern area. She
43 stated they have been working with the City to develop the park and the tower will not work.
44 She thought this would look terrible and higWy encouraged the Council to deny the entire
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 7
I request.
2 Motion carried unanimously.
3
4 Motion by Jacobson, Seconded by Bukkila, to have staff prepare findings offact to support the
5 denial for the Andover Lions Park Clear Wireless, LLC conditional use permit application.
6 Motion carried unanimously.
7
8
9 CONSIDER CONDITIONAL USE PERMITISHADOWBROOK EAST PARK/CLEAR
10 WIRELESS LLC
11
12 Mr. Bednarz explained Clear Wireless, LLC is seeking to locate a 118 foot tall tower and wireless
13 internet antenna array within Shadowbrook East Park. A conditional use permit is required to locate
14 antenna above 35 feet in height.
15
16 Mr. Bednarz reviewed the information with the Council.
17
18 Councilmember Knight suggested they look for a site to place the tower along the Ham Lake line of
19 the park. This would take the tower away from everyone and there is some high ground there and he
20 thought they could find a spot there. Mr. Berkowitz stated they did try to evaluate the site for the
21 best placement.
22
23 Mr. Berkowitz explained they did evaluate the site and there are a lot of wetlands in the area. He
24 reviewed the analysis with the Council.
25
26 Councilmember Trude wondered if the tower could be placed on the berm in the park. Mr.
27 Berkowitz stated that would be pretty tight to the right of way and the berm was put there to screen
28 the parking lot from the road.
29
30 Councilmember Bukkila asked if it could be placed amongst the grove of trees to hide it. Mr.
31 Berkowitz stated there is potential in the current location to place it further into the trees to hide it.
32
33 The Council requested the tower be placed further to the east into the trees.
34
35 Motion by Jacobson, Seconded by Knight, to approve the conditional use permit subject to the
36 conditions of the attached resolution changing the resolution under the Now Therefore It Be
37 Resolved, #2 to read: the tower, antennas and ground mounted equipment shall conform to the plans
38 revised November II, 2009 but move east as far as possible.
39
40 Councilmember Bukkila stated she is fine with that as long as it does not end up where it is currently
41 proposed. Councilmember Trude asked if they could have this moved to the southeast as far as
42 possible. Councilmember Jacobson stated they could.
43
44 Mr. Berkowitz stated when they move this they do not want to remove any trees. If they need to
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 8
I limb trees up he wanted to make sure that was acceptable as long as they do not have to remove
2 trees. Councilmember Trude stated if they have to remove a few trees that would be ok and would
3 ask for a couple more to be replaced. Mr. Berkowitz stated there are some mature oak trees in this
4 area and he would like to preserve them. The Council would not want the oaks removed and to use
5 judgment when placing the tower and equipment.
6
7 Councilmember Trude asked if they were asking for screening in this motion. Mayor Gamache
8 stated there is screening requested for the building. Mr. Hagen stated they did plan on putting up a
9 chain link fence, six feet high with slats for screening around it but if the Council would like some
10 screening in lieu offencing that would be agreeable. The Council preferred trees for screening over
11 a fence.
12
13 Councilmembers Bukkila and Trude amended the motion, point #2 to read: "...and reasonable
14 screening as directed by staff."
15
16 Mayor Gamache stated he is going to vote against this because he is having problems with these
17 being in parks. He never thought it would come to the point that there would be five coming in for
18 approval within months of each other.
19
20 Mr. Jason Kunzie, 13881 Sycamore Street, stated he agreed with many of the points raised by the
21 Council. He stated the issue is whether or not to allow 120 foot microwave towers to be constructed
22 in their parks and he agreed overall they should not be allowed to be constructed because they over
23 power everything in the area and there is no scale to how they are being placed in the parks. He
24 thought what it comes down to is they need to clarity the definition of a park because he thought
25 there was some confusion. He thought part of a park was open space and that open spaces increase
26 the value of homes so it must be the opposite if open spaces are removed or compromised and he did
27 not think a large microwave tower belonged in an open space.
28
29 Mr. Kunzie continued to give his opinion on the benefits and drawbacks to the towers in the City.
30 He stated the benefit would be the revenue. The drawbacks would be they are given limited
31 information, which he provided additional information to the Council. He stated he did not see the
32 speed or price benefit of this service. He wondered where the benefit is for this service to the
33 residents in the City. He discussed the safety issues related to the towers. He thought that without a
34 clear need to installing these towers adjacent to pipelines, that it not be done.
35
36 Councilmember Jacobson explained his experience with high voltage transmission lines and
37 indicated they crossed many pipelines when they have built these towers, he had never heard of any
38 concerns from the pipelines except that the towers are adequately shielded and grounded which they
39 are. He stated a pole adequately grounded according to electrical code and according to the specs set
40 out by the Natural Gas Pipeline Companies, it will adequately protect against something happening.
41
42 Mr. Kunzie asked what the increase in risk was and no one can really answer that because of the
43 unpredictability of lightening. Councilmember Trude stated she would be more worried about
44 pipeline ruptures and railroad cars derailing than towers being hit by lightening and causing a
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 9
I pipeline problem.
2 Mr. Kunzie stated in general he is against the construction ofthese things in open spaces and parks
3 that are not scaled properly and is detracting from property values and the things that the citizens of
4 Andover voted for in the referendum to protect these open spaces and they are not protecting the
5 open spaces they already have.
6
7 Mr. Ponde explained the tower is never a microwave, it is a small two foot dish and impossible to
8 reach the microwave ration to the ground. This is a regular tower just like the cell towers throughout
9 the City. He stated this cannot be compared to Comcast because it gives Wi-Fi outside of the home,
10 throughout the City and Comcast is only available for in home use. He stated they need to follow all
11 the FCC rules.
12
13 Mayor Gamache stated there were some towers approved in the City of Coon Rapids and some are
14 collocation on water towers, some in parks and he wondered if some were located in commercial
15 districts. He also wondered if the City of Coon Rapids denied any of the locations submitted on
16 public land. Mr. Ponde did not think there were any denials. Mr. Dickinson stated the consultant
17 that was working on the Hidden Creek project did work in Coon Rapids and there were two small
18 parks that did get declined and they are looking to see ifthey can be installed in the general vicinity.
19
20 Motion carried 4 ayes, I nay (Gamache). (See Resolution R023-1O)
21
22
23 CONSIDER CITY CODE AMENDMENT/EXTERIOR STORAGE OF COMMERCIAL
24 VEHICLES & OTHER STORAGE ITEMS
25
26 Mr. Neumeister stated the City Council directed staff to prepare two draft amendments to the City
27 Code pertaining to vehicles and exterior storage. The direction given was to allow up to one
28 commercial vehicle such as a truck, suburban, or a van other than a "cube van" or "moving truck" to
29 be parked on a residential driveway. The Council also directed that staff prepare an amendment to
30 allow an increased length of up to forty (40) feet for adequately screened recreational vehicles such
31 as motor homes, campers, travel trailers that are located in the rear yards of rural lots which are at
32 least two and a half (2.5) acres in size. The Planning Commission held a public hearing on January
33 12, 20 I 0 and continued the public hearing to their February 9, 20 I 0 meeting where they considered a
34 draft code amendment.
35
36 Mr. Neumeister reviewed the staff report with the Council.
37
38 The Council asked if this could be tabled and brought back to the March W orksession for discussion
39 after staff has reviewed the Council changes since they felt this needed more work and then to be
40 brought to the Council for resident input and final review.
41
42 Motion by Bukkila, Seconded by Jacobson, to table this item to a future Council Worksession.
43 Motion carried unanimously.
44
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page 10
I ADMINISTRATOR REPORT
2
3 City Staff updated the Council on the administration and city department activities, meeting
4 reminders, CIP Projects and development activity.
5
6
7 MAYOR/COUNCIL INPUT
8
9 (Andover Home Improvement Show) - Mayor Gamache stated March 20th the home improvement
10 show will be at the Andover Community Center from 9:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m.
11
12
13 Motion by Jacobson, Seconded by Bukkila, to adjourn. Motion carried unanimously. The meeting
14 adjourned at 9:28 p.m.
15
16 Respectfully submitted,
17
18 Susan Osbeck, Recording Secretary
Regular Andover City Council Meeting
Minutes - March 2, 2010
Page II
REGULAR ANDOVER CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES - MARCH 2,2010
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ......................................................................................................... I
RESIDENT FORUM ...................................................................................................................... I
AGENDA APPROV AL.................................................................................................................. I
APPROVAL OF MINUTES........................................................................................................... I
CONSENT ITEMS ......................................................................................................................... 2
Approval of Claims...................................................... ............................................................... 2
Approve Plans & Specs/Order Advertisement for Bids/09-22/Bunker Lake Blvd. NW Frontage
Road/Jay Street Realignment (See Resolution R022-1O) ................................................... 2
Consider Approval Application for Exempt PermitlNational Wild Turkey Federation............. 2
CONSIDER CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT/ANDOVER LIONS PARK/CLEAR WIRELESS
LLC Motion to Deny .................................................................................................................. 2
CONSIDER CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT/SHADOWBROOK EAST PARK/CLEAR
WIRELESS LLC (See Resolution R023-10) ............................................................................. 7
CONSIDER CITY CODE AMENDMENT/EXTERIOR STORAGE OF COMMERCIAL
VEHICLES & OTHER STORAGE ITEMS Motion to Table................................................... 9
ADMINISTRATOR REPORT............................... ........................................................ .............. 10
MAYOR/COUNCIL INPUT ........................................................................................................ 10
ADJOURNMENT......................................................................................................................... 10
@
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.C1.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Councilmembers
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator / Finance Director
FROM: Lee Brezinka, Assistant Finance Director
SUBJECT: Payment of Claims
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
Attached are disbursement edit lists for claims related to the on going business of the City of Andover.
DISCUSSION
Claims totaling $159,362,84 on disbursement edit list #1- 4 from 03/02/10 to 03/12/10 have been issued and
released.
Claims totaling $183,776,33 on disbursement edit list #5 dated 03/16/10 will be issued and released upon
approval.
BUDGET IMPACT
The edit lists consist of routine payments with expenses being charged to various department budgets and
projects.
ACTION REQUESTED
The Andover City Council is requested to approve total claims in the amount of $343,139.17. Please note
that Council Meeting minutes will be used as documented approval.
Respectfully submitted,
)i"~~
Lee Brezinka
Attachments: Edit Lists
~
"
~
P-<
~
-i:i
8
~
Cl
.g
.. &l
...
~
p::
&! ~
_ V)
... ..0
,,0
"
0'"
.&>.
5'"
EI
;::l6
i
g'o
",b;
....
~'<l"
'"
o '
<
,,0
,.c;'<l"
u:;
~
0=
~
....
0
Cl
-
..
0
EI
~
~
'"
~
~
'"
0
d
00
=
00 0_
0
dd 0
---- ~
V) V) d
t--t--
V)
t--
\
~
"
~
0
~
0
'"
-
;::l
0
..,
0
.g
..... ~
<Zl
:?
......
.. "
~
;::l,.c;
0
au P-<
(])'-H = 0
'"
~ ..
,<;..,
.-< 0 0
-l1 0 ~
.-
~~ .... O~c;l
~ ~ '"
~ .S< ~~o
u.c ,
... ~~
0
~~ '" ",E-<
-
'" ~O73
0
'" "
~
- ~ - "
"El"El
p., ~ ,;.; ....:io,.c;
'"
",u
E3E3 ~
r.r:,,..Q ,
g
+-,U 0
~
S a-s 0
-
~ 0
<n
'" ~
:.:l
o~ <nO
<;..,
.@(:f)
0
Q S' ij:io Z
J:
<8 .o..e .. ....:i
~
.. "
k - '" ;.;
0
~ .s '0 .g
6
~!t ~ 5
.... :>
1il
'5
S'
8
,
~
-
"
gp
~
000
Z ZZ
~.i:j .i:j
"" "
Q.} - - -
U ~ ~ ~
= <=l <=l <=l
e P:< P:< P:<
~::r:::r: ::r:
~ ~ ~ ~
_~ N~~~~~~~ M~~O~OOOOOO~OOO~~~
.. "<t' .. 0 0 0 <=> 0 0 0 .. - - N - N - - N N - 0 N N N _ 0 0
_ 8~ B~~gg~~g B~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
_ <l) I <l) I I I I I I I Il,) I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~ ~o ~ooooooo ~ooooooooooooooooo
~ ~o ~ooooooo ~ooooooooooooooooo
= <l.l_ <l)~~~MMN- <l)NN~~NN-O-O~-NNN--
Z OO~ OO---~~OOOO OONN-----~~~~MNNNOOOO
... ~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
U 00 uOOOOOOO 0_______0000____00
U ~~ ~N~~~g~8 ~~~88888~~~~888888
< UN UNNN~~~~ UOOOOOOONNNNOOOO~~
..
...
01
~ 0 0000000 00000000000000000
= - ------- -----------------
o 0000000 00000000000000000
~ ~ ~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
e M MMMMMMM MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
= ~ ~~~~~~~ QQQ~QQQQQQQQQQQQQ
~. M MMMMMMM MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
~ 0 0000000 00000000000000000
~ 00 00000000 OOOOO~~MOMMOOOOMN
A ~ ~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
O ~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~OM~O~~~~MMOOO~~O
S NN ~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~N~N~~M~~~N~~
~~ ~~~oooo~~~ ~~~ M ~ MN N
...... . ...
"'<.l.( ~~ ~ ~~oo
~
~
~ ~
15 88 8 8 ~
.~ II ~ ~ s:::: s:::: 0:;
~ ~ ~e~e e N
u _ ~~~~ ~,
g ~ 15808 S ~
..f-) i2 u cd .t:l b .t:l .t:l b b b ~ C) u .~ U d) bJ} OJ) ~ rI) ~ u 0
r.f.1 d)~'- ~~~~~ s:::: ::sa.>::s N
.~ ~tS -aClClClClClClCt ~ 0 0 rI) o~'+i'.E rI) rI) Q::SO a rI) U) ~
~ .~ &1 S ~ .3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Sb i i ] i .~ 3 3 :& ~ .A ~.~ i :& :& ~
Q) 't; Q.. 1ii .s ~ 8 <Zl "H/H/H/Hn <Zl ~ a '<=! .<=! ~ '<=! -Iii ~ ~ g. g. !l :~l:E -Iii.<=! g. g. s
-,.0 0 .C .~ ~ ~.. ~o (9 S c; (9 G C3 6 ~ ~ 1i ~ ::E .s 2 ~ tS en en ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1i en en ~
l-I - - Cf.l rI) U) U) ...... .. _ - --- - U) .. .......,
.... I-< ::;s ~" Ol U :>.. 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ 0\ U - .- .- 0\ .- S <Zl Ol U U s .s s S S'6b U U ....l
1.\.1 ~ Pool <1.l 8 ~ ~ +.,.' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ,g Q) ~ ~ 0 ~ d) - Q).~.~ 0 ~ Q) Q) d) Q) .~ .~ C+-I
>-.~ S; ~ <<:~U u?:n'l~~~~~u ~~~~~::;S~::;S::;S::;Su~::;S::;S::;S~::;S::;S g
ro (,) N P::
P-;Q) , -"l
~ 0 g
lZl U - ~ 0\ .- .<::
~ ~ eg~" a u
...... I-< _ ~_ p:.. ...
l-< Q) '" ~_ ~ "
~..f-) ~Q 0 00 E ~ "E
O;::l:88 Z ~ 8 ~ S-
o ~::E-g .~ ~~ ~.b.b.b.b.b.bb ~ 8
Q S ;..; 5 0 -g t-- -g CICICICICICICI -g ,
< U ~~ .s >~ >~~~~~~~ > ~
'"
g'p
p...
"
"
=
"
...
~
"
~
OOOOl(')Ol()OO
C'lNNN_NOO
... 00 I""'"'lO_MMN
.......____......N"d"
" I.D\.O\O\O\OI.D\ON
,Q I I I I I I I I
8 10010101010010
00('1")010.01010
= NNO\OOOOOOOOO
Z NN_ooooooooO
<o:::t"d"o:::t"'d"<o:::t"d""d"O
.... I I I I I 1 I I
" ......__000,00
" 100101001000
-< .......-------
00 0 I.D 1..0 \O\Ot""-
~
OS
~ 01001001000
....
= .......--.......----
0001001000
" f::!~c:!t:!~~!:::!r:!
8 ('1")("f')("f')MMMMM
~ 01010100000,
OS --------
f:l.< MMMMMMMM
0000010100
.... \DNM\O\DOl/)OOa 0'"
= 000\\0 OOMOO['-... lO -
= 0\0""'; d It"idl.cic-ric--i N
0
8 I()N_O\N_O-.:t'_ 0
__ N'- "'d" '0
-< -" ~ '"""
-
~
p...
t-
o; -
-tl N
<g .. " ,
~~ ~~ 0
-
0
= 0 -'< 0 !:::!
= ~~~~~Q() " ....
._.,-l._._._ 0.. tU co .. " " '"
0 ~~ 0
.. 15:0. 15:a:o.:E ~ .S 11 -
.... ""
c.. p., 0.. P. 0.. 0.. IZl ...c:: 0 2-
'C r35aJ3aa~5~~ -sz ~
" ddddd"S~~~ '"'"
'" 00 00 IZl IZl 00' tU ;::1
" ~~~~~~~~o 15'0
~ '<-<
E-<E-< 0
8
p...
-'<
"
"
.<::
U
0 ~
z s-
"
" 0
'S u
~ ,
~
-
"
~
~
0
z
.;,;
"
.. :g
OJ
= &l
"
...
~ ~
~
-Of)
-
... 4.iC't1
,,-
" <1""
,Q " ,
s ,,0
0"'0
" "Of)
Z IZl ""
"."'1"
.... "0
OJ ~:::
OJ
-< ON
..
....
=
~ 0
.... -
= 0
.. ~
~
~
'"
~ 0
.... 00 0_
= 00 0
" 00 d
0 00 0
S NN N
-<
~
~ .[;l ~
p, ....
" Of)
~ 00
.... ~
t-< ,
i 0
.. " -
~~ 0
~
tl ". 0 0
~ .. " k -
...... = " " '"
.....:l .Sl _OJ ~1 e
Q)'+-< .... i~~ ~
s::>.. <sZ ;.:1
.......0 .;::
~~ ~ OJ ,sf) OJ OJ ~
'" o " - - 0
.. 0"<:: o 0 ....
.... ~ 1'00 t-<t-< ~
~~ 'f! f)
00 e
P-.] ,
0
rnU - 0
0 i "S
g ~ ~ ~
",0 0
;l ,,- Z
-0'" 0
8 a _ 0
'+=l .. " ;..; ,
"
,D-o '0 0 ~
;..: -E -0
U 0 i; 5
<U ~ 'C :>
~~ ...
-
"
~
0..
o 0 0 0 0 0
z z z z z z
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
l1) d) d) l!) d) 11)
~ - - - ~ - -
rJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~.:: .:: .:: .:: .:: ,;1
... P'I P'I P'I P'I P'I ""'
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~OO NO ~OO ~OOO ~~ ~~~~~~
~8~ ~~ ~~~ tl8~g ~~ ~88888
_ u~~ UN U~_ OMNN 0_ OMMMMM
~ ~~~ ~~ =~~ =~~~ =N =~~~~~
.c <l) I I l!) 1 11) I I d) 1 lid) I d) I I I I I
e &88 &8 g.88 g.888 g.g g.g~~~~
= lUMM lUM l!)~~ d)OO~ <uO l!)~~~~~
7 OOMM 00- W~~ OO~~~ 000 0000----
~ ~~~ ~~ ~~~ ~~~~ ~q ~~~~~~
rJ 0__ 0_ 000 0_00 0_ 00____
rJ ]~8 ~8 ]~~ ]8~~ ]8 ]~8888
< Uoo Uo UNN UONN Uo u~oooo
.,
....
os
9 00 0 00 000 0 00000
= -- - -- --- - -----
00 0 00 000 0 00000
~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~~~ ~ ~~~~~
~ NN N NN NNN N NNNNN
~ -- - -- --- - -----
~ -- - -- --- - -----
^. MM M MM MMM M MMMMM
~ 00 0 00 000 0 00000
d ~~~ ~~ ~~~ g~~~ ~~ g~~~g
= . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
O ~~M ~~ ~~- ~N~N 0000 ~~~N~
d N~OO NN O-N ~OM_ -- ~~~~oo
~ ~_~ ~~ -NM ~_~ ~~ ~M_~
~ < ~~M ~
'% bI)bI)
.S .S
, ~~ ~
ll) d) 6- S ~ l!) d) ~~
CIl ~ lUlU g~~fP-i
5 0 ~~ P88~@
~ ~ olJolJ ~OOdOO ~
~ :sa ll) 0,) :D (\) Go) ,;;;;I ] ~
1:1 ""~ bI)~~ ~~~~.B ~
~ .Rk E~~ g..::.::]i 8
tIltll i> 0,..,..0 '0 '~ lI)lI)__U')
"" 0 oS~'"" >>OJOJ ",bI)-~t:c.>> -
b.l)b.O _ ;...;... 000 $-l "lI) -
-- 0 ~""~ .,,~~ S o~ ~u~ '
iZl iZl N .~ -:;! g ~ " " " eo '"" :2i :2i B p 0
~ ~ l:.;-( ...c:l l:l:S _ ;... S S ';::l 0 b.f) ~ I _
...... " " 0 g. Cl (Q ,," ~ S S " u :::l .S .S U '; 0
.~ ~ ~ ~ (5 8 ca ~ ~ 88 J: ,0.0 gf b.O~ 1IJ S
~ = k k .. .;:: .. _'" .::.~ .. > .. .. E .;::; .., .13 0 z -
s ~~] 1IJ] ~~~~ ?~8~] 81 ~B~~~o ~
Q) """'0 1:... . 0 u ~ 0 6h d..c:: 0 'S! 0 0 0 0 0 0 ;;1 "..,..,.!; il= e
,........( .~ OJ OJ E-< oS " E-< .~ " u E-< :-. N N N E-< U N E-< ""' iZl ~ - M E-< _
~ 8 ~ ~ '5 '5 ~ r~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tJ as "E ~ "8 ~ :s "8 ~ 8 'a 'a 'a =a :a ~
I.o\.,) ~ <( Q,) ':E 1:d ~ 1IJ v 0 1IJ .CQ 1IJ ;... iU lI) l:l:S l:l:S ~ 1IJ ~ 11) .~ 0... 0... 0... -- -- t+-t
>:-. u 8 ~ ",:::E:::EO ~~O <C~~O ~:::E:::E:::EO ~:::EO :..:~~~lLs g
ro"U ::: ~
p.. 0 , -'<:
~ 0 g
rnU :5 u 6h "" 0
~ I-< lC:' oS'-:::: U.:: k
~(1) - U') 0 --< 0 (\)
~ ~ {/1_ 0 e:> () ~ ~ o-N('i")~l(") 1j
O;::l .g "'0- Z:::E ~ ~ .5.{ ~ .!:l 2, 2, 2, 2, 2, g..
,..., ......... ('i")-:;t ~ <t: ~ ~ 'G..j____.-l ~
,.'\. ~ ~ ,. Co) i-: _ ~ i-: i-: i-: 0"10"1 i-: t...: 00000 0
'-' d.D13 .:= 00000 0 0 oGr:--..r:--.. o~ OC'lNC'lN.N. ()
U O$::i;..;-- 0 "ONN. "'C "'C('i")<o::t "'Co\O\O "'C~ "'C~~~~cA I
-< 1IJ S :> t::__ t:: t::('i")('i") t::\O~'<::t t::.-. t::____.-.
U ~~ = ~iZliZl ~ ~NN ~-~~ ~N ~NNNNN 0..
~~ ~ ~OOU') ~ ~NN ~ooo ~_ ~O"IO"I~~~ ~
<'I
"
~
I>-<
0 Z 0 0
0 0 0 0
z z z
z z z z
.;j .;j .;j .;j
.;j .;j .;j .;j
" " " "
" " " "
.. ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~
""
= " rn rn
rn rn rn "
" ~ ~
~
...
~ :r: ~ ~ :r:
:r: :r: :r: :r:
~ ~ ~ ~
U ~ ~
<<:
a
- <'I ~'" ;!:;oo
'" '" .....a ooa 0, or> _or> _N -'"
aa ~ ..N ..a ..~ ..- a)N
..a ..NN
... ~~ dio "a "a "N "N ,,~
"aa
'" '" "'" ,,~ "<'I "'" "00- "00-
"'" ,,-~
.. "'''' "'" "'" "'" "'" "N "<'I
"'" ""''''
,Q , , " 0 " , " , " , " 0
" 0 " , " , ,
a aa ;::la ;::la ;::la ;::la ;::la ;::la
;::la ;::laa
"'~ <:>,a <:>,a <:>,a <:>,a <:>,a <:>,a
<:>,a <:>,a a
= 0, 0, "a "N ,,00- "'" "a "a ,,0,
"N'"
Z ~~ m '" mN m '" m ~ m a ma moo
moo-oo-
00-00- ",'1 ",'1 ",'1 ",'1 ",9 ",9 ",'1
",00-00-
.... 0 0 o 0
~- ,,~ ,,~ ,,~ ,,~ "a "a "a
"aa
"" aa ]a "a "a "a "'" "'"
"a ~f'rlM
< ~- u8 ""~ ""- ""- ""- ""-
""N U--
aa Ua Ua Ua U<'I UN
U'" N<'I
"
....
OS
~ aa a a a a
a a a aa
.... ~~ ~ ~ - ~
- - ~ ~-
= aa a a a a
a a a aa
.. ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~~
a NN N N <'I N
<'I NN
~ ~~ - ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ -~
-- -- -- -- -- --
-- -- -- -- --
~ '" '" '" '" '" '"
'" '" '" '" '"
aa a a a a
a a a aa
.... aoo-oo- aa '" '" -~ aa
or> '" aa N<'I ~~N
= "'.....<'1 -- '" '" -~ aa
.......... aa 00 00 .....00'"
= N\.Oo\ \C\Q <"'iM odod 00
vi"'; r--:~ NN C'il.Oo\
0 o,No, 00- 00- ~~ -- '" '"
<'IN 00 00 '" '" o,"'N
a NOON 00-00- NN
aa 0, 0, ..... ..... ~ 0, ~
< 00-0
("fj"'C'f)'" !:,"--"t..:' (".f ('.f ~
.:r:
13.U '"
8@ -
-
b';> iJ::
12~ ~
" I>-< ~
[a a " .....
0 t;j
~O " ""
::E
0, '1: '" ...
'"
~ "
'" ~] -11 " '"
"
.~ OJ) 0, " 1; ~
.=l a
R] OOm il
'"''' 0 ~
~ a '"'OJ) 1:: ~ ""0
~~ ....:I or ~
B;E " ..:i! ;>,
.- ;>, 0'0 t> 0
....:II>-< U 0 il ' "
P" .=l-El .g a
~.El .- " U ~-11
.'" ~
~ S -.; "" 0
a
... "" "
pO ...
~OJ) m~ " t;j o '" 'C 0
" 0 ._ U I>-< '" ~
[(J.El ] 0 .. "'- " " """ >;:r:
~ gs .. '" -
= :a~] " .. ~ ro" ~~7J ..c:- .. @'O-a
g~~~ -
0 ~a-'; ":.s'El o 6h 'El oorSs ~8]
--
.- [(J~ ~ """"" '"
.... ~.- 0 " '" 0 ..:i!iZi~ o gfo 8 Vol 0 "o~
m " 0 ~ """"~ 2-
Po. "...:i E-< iJ::i'l~ f-<~E-< U._ E-< "E-<
:r:-5~ ,",,~f-< ;::l ;::l 0
.;:: ~ 'a 11 ",,",,'" Ei.~ '" ..... " "'""'", cd '';:::::: ~
~m ~:a-11 ...CIlCllE-< ~
org'" ",",,-11 !U . .~
"" " " " o " .0 il ~ C> 0 '" ;::l " ~ ~
~ g ;.:1
'" ~~6 .- a " " """ o " " o """ o OJ) "
IZlti]
" ';iJ::EO ..:i!""" U~O ..:i!""" ..:i!""" ..:i!::BO
!U'-'- ....c:l .....
~ ~u ~u PU
';;:.=lu ~::E::Eu 0
8
I>-<
-11
"
"
"'00 ~ 00-
'" @ g ~ 0
iJ::oo- .e..... - '0
0 i
" il
",,00 0 U'" ~ U
m ~
'" - ,,- ;::l
ti
~ 0 , ;'::::1:'"-- " ~~ '"
'"
aa ~::!: ..:i! ..:i!
'" " s-
~~ <<:
~NN
.. aa ..a ;..; ..a ;..; ;..;
;..; ;..; .. 00 00 0
" NN C>9 "''''
"'aa
.- o , 0..... Oa 0 0
0 000- 00000 U
0 '" '" "",0, ""'00 ""a "" "'"
"" ""a "".......... 0
~ ~N iilo, iil~ "- iila iil
" "a, 500 ~
NN :>gg :>::!: "a :>~ "
"..... :>aa
0,0, :><'1 :> :>
:>'" aa
'"
"
~
~
0 0 0 0 ~ 0
z z z z z
.;,; .;,; .;,; .;,; .;,;
.;,;
" " " " " "
., :g :g :g :g :g
:g
'"
CI &l &l &l 0"'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' &1
&1
" ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
... ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ::c ::c ::c ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 0
::c
~ ~ ~ ~ ONNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN ~
<00000000000000000000000000000000 ...:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
'0 \D ~O ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Q',
0
-'0 ,.....t1.()lJ)l() -'0 ",'0'0
..0 ..,.....t....... ....... ..N ..---------------- ..0 ..00
... ,,0 0...............-1 "'" 00000000000000000 ,,0 ,,00
U", 0____ U _ UNNNNNNNNNNMNNNNN U", U",,,,
., 0'1' C\D\DI..O 5~ C\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D\D l'l\D 5'9'9
..Q Q) I I I d) I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I " ,
El ;:l0 ;:jooo ;:l0 ;:joooooooooooooooo ",0 ;:l00
0"'0 0'000 0"'0 cr<1.()OONNNO~OOOO-oooo 0"'0 0"'00
= "'" Q)oooooo ,,'" Q)~,.....tO~~~.....-l~__.....-l_~N~N "'" "'" '"
Z rn~ lZ)OOOOOO rn- lZ)_OOlJ).....-l_...-tOO.....-lOOOOOOOO-OO-OO rn..;- rn..;-..;-
~-.::t'o::::t'o::::t' ~! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~"i ~..;-..;-
~, , , ,
ti Uo 0000 0...-10...-1___0_0000_0...-10 uo goo
Jl..;- (1)000 "0 ~oooooooooooooooo ~~
'" ..d.___ .o- o...-l__.....-l.....-l__,.....t...-l....-t__...-IM_N .o"''''
< u:;t U--
U\O\OI..O Uo 01.()OOOO1.()OlJ)lJ)1.()1.()OlJ)01.() UN
NN
.,
-
eo
~ 0 000 0 0000000000000000 0
00
d - --- - ______________...-I,.....t
- --
0 000 0 0000,000000,000000
0 00
" 2J ~t:!t:! ~ t:!t:!t:!~~t:!~~t:!t:!t:!~t:!t:!~~
~ t:!t:!
El NNN N NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN N
NN
~ - --- - __,.....t_________.....-I............__
- --
- --- - ---------------- -
--
Ilo< '" "''''''' '" MMMM('1)('1)('1)("t)('1)("f')("f')("f')('f)("f')("f')("f')
'" '" '"
0 000 0 0000000000000000 0
00
- 00 ,.....(0\Ct'-- 00 ~~~OO~~O~~~~N~~OOO
00 00
= 00 ~Nr:-\O 00 Or:-~~r:-~N~ONN~OO~~N~
00 0'0
= tritri .....:;~~tri dd ~dtriN~Nd~~~dtri~.....:;tri~d
dd d~
0 -- - '0 r-- 00 00 ~\CO~O\C~OO~,.....(~r:-MNO,.....(,.....(
00 r--_
~ '" '" -- -- M~,.....(N~~,.....(N,.....(,.....(,.....(
~ ~ 0 '" '"
O\~... N'" ,.....(" ,.....(" ,.....(... 0
-
~
~
'"
'?
.... ....
-
o '" .... 0
-
" - " tJ
g8 [;J 1::
~ ~ ,
d 6i\bll- " E
0-0- 0
.Ei s ",f'! '" .....S ~ "" U
di~ -
.;;:]' '" 0
~;CI)CI) ll):9-sa $-4 [;J.Ei [;J::C::C S
CI is A-t.....Q)(\) ~ ~ ~.Sll)A-t,.....(NM~~ \C~ .g~~_ S "
" "
ll) ~.. ~._._.- .. ll) ll) .. ~~~=*~~~~ ~~ 5*di~" ~ td .. stdtd -
0 :::\rn'lil ~~~~~ .1l"E'l'lil .B-~0888g~ ~~ oo~~~i 1!""'lil -
.- ~r}3~ '"
- o'd"" 0 05e~'-'~'~=ll) =~ ~.g=.go urno 0
.S< ~t-< OOll)~ ~s~ ~SSOQ_OOM~~rotd~ Ot-< .o 0 0
~
... l'l "" $-4r.Sr:.:r:.:~ &l:::\~ "-"" u-- -
~.~~.~~oooo~~~~~~~oo~~~ '"
'" o " U ~~ ~ ~ ~ p8 ~ .>l ~ U ld ~ ;::j
'" ~s] l'l~~~"""Sc~S~~b=Z~" '" "
., o '_~.o .- 0..0:: " 0"' i:3: .....!ol.!ol.!ol ~ "' i:3: ~ i:3:'- .- ~. .o "'".o
.... " " ....
~ r:!lrnU r:!l~::S U UNU U~ ~~~~~rn ~~ U~ ~U ~~U r:!l~~
0
8
~
'i:j
I
~ "
- '"
cJ
ft '"
c - ~ S
~
....
0 " il !if
!if 15
0 ;t; >>
Z 0 0 - .o .o
S'
., ~oo ~ :x: ~NO_M,.....(,.....(O_t'--\C~MO~OOr:- U U
'" ....'0 MNNO ;.; ~~r:-~~~O~~ONM\OOOr:-~r:- ;.; ;.;
0
'0 000 000\0 0 ~~NM_~\O\O_MN~~~OO,.....(O .g 0
U
""0 ~('1")MM "" ~~OO,.....(_N~MMt'--r:-~ON~~ ""
,
~ 0'" 5000 0 ll)N~~~~~\OOO~ON~~Nr:-N ~
0 ~
>8 >000000 > >oooooooooooooooooo~~~~,.....(~~ >
... "'''' '" ~~~~~~~~~~~~~\Or:-r:-
<T
"
~
P-<
o 0 0 0 0
z z z z z~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
.. ,. .. .. ..~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ ~ ~ A ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
= ro ro ro ro ro~~~__________________
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~g~~gg~~gg~~g~~~gggg~
U U U U U~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
NM ~O ~O ~OO ~O~~~~~~~~~~~~~---~~~~
.. N .. N .. N .. 0 <=> ..1""""100000000000, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
... o~ ~o 00 UMM uMOOOOOOOOOOOOONNNOaOa
Q~ u_ 0_ oNN o_NNNNNNNNNNNNNMMMNNNN
,.Q~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~ ~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~---~~~~
U I 4) I d) I iU I I Il,.) I I I I I I , I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I
d ~O ~O ~O ~OO ~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
~ ~o ~o ~o ~oo ~oOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOMOO
= u~ uN uO iU~~ uO___NNNNNNNOMOOOO-~~~
Z oo~ oo~ oo~ oo~~ oog~~~~~~~~~~~~~ggg~~~~
...... ~ I ~ I ...!::4 I ~ I I ~ I I I I i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~ Uo U_ UO U__ u_oooooooooo_o____o___
~ ]~]8]~ ]88 ]8~88~~~~~~~8~8~8~~88~
< ON 00 UN UOO UO~~~~~~~~~~O~OOOONOOO
~
'"
e 0 0 0 00 000000000000000000000
- - - - -- ---------------------
~ 0 0 0 00 000000000000000000000
g ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ N N N NN NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
~ - - - -- ---------------------
= ~ - - ~- ~~----~~-~-----~~~~~~
~. ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ 0 0 0 00 000000000000000000000
d ~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ggg ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~8~~~
= . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
o ~ NN ~~ ~~ ~~~ _~O~__N~M~ONOONOO~~~OO~~
8 ~ ~~ 00 0000 ~~oo ~~~~~~~~~~~_ ~ __~~_N
~M N~ ~~M - - ~~
... " "
~ - -
g g g s
_ ~~ ~$ ~I 10 I I
.-I ~~ ~ooOV~MOU~~
~;SS~~~~~~~S'~~OOOO'~NN
~ ~=._._._._._~._=ooOOONNN~N~
~~ N~~~~~~~~~~~~~N88-~~~
U d _ ~ I I I I I I I I I I ~N_NNN ~N
d Cj s:: oO~N~~N~-~~O- $-0__- I - ~
!5 .e~~~g~~~~~~~N5tl~~~~~~
s:: tl~ :3 I -~r-oo~~oo_--""Eh~~\D-N >~
~ ~ 'Cd aN ~ l() 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l() 0 ~,- !3 M ~ ~ 0\ ~ "'0 ~
..... ",Cd 10:::::1 I.() N N N - N N N N N N S ~ P=l - - ..... I.() .....-t ~ 0
~ s:: . ~10:::::1~ ~~__________=.....~~~s::-~~ ..
"'0 tl U ~~ $-oOO~~O\_r-\DNM~N~ 0<.1Q"'O'"'Q ~- ~""O -
8 S ~ ,El 2 >-.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .... H ~ ~ ~ u 12 0'0 -
<S ~o ~ ~......~ C_lU~s:l:==s:l:s:l:l=ll=llU.BbO.....:l.....:l.....:l~~ti= I
~ .;:; ~ 1:: ~~ a ::1 _ ~ ~.0.9.9.9.9.9 ,9 ~ Cd .g 't:I "'0 "'O.~ 0 ~ ~ ~
bll ,~ .... ~ - 0'" >.iX1 ~ 0 o:g t! t! t! 1;! 1;! 1;! 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ .... - 0
~ 0 ~ '" '" "" bll~ ....,.c;,.c; ~ ~ ~ ~ .. .. .. ,.c; l::l "'....,....,...., ~ <> u ~ N
. P l'Il 8. .8 ~ 0 ~ ctS Q ~ ~oo en. 00 CZl w r:n 00 ~ t: ~ C\] C\] C\] .- 0 tl:S ~
== .. ~ il .. " iJ .. " g),.. .I:l 0 - .. l::l 5h ;l: S R ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 0"'" 5h 5h 5h :0 0 5h ;:::
o ca 0 ~ ~ C+=i 00 Cd i=l tl:S Cd U _ 0 Ci:1 ~..... 0 ~ a._._......... ~ ::::l.... a ..... i-I-( ..... .....,....., 0 = 0 .- ~
;:: ..... t:io~ Cd.......... o.cQ+-' ~ON~ ~en.~~~.....:l~.....:lH~.....:l~~ooUWCl)Cf)U~-Cf) ~
~ ~ 't:: U ~ (IJ 0 ~ u ~ ~ p::j N t>-o~ ::s I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I e.-
.- ,J:l _r./J:;:::: ~ ca X_NO~N\D~N\D_~I.()OOO~~~N\D~O\ .....
C ~ u a ~ ()' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l=l ~ e ~ g - l(') 00 \D 0 ~ 00 ~ \D NON ~ r- v 00 00 ..... ~ N - .~
fa g ~ 8 gaS g ~-e g ;:3 =~ g ~~~~~~ggfriG;g~~=~~~~~~~~~ H
~ ~ ~o~ _.~~ -~~ O~tl~ O\Dr-Ml()OOr-r-r-~l(')l()OO\DOOOOOI.()O\r- ~
~ u ~ooU U~U U~U o~~u UN_NNN_NNNNNNNNNNNN_NN 0
....
P-<
~
"
,.c;
~ ~ - 0
.s ~ U (;J ~ a
00 a) r./J .... c:: .....
o ] [;l gj ~ l::l '"
Z u 0 0 80N 8 ~
~ i-: i-: r--. i-: i-: l{) - i-: 0
._ 0 o~ o~ o~~ 0 U
~ "8 "8;! --g~ ]~~ ] I
= ~ lU('f') lU~ ~U() ~ P,
~ > >- >~ >iX1iX1 > ~
on
"
~
~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
= ~~~~~~---------------------------------------
...~ I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I 1 I 1 I I I I I 1 I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~g~gggggg~~~~g~~g~gg~~~g~g~~~~~gg~~gg~~g~~g~g
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
N 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~ ~m~~~~M~MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~O~O~OOOO~~O~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO~O~O~~~~OO~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
... OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOMOMOMMMMOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
NNNNNNNNNNNNNNN~N~N~~~~NNMNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
_ II I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~ 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~ OOONNOO~~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
= ~~~~~O~~~~_____O_O~OOOONNOOOOOOOO~~~~~~~~~~~O
Z MMM~_~~~~oo~OOooooooOOOOMOOOOOOOO~~~~~~~~NNNNNNNNNNN~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~9~q~9999~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ __~~_~o__ooooooooo_oooooo~______~_~~~___~____
~ ooooooooooooooo_o_o~___oooooooooooooooooooooo
~ ___~__~~____~__________NN~_______~_~_~_______
~ OOOOOO~OO~~~~~~N~NONNNN~~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
'"
....
OS
e 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
= ~--------------~~-~~-~~-~~~----------~-~-----
~ 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
------~-------~~~--~-~~--~~------~-----------
~ ---------------------------------------------
~. MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
~ 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
d ~~~~~~~~~$~~~~~8b~~~~~~~~~~~g~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
5 ~NO~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~OONOONN~~~~~~~~~~~N
~ NMMOONM-~~~~~-O~oooo~~-~ ~~N - - -- -
~ OO~ ~_~_ _00 _N _~ ~
-< N"~" ('1)"
~ ~ :;j ~ 1
0\ I 1 ] ,g ] ~ M N '';:; ,_ 0 rn 0
~ _ r--- I :55 +-> p.,. 0.(".1 p" 1 ~ ~ ~ fri M .s ..c: 0 I I oU Z I ~ ~
~ ~ ~ 00 J~ fri r:g u = ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I 0\ ~ ~ rn q:: ~ ~ I ~ ~ .S ~ ~ g ~ ~ :::: 1
o~_oU~~OOI~~~-~~~1 ~O\~NO\~~~~~O_~~oo~~~~~~OONO\~-M~~
~~~~ I ~~~ I I ~ 1 - I N ~~f6-~ E;~ I I I ~~G I ~.q-~ 5 5 5~****~**0\
~ _ _ 1 ~ N 0\ N .€ lr) ~ - gg ~ $ ~ 0 0\ ~ ?; "'0 "'0 oU 0 C\ In ~ N N gg lr) ~ _ .~ .~.~ oU 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 ~ -.
~~~O\N-_-U~~Eoo_o~~O\_~~~.~~-OON-~~N~~oooooo'~'~'~'~'~'~'~'~N ~
~~ ooO\~~M __roM+->M~IN ~~ooooo~_~~~_~~I I loornoornrnoornrn_ ~
~~~O\r---,.s::::>N 100-~~ONN-~'O 1 1~~O~~COl()~~ 000\0 II I I I I I~
~__~N.~~~~NN~N~N-OO~~~~~OONN~~~~N~~~O\O\O-(".1M.q-l()~~~~ ~
~~~_~H"'O~~~~5~>~~~~~~~~~---~~Z~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~
~~~_*~~~M~~~*~~~M~"'OSH~O~~~~~~~~~~ooooooooooo~ _
~~~~=~~o~~~g~~~~~~g~~~~~=~-dge~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~'d I
'O"'O"'Os~oU"'O__=~e~>=~N~~~~_-.9.g00~U$O~~NO_-------_o 2
~~~._~ 00 o_o~*~ ~a ~_+-> ~o~_~__~~NO\~_M~+->
01 01 01 d en ~ ~ ::;! ::;!..c:i ..c:i t:..c:i o..c:i ./:1 ... C/J Po a:l ~"" .el .el ~ fi' ~ Ii P:: "0 >>"" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" "" g ~
= 6h 5b Ei/n oU ~ f;) p a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ Z S ~ N ~ 5 ~ ~ ~ 5 -g:g ~ 'E"'O ~ 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 ~ 2:
o ._ ._._ e.b ;::l - 'u- 'u- a a". a Uo a '" ~ ~ Uo '" '" p:l .!O .-.- ;::l UO ..c:i ;.;:: .S :z:0 2 ,~ .!O .!O .!O .!O .!O .!o .!o .b .b .0: .!o ~ --
~ tZJ rn CZl ..... ~ 00 _ ~ ~ p- ~ ~ I-) (""'""'"'-'--I ~ _ ~ rn ~ ~ CZl rn jooI..( P-t ....... ~ CZl CZl CZl CZl rn rn rn CZl rn rn CZl ~ M
Col 111~IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII~1111111111111 I III1I11 S
oE: O\_~ I ~MO_l/)l/)~Noo~O\NNO\O\MN ~oooC'\~oo~oot-lr)-.:t~O\O~(".1M-.:tIn~r---t-oo ~
~ ~~~~~~gg~~~~~~~~~~~~frifri=~~8~~~~~~8g~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~
~ ___O\~M~_____M_M~_O\~~O\QO_MOC'\~_~O~~OOOOOOOOOOO~
~ oOOoot-t-OOMMOO~~OO~M~t-O\O\UOO~t-M~~~l/)l/)-.:t-.:toooooOOOOOOM ~
~ NNN~NNNNNNNNNNNN(".1N-NN MNNNNNNNNNNMMMMMMMMMMMN 0
k
~
'i1
"
D
o
o ~
Z ~
~ 0
o~ U
~ ~
'"
"
~
il<
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NNNNMNNNNNNMNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
- ~~~------------------------------------------
,. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
~ M~MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
~~~~~~~~~~O~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
OOOOOOOOOO~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
.. OOOOOOOOOO~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
NNNNNNNNNN~NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
~ 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~ oooOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
= OOOOOOOOOOOO~~~~~~~~~~~~~~OOO~~OO~O~~~~~O~~OO
Z ~~~~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~oo~~~~~~~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~9~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~00~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~00~~~~~~~
~ oooooooooo~~ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-------~-~---~....-(-
~ OOOOOOOOOONNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO~~OOOOOOO
<I.l
....
OS
e 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
- ~-~----~----~~~-~-------~-~-....-(~---------~---~~
~ 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
g ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
~ ---~~----------~-~--------~----~--~~-~~----~....-(
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~. ~~~~mmmmMMM~~MMMMMM~MMMMMMMMM~~MMM~~~M~MM~~M~
~ 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
d ~b~~~~~~~~~~~b~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~gg~~~~~~$
= .............................................
o NOO~OO~N~~N~~-O~~-~MOON~~~O~OOOOOOOO__OM~NM~~O~~~MOO~
~ -MM --N ~N~~~NMM'--NNNNN~N_ M~~OM_M~~~~ ~~
_ NM MOO ~ NM'- ~_M
< ~ ~ ~
- -
1<1 ..:, El ,:, i5 i5
I~~~~~ 8&IM8'~~~~~~,~81 ~~ $~< ~U~~~<~N._I~1
~ i9 Cd ~ ~ 00 ~"E I a;; ~ I M ~ -.::r ~ 00 ~ 00 ~ ~ 0 gg V N ~ - 0 I ~ 0 I ~ ~ ~i2 S 8 I ....-( .....:I _ (3 ~
~~= ~ o~ ~N~O-NNN~N~~_.~~~~_~~MM'~~_OOM-~ 0 ~
~OOIO~~MZ~~~~~~~o~~~~~~~~~N~~~~~OO~~~~~~~~~~NI~
M I ~o:,N:;oo I ~~~~t;;~_~NN__~-~~ I _-I:'I:'--O____~~N I ~ I I ~~N~[e~f::
N~~~~~~~~_~~N_~___~N~~_~~~NNM~o~~_~~~~~~__~~NN ~
--OOOM~~~~- ~N--m~~~~~-~~uoo8 -- ~N~U~~_~N_~~_~_
~ ~ ~ ~ ti gp~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~;j dJ ~ ~ ~ ~:~ ac! ~ ~ E;::; ~ ~~n~ ~ ~:si ~ ~ ~ d B ~:si ~ ~~.E ~!J ~
- N -- ~ "rii J-i .- to 1--1 ~ ~ ~ - .- "'C ClJ t=l ~..c ""0 - ._ .~ - &i ::t:: $-j - ............ - ~ ~ 1ZI OJ) ~ 0
~-.;4~g.~-il<:Z;~6ac!~ac!~~~~~Oe~-~~....:i....:i~~ac!~~ac!_ac!--i~.;4~~~~ ..
~a- o~~~ H~;"'''"O'-'O''"O -lZIU'-NlUH~ .....:It-i-(H ~;"'~Hl.(")~ I--It-iC-tO -
~1ilil<1il~~-1il~~ u"oo".;4.;4.;4 ~&l o""""1il;g.;40"~-"1il"""""~'O~0ll~il<~ -
e~u~~ ~~oe8b~~~~~~~~=g~t=l~~~.g~~~o~~~~lU~o~~~u~.~ I
U " Ollli:l ....:i ~ ~ . --g U -"'S SonS:9:9:9 on '" IN'''' on .15 q '0 . ~ il< on S:Z; .~ S -" S gj ;::l :z; ~ &l <=: bl ~ ~ ~
=:E ~"'g.- ~ 5 v '-'0 ~ Q:l ....-( Q:l ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ - ~ ro ~ ~ .C "'C U - ~ .s ~ ,CQ +:J ~ 0 o.s ~ 0 u 0
J~1<1~~~~~::;aJ~El~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~&lN~~~~~I~~~~i~B~1ilJ ~
= '0 <=: ~~ 0 !J'~ ~":'O", El5151515151515151515151~ 51-::::"0 I:: 5151'0';; 51<=: 51<=i El'O;::l o-Eh.o'O Q :::
o ;.;:: ;::l .$l 0 u~ u~ k .$ 0;';:: "" UO .- .- .- .- .- .- .- .- .- .- .- .- .- 0 '> .. ".-._ ~ k._ ..._ 3 ;::l ~ 0 J;:J._ ;::l " ." -.
~ ~OOt-i-( ~~~~~ ~~~oo~OOOOOOOOOO~~OO-?W~~~~~oo~~~~~Uoo~ooU~ ~
Col I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I e
.5 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~8!~~~=8~$~~$~~~~~~~~~8~~ l
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~b~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~
~ M~M~~~~~~~~oo~~~~ooooOO~~~~~~~I:'~OOO~~~~~M~~I:'~l.(")~~~ 0
~ NNNNN-----NNNNNNNNNNNNN-NNNNNNNNNN_NNNN_NN__N 0
P::
-'i:l
"
o
il
o ~
Z ~
8 0
- U
o ,
~ ~
r--
~
p,
o 0 0 0 0
~~ z z z z Z
l:"'-- t'--'. .. .... ..
N~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Q,) 0'\0\....... _ .-........ .......
c:J ~~.g ~ .g.g .g
== II !:l ~ $:I C Q
~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ 00 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~~ U U U U U
~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~~ ~OO ~~ ~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~~O~~OO~O~~~~
00 ..__ ..0 ..0 ..00000 ..----NOONN-N---O
00 ~OO tlN ~O ~_____ ~____O__OO_O___N
~ NN O~M Q~ ON U~MMMM 0_______________
~ ~~ C~~ QN C~ C~~~~~ C~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
_ I I l1) I I (!) I lU I d.l 1 I 111 lU I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I
S gg g.gg g.g g.g g.ggggg g.ggggggggggggggg
= 00 a.>_N lUO U~ UOM~MO a.> 00 00 00 00 00_00 0000 00 00 00 00 0000
Z ~~ 000000 000 OOM OO~~~~~ 00000000000000000000000000000000
~~ ~~ ~~~ ~9 ~~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ __ 000 0_ 0_ 000000 0000000000000000
c:J 00 ~OO ~O ~O ~MMMMM ~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
< 88 u~~ u8 u8 UNNNNN u~GG~G~GGGGGGGGG
~
.....
'"
9 00 00 0 0 00000 000000000000000
= -- -- - - ----- ---------------
00 00 0 0 00000 000000000000000
~El ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~ NN NN N N NNNNN NNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
~ -- -- - - ----- ---------------
~ -- -- - - ---~- ~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~
^. MM M~ M M MMMMM MMMmM~MMMMMMMMM
~ 00 00 0 0 00000 000000000000000
d g~~ ~~~ gg ~~ ~~~gg~ ~~~~~~~~~~~8~~~
= ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
o ~~~ MM~ 00 00 O~N~~OO _o~_o~~~~~_~~~~
El ~N ~NOO 00 ~~ -~~~NM ~~M-~OO~ mM N~m
~ ~~o NN __ O~~~NN I _
-< ~. "f M N....
...
".~
ta '
~M 00 en
d.>~ $-0 I-<
(I]~ ~~
ag) ~~ s ~
~~ ~~ g ~
~ 53 0(30(3 H ~~ 8
-(;j 1ZI 1ZI r~ u"i) d.> ~ ,.:..;
0>0 ,,~ ~ ~~ 0 _
~ 0 .~ .~ ~ CIl ~ ~ ~ ~ \0 ~ I
" Z ~ ~ .~ .~ .:a Q 00"' ~ ~ 0 * 0
~ d.>d.> -00 ~~ I-< -~ N
~ .s @rn rn ~ 0 'P..Ci) .s ~& 0 j * 00 'S 8
~~ a"g""g afr ~o ~CI:I~t;d.>S:: 's gf ::> S
= '" ~ .. Q ::::::::l .. ;> Q .. Q b .. ,J:j t ::::3 e ..... .. ::>':8 p.. ~ _
.S .9 --;;j ~~~O3 ~~O3 00:03 ~;;::-g"'E:::ClO3 g.... ,;0 '" U'" <H M
.... I-'-l ~ en +-> d.>"""+-> ao+-> oO!:Q~ ~+-> ~ a - I-< I-<
~ I I ~ ::t 0 0 ~ () ~ ~ U U ~ U "" rT"I ""0 > ~ "' ~ "d oo.~ 00 B I-t ~ a e
.,.. 00 ("""""" x - - l:""'""' a (""'"'" l:""'""' l-'-l d.> l-'-l ~ l:""'""' -(I] 1ZI rn C'Il d.> I-< ~ I-< ..- 0 ..... ......
~ ~ ~ ~ @ ~ ~ ~ ~ ] ~ ~ ~ 13 ~ '8 ] .~ jg 'a ~ ~ gf gf ~ ~ ~ rJ) 0 a ~ ~ ~ .~ ~ e ~ ~
~ 8~~ o~~] 00] 81-<] ofrfrfrfrfr] O~~~d.>~~~~a~e~~~g ~
~ NNU u~~u u~u UE-<U u~~~~~u U~~>~~>~~~~>O~~~E-< 0
....
p,
71
"
d.> ..... a ...c:l
';j !l ~ U '" U
Cl) ~ ~ d Q t
Zo a ~ 0 i:; ~ ::;
8 888 8 ~
~ i-: i-: i-.: i-:o:::t'_t()\OO i-:Nt()N\OO_N~t'--t'--OONt'--\OO a
'S ~~~ ~ ~ ~N~_N~ ~ONMM\OONMMMMO~OO~ U
i> QNN Q Q~ Qbb~~~ Q~eg~$~~~~~:G:G~~~~ I
= >d.>:V:::V:: >" >"~ >d.>V)l()~V)~ >O)NNNNNNNNNNNNNMM ~
~ l-l-l_ ~ ----- \0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0\0 ~
00
"
fJ'
>'<
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z z z z z z z z
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Q) d.l Q) Q) Q) l!) Q) Q)
~ - - - - - - - -
u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ U U U U U U U U
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
O~ ~~ ~~ ~o ~o ~-~ ~~~ ~~~~~ ~~
g:::: 4):::: di~ d)~ o;~ di~~ di~8 d)g~g~ Q;~
:r...,.....c,.....c 0_ 0.- 0.- ON OMo::::r 0__ O("t')(f')('f1('i') Ol()
~ ~~ 5~ 5~ 5~ 5~ 5~~ 5~~ 5~~~~ 5~
6 00 ;::::sO ::;0 ;::::sa ;::::sO :::saa ;::::soa ;::::socco ;:sO
00 C"'O cr'("'f') 0"'0 0<0 0'00 0'00 0-0000 0"'0
= NOO 4)00 Q)Q\ 0.>00 0.>0 Q)OM Q)-- d.l('f)M("I")l() d.l7
Z ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~g~ oo~~ ~~~~~ oo~
.... II ...!:&. ~l ~, ,.1{, ~ll ~II ~1111 ~I
C..J _0 00 0_ Uo 00 0__ 000 0,000_ 00
C..J 88 ~8 ~8 ]8 ~~ ~88 ]88 ~~~~8 ]~
~ o~ u~ Uo U~ UN Uoo U~~ U~~~o UN
"
....
OS
9 00 0 0 0 0 00 00 0000 0
= -- - - .- - -- -- ---- .-
~ 00 0 0 0 0 00 00 0000 0
6 ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~ ~
""-- NN N N N N NN NN C"lNNN N
~ -- ,......( - .- - -- -- ---- -
~ ~~ - - - - -- -- ---- -
^. MM M M M M MM MM ('1")("t')('1")M M
~ 00 0 0 0 0 00 00 0000 0
d ~~~ ~~ $$ ~~ 88 ~8~ ~~~ ggg~~ ~
= ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
O Nl()~ 00 -- -- NN ('1")l()OO oooo~ MMMOO\ N
6 M o:::t l()l() ~~ l()l() o:::to:::t NNO\ __('1") NNNMO\ o:::t
If) -- 0'0'\ --N --- M
< M~ ~
"'
U
",~o
~ ~d.l-
cd 0 Q) 0
~ oo~~
~ ~o~
~ ~ E~~ <Zl8~ ~
~ ,,"'0.0. ~Np:: ~
~ w ~~~ ~-~ M
~ ~ Q -s~ ~ 0
() ~ '0 - a a .0 '.;j A-c '"0'-
~ e d ~~~ _u~" g-
~o t Cd r-...c..c __ cJ13.E~o c.S I
~"~ ~ ~ f~ .g~~ g~M ~"'&~~z':g ~ 8
~.q- ~ p.. S:::iU ~CI)cn _\J)(/) ~d)8t'1) b.O N
o ::tt: d S .g ~ c.;..... 0 0 D ~ ~ d) ~ 0 ~ b.O (J:l .S ~
= ~.~ .. i;o;j .. 0" ~ t .. 0 - - .. iU bl) OJ) .. ..c r-. ~ CI.l S .. "O..c .......
~ i ~8i ~i u~i ~'a] ~gg3 ~~~i ~~~~'~i ~~o ~o
1'""1_ 0 en 0 \oJ 0 ....... ::=' 0 0 0 C!.) 0 ..... 0 _ \1.1. t'I) ~ "" 0 ...
~ ~D~ 'I~~ ~~ a~~ IU~ g~~~ g~~~ ~~~8~~ ~U ~
~ a&~ ~~ 8~~ s:::~~ j~~ aee~ 8~~~ ~CI)~o~~ ~8 ~
~~t'I) iU iU ..ct'l)iU 0('1) ~~~t'I) (J:l~~d) ~ __~iU 0
~ "O~ i~ ~~~ ,,-~ ,,~~ """~ -oo~ U~oo",~ !o ~
~ O~U u>,<u o~u oou O~U o~~u O~~U ~>'<NN>'<U ~<Zl g
...
>'<
{j
'" 0 ::s ]
.S .- t'I) .0 B ~ u
e 0 0 bl} j +..> ~ ~
o so] jag ~~~~~ ~ ~
z 8~ ~ " " " - u~~~~ ~ 0.
~ 0 0 0 0 OooN ~~~~~ ~ s
~ _~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~~ ~~~~~ ~ 0
... \01:"'-- o~ 000 ON 00\ 0 Or---oo or:---t"--t'-t- 0 U
~ ~N ]0 ]~ ]~ ]~] ]~~ ]8888 ] I
= "'''' >"0 >"- >"~ >"~ >" >"-- >"0000 >" ~
~ \D\D ....... N ~ ~ 00 1--11--1__ ~
0\
"
~
r:>-.
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z z z z z z z z
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ <l) <l) Q) <l) <l) <l) <l)
4.) ........ .............. ....... ....... ........ ...... ......
r.j ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
!:l '" '" '" '" '" '" '" ,\1
i: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '"'
~ II: II: II: II: II: II: II: II:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ 0...... N M ~ ~ ~
~M ~~ ~~~~~ ~OOO ~~~ ~~ ~M ~O~
d)~ d)::: Q);::~::::;:: Q)~~~ U~~ d)g a;~ d)g;3
.... Oll") 0_ u____ u___ 0__ OM ()V) 0__
<U ~V) \:::l1.O t:l \0\0 \.O\D l:::l\O\O\O s::l\O\D s::l\D Qt() \:::l\D1"Q
,.Q <l) I 0) I d.> I I I I Q) I I I <l) I I d.l I cl) I (\) I I
e ~g g.g g.g g g g g.~ ~ g g.g g g.~ g.g g.g g
= Q)"'d" 11)00 d.lOOOOOOOO (1)0'\0\('1') QJNN .uN lU"d'" ll.JOO_
Z ~"'d" 0000 0000000000 00--('1") OONN 00- OO"d'" 000000
.... ~~ ~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~ ~~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~
_, {.) 0 (.) 0 000 0 0 I:) ...... ........ ........ (.) _ .- 0........ (.) 0 () 0 0
~ <U("f') 11)0 LUOOOO tUOOO 000 ll)O a>C"f) (1)00
~ ~- ~- ~---- ~--- ~-- ~- ~- ~--
~ UN U~ U~~~~ UOOO UOO Uo UN U~~
..
....
o;l
~ 0 0 0000 000 00 0 0 00
- - ...... ---- --- -- - - --
~ 0 0 0000 000 00 0 0 00
"8 ~ ~ ~~~~ ~~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~
~ N N NNNN NNN NN N N NN
~ ...... ........ ---- --- -- ........ ........ --
~ ~ ~ ---- --- -- - - --
~. M M MMMM MMM MM M M MM
~ 0 0 0000 000 00 0 0 00
d ~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~ ggg gg ~~ ~~
= . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ON NN NN ~ooooV)V) Nt()C'\N 000 V)lI") NN t()\D
El "d'" "'d""d'" V) V) "'d"1"Q1"O~M NMC'\- 000 MM "d"'~ ~~
~~ I ~~ I-ON ~~N
...... . . .
""'l,j -- -
2 ~ ~
'" 0. '"
'S 0. v.l B~ ~
"C oU S 00 bJ) "C Gf.) _ ....-l
g S UO .S '" bJl g "U ~
~ 0. NN = R~ d ~ ~ ~ '
2 ~N ~ t--t--~ ~ ~~ ~ 2 I ~ 0
~ 0'['- ~; ; :36 >. e ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8
g~ ~~ r:>-. .;::.;::.... aU" "f-< f-< gp liJ,,:=: ~
tl ." -;l "" ~ '" R "" 0. ~ liJ :l .,. :!l bJl .- II: liJ 8: ~
= . . ~"'" .. -l'l.;:: .. !'< >-i >-i.~ .. s ~" ,.._ .. 0 t::: .. " .. .R .. ,. - ~
o - bJ)~~ ~~~ ~~~~~~ 0 ~-- dO~ ~- u_ v.l~- ~
._ d ,.... d ro oU ......... ro 0._ ~ ~......... ~ U "C c. m ~ ~ ro ^ ro ro ro -oU "0 Gf.) ("f')
~ 0 ~oo R~O ~"COO~O ~c.o Gf.)~O ~o 00 ~~ 0
.S- f-< ~ U f-< i3 tl f-< :>.. u~ 'e. 'e. tl f-< OJ 2 II: 05 f-< ,.; ~ 6i' f-< .fl S f-< ~ U f-< ..9 ..... .ff ';::
~ ~ ".... ~ ~ 0 tH ~ ~.~. ~. tH ~ l:::: fo"'"( ~ 1--'-4 - S ~ ~'" 0 ~ - ~ v 'd i-I-t ..0 v.l
~ u a B u .!:l CIl u B 01) 0) lI) U B d d u ~:a ~ u d "C u ~ B '0 ~ d ~
~ ] ~g] ~i] gtlii~] ~~~~] ~J~] ]a] ~g] e~j ~
~ U f-<~U ~r:>-.U ~U~~r:>-.U ~r:>-.~~U ~'"'~U ~~u ~~u ~~r:>-. 0
~
r:>-.
<'1
"
~ .s. t) e
o ~ ~ d("f')O ..0 ~ 0
tl $.g ",t--~.... j" OJ il
o ~ > ~ B::!:~::: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
z ~ d roOO~~ ~....-l....-l....-l ~ .!:l_ _ ~ ~
~ ~ ~O\OOON ~I~~ ~ ~,- ~ ~ S
Q.l .. .. "("I')~N....-l .. 00" ..\0.. .. 0
.Y t) ~ t)~~~S t) U t)("f')_ t)~ t) ~~~ u
o "C "Co "CNNNN ~ ~ "Coo~ "C....-l "C "COO ("I') I
5 5 5.-1 ij("l')("f1....-l....-l 5 ZZ 500 5N 5 5\0['- P-i
~ > >~ >~~~~ > ~~ >~~ >8 > >:::::: ~
o
......
~
~
o 0 0 0
z z z Z
-i:i ..c:i -i:i .ij
QJ ll.) QJ QJ
cu - ............ ......
u ~ ~ ~ ~
l:l 0: 0: 0: 0:
.... r.il r.il r.il r.il
~ p:: p:: p:: p::
~:.J :.J:.J :.J
r--... 00 0\ 0
~~~~o ~oooo~~oooooo~~oooo ~oooo ~~~ ~o
.-lOOO N ..000000 N N N N N N 0 0 N N 0 0 .. 0 0 0 0 .. NO.. 0
~ ~8~~8 8~~~~888888888888~~ B~~~~ 8~8 8~
~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~ ~~
_ I I I I I t1) I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I 1IJ I I I I QJ I I Q) I
EI 00000 ~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO ~OOOO ~oo ~o
00000 ~oaooooooOOOOOOOOM.-l ~OONm ~NO ~o
= OO..-l..-l_N QJO_O__N_OO~O_O_N~OO~O\ QJ_~O\O\ Q)~~ 1lJ_
Z 00 00 0000 N ~~~~~OOOOMOO~~M~OOOOMOO-- OOOON-- 00-- WO\
~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~ ~~
u 0000...... uoooooo......o____oo_o__ uo___ u__ uo
u 88888 ~~~~~8~8888888~8888 ~8888 ~88 ~~
< ~~~~o UNNNN~~O~OOoo~~o~oo u~ooo Uoo UN
.,
....
'"
e 00000 000000000000000000 0000 00 0
- ----- ------------------ ---- -- -
~ 00000 000000000000000000 0000 00 0
"e ~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~ ~~ ~
~ NNNNN NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN NNNN NN N
~ ----- ------------------ ---- -- -
= ----- ------------------ ---- -~ ~
A. ~~~~~ MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM MMMM MM M
~ 00000 000000000000000000 0000 00 0
d ~~~~~b ~G~G~~~~~~~~~~~G~~~ b~~~~ ~~~ g
= ...... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
O ONOO-~ ~~~~M~NMM~-~-M--~OO~ M~OO~~ OO~~ N
~ -N--N~ NNNNN~~NN~~~N~NN~~M ~M~O~ ~-~
_ _ _ _ 0-. N_NI..O _\O~
-<
!J
~
p
.@
]]]] ~ ~
5555 ~ u ~
P'i P'i P'i P'i -s -;:;,:..;
u'O)UO) 0... ~.Q-
~~~~ .13 C)~,
0000 d)d)ll)d) 08 !3~ 0
f-< f-< f-< f-< bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ bIJ_ _ gj gj gj gj ..s k ,.c;u.2 8
'" k k k k oj 0: 0: d ~ oj oj 0: 0: 0: 0: 0: '" '" " " " " " 0 ~~,
.", '" '" '" ",... .- .- .... .......-.-.-.-.- - - , , , , 0: "" 0: 8 "
k ~ "'~~~~gggg gggggggo:o: ......--- 0 '" ~
= 0 ;=: .. 8 ~~ _~ ~Y ~I.,J d) lI.) lI.) (l) ll) ll) (1) lI.) (1) d) d) C!J ll) 0 .. ~ 5) ~ as ., '.;':j c.. s.., d -
S u",,~~ _~~~~_..............................--_......--P'iP'i~ _----~ C)o ~ ~~ -
~ d~~o...~ eo...o...o...AUUUUUUUUUUUU--~ roo...o...o...A_ 08 ~ ~~. 8
.~ ~ .~ ~ ~ bl ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 ~ ~ ~ .~ 8 8 8 8 ~ g ~ k ~ j s ~
u d)dUUuO ~____~~~~~~~~~~~~s..,s..,o u~~~~o U (1)0 d)8 .~
~ ~B ~d) ~~~~~,_,_,_,_._,~.~.~,~,~,_,_OOll.) B8BBu >~dd) ~8 -
~ ",~~~~,.c; ~====O:O:O:O:O:=QO:O:O:O:O:..s..s,.c; ~~~~~,.c; O~o,.c; 40 ~
_ ~r.il~~~u ~oooo~~~~~~~~~~~~~~u ~~~~~u ~......f-<U ~U g
k
~
-t3
"
.~ s ~ e_~ 8 ~ ~
o ~~~Oo~~~~~I"QI"Q~~~~~~oo U > ~ ~
Z "'Q~~O\~MMMMMMI"QI"QI"Q\D\O\O'-D\O ~ 0 s.., ~
~~~NN~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~N ~oooo ~ 13
~ ..l.()I.()OOOOMMMMMM~~~~~~~~ ..\0\0\00\ ..0000 .. 0
U M\D\DOOOO~~~~~~oooooooooooooooo s..,oooo s..,0\~ M
.~ OOO\-I"Q~ ~NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN ~~~~~ ~NN ~ U
> ~~~~~ =~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ d~~~~ ~~~ d I
= _____ ~oooo-------------- ~MMMM ~\o1"Q ~ ~
~ ----- ~------------------ ~I.()I.()I.()I.() ~~~ ~ ~
-
-
"
~
p..
000000000
Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ 0 tl V tl tl tl tl
~ - - - - - - - - -
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
= ~ ~ J::" !:l r:l r:l r:l !:l I=l
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ::r: ::r: ::r: ::r: ::r: ::r: ::r: ::r: ::r:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ M ~ ~ ~ ~ 00 ~
~M ~~ ~O ~O ~~ ~~ ~OOO ~~ ~M
u~ 08 o~ ~~ o~ 08 o~~~ o~ u~
~ O~ OM O~ O~ 0_ OM 0___ 0_ O~
~ r:ll.() r:l\O r:l\O Q\O r:l\D l:::!\O =\0\0\0 1=l\O 01.()
_ d) I d) I iU I <I) I d) I d) I 11) I I I l!.l I iU I
e &8 &8 &8 &8 &8 &8 &~~~ &8 &8
= d}V UM (1)00 UM 000 u- d)~~~ 0_ d)~
~ OOv OO~ 0000 00- 0000 0000 00--- OOM OOv
~.... ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~ ~~ ~~
~, 00 00 00 0_ 00 00 0___ 0_ 00
Y tlM tlM 00 d)O 00 Va 0000 00 UM
~ ~- ~- ~- ~- ~- ~- ~--- ~- ~-
~ UN UN U~ Uo U~ U~ UOOO Uo UN
.,
....
Ol
e 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 0
- - - - - - - --- - -
~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 0
d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~
~ N N N N N N NNN N N
~ - - - - - - --- - -
~ - - - - - - --- - -
~. M M M M M M MMM M M
~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 0
~ g ~~ gg ~~ gg ~~ gg ~~~8 ~~ ~
= . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ON NN 00 00 I.() I.() I.() I.() 0000 MI.()OOOO NN N
~ VV \0\0 MM \0\0 I.() I.() ~~ -NOON ~~ v
MM VV __ -- N--I.() I.() I.()
v"-.::r"
.~
~ ~ ~
O~ ~ 8
'<-< =.- !:: ..
] B Z o~ -.:0 ~] ::::
~ u ;2l ,," ...c::U '" <S'
" .E '<-< 130 fr ~Ol "'" 0
p::: ~ ~ .'So. 8b\ dJO ~ tz:: 8
gp ..E 5 t):E rn- ~f-l 0 CO CO N
~.- ooU d~ ~~ .2: ~o o~~ .8~ .S ~
= . . ~ ~ .. ._ 1; .. ~...... .. "'"""" d) .. +->.- .. "'"""" - .. ('1') ~ 0) .. (""!._ .. 1-0 ..d _
o Ol N - Ol b Ol -~ Ol '" "" Ol gj = - '" 0 Ol '" - "'Ol ." - Ol " aJ -
~ +-> _ ~ +-> a c}3 +-> 'S ~ +-> ~ d +-> - 0 .s t:: N +-> I .~.~ +-> ::;s ~ +-> ~ 0 $Q
o .... 0 0 -0 01=<0 0.... 0 '"0 0 - a '-"
.9< E-< tl U E-< ~ S E-< $ a E-< .~ ~ E-< ~ t; E-< 11 ~ E-< 0 "il bl bl E-< il a ~ ~ U ';::
~ ~ ]8~ ~~~ ~u~ ao~ ~~~ Ee~ i~~~~ 5~~ s8 ~
~ e 8~a j~a ~~a ~~a E~~ ~~a ~~~~e ~~a ~~ g
P::
~
8 ~ ;:j .S 0 ~
I j ~ ~ ~ ~ i l ); ~
~ " a -0 0 .g 1;; ..., ,i'J ,~ g,
tl ~ ::r: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ s
3 i-: i-: i-: i-: i-:\D i-: i-:OONN i-:oo::t- i-: 0
.. 0 0 o~ 000 o~ 0 O~N~ 00 0 U
Q "d "d '"O"=:t' '"00 '"O~ "'d0\ "'d0'l('1')~ '"0\0 ""C I
> 5 5 50'\ 5~ 5tn 5~ 5~oo::t-~ 51:- 5 Poi
~ > > >~ >~ >~ >~ >~~~ >~ > ~
N
-
"
~
P<
0 0 0 0 0
0 0
Z Z Z Z Z
Z Z
-i:i -i:i -i:i -i:i -i:i
-i:i -i:i
" " " " "
" "
" ::g ::g ::g ::g ::g
::g ::g
c.l
= &l " &l " &l
&l "
" ~ ~
~
...
~ p:: p:: p:: p:: p::
~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U
-<:
S5t-\.D - fClo ~o \600 :2",
~oooooooo
",,,,
..~- ..- ..N ..- ..NN ..0 "NNNNNNNN
... "NN ,,- ,,'" ,,0 ,,00 ,,0
U_OO_Oo__
u__ u_ UO U'" u__ U'" u________
" "NN "'" "'" "'" ""'''' "'"
~\o\oI"QI.O\D\O\.D\O
,.Q " , , " . " , " . " , . " ,
OU I I I I I I , I
8 ",00 &8 ",0 ",0 ",00 ",0 ~OOOOOOOO
0'00 0'0 0'0 0'00 0'0 0"- 0 0 .-I
0 0 00 ('f')
= ,,00 ,,00 ,,0\ ,,0 " '" '" "'"
ll.)0\C'lOO'\O-.::t'0\0\
Z 0000 0000 mOO 00'" OO-N 00.... W_('f')\f)_-.::t''''
''__
".00 ".'1 .,.'1 ".'1 .,......... .,.'1
~o:::t'-.::t''<;j-<<;;f-<<:jo''<:t''tt'<:j-
.... . , . , I I I I
I I I I
u__ uo Uo U_ U__ uo 0____00__
c.l "00 "0 llo "0 "00 "'"
~OOOOMMOO
c.l 088 ""- ""- ""-- ""- u--------
< u'" ufCl Uo Uoo UN
OOOONNOO
"
....
,.
~ 00 0 0 0 00
0 00000000
.... -- - - - --
- -------.....
= 00 0 0 0 00
0 00000000
" ~~ ~ ~ ~ NN
~ ~~~~~~~~
S NN N N NN
N
>. -- - - - --
- ......--............---
,. -- - - - --
- --------
~ '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
'" ("l')("f')('f')("f')("I')MMM
00 0 0 0 00
0 00000000
.... 0 00\0\ 0\ 0\ 00 00
N.... '" 00 _("f') \f)......_\f) NOO\O
= '" r-- '" '" '" '" ~~ 00 0\ 00
r-- 00 0\0\00\00\1.000\0
= N oO~~ r---:r..: '" '" dd
...oMO dd ddN...odoO...o~r..:
0 .... N....r-- 00 00 '" '" --
-N '" '" ("f')N__\DM"","N~
8 -.::rt----n r--r-- NN
-- N
< -
a
0
-u
00
~ ~
.~
i:i1
....
<2il~~ ","" '" '"
<S '"
.~ < "
" .... "" '?
d ..c:""
" '" -
;.::l'S'S .E .- "" 1:1 1:1
u 2 -
01"" Us ....~~
S >Q ,
.... .... oj' .s 0 '" 0
0
gP<P< " 5lU g-D ~ a a ~~
_.0 -
'~a~ ~ ~~ .:: .gUU
'8 2 0
""~ " P< u ~
Z~....l .. '" s:-;:: .. ~88 .. '" "
a CIl CIl r:n -
= -a :::E'~ .. ~~ .. 1d fJ .. ~ ~ ,g .~ d8..!l
.. -
.51 E88] CIlo.'Cd 01 0001 IOOca
.- "" "" -a "" "" 01 -
~ ~~o ~ bOo NN _ :::Eo~
'"
.... 0000 - ~o .2 ~ ~~ ma"" """olilo
0
!:l. ONN~ 0l"'E-< O.S E-< '-.S E-< .g ,.,E-< ~.EP::bJ abJ:::Ep::E-<
~
.;::: .S""",, .,. ~oo.,. "~". 0<3.,. -
.,. ~='::S~ oJa7j 2uou$.6E.2bl)73 '"
c.l u H U <.) 0 ll) d 0 5h 0\ U _f/:l >. U ;.::l
'" al>li~
" " " a a " E .f!lll ",0 " " u " S u " ll.) ~.~ .;!3 ~ a'a
0 S ~ 4-<
"" tl:::E:::EO "0"" 3~o :::E~~O . ~""
~ U :.::l:::Eu ....lNU E-< U :::EP:::::E:::E>QP::P<~....lU
0
8
P<
.,.
u
"
~ "' b "1
" '" 0
""
~ U ""
-5 a I
0 ~ ~
~ u E '"
'" ~
.S~~ "
1d
~- 0 :::E
:::E
" ~t-r---- ....l
.... 0\ 0\ .. '" ;..; ;..; ;..;
;..; ;..; 0
c.l ....-
'S 0",,,, 0.... 0", ON 0
0 .g('f')_OOOO_\f)\O-q- U
"""'''' "".... ""0\ ""r-- ""
"" Q\f)\o_Or:-NlOO ,
.s " , , 50 5'" 50 "
5 11)--tnO\OO\No::::!"
"....l....l "0000 ~
>>Q>Q >:5 >~ >[ri >NN >
>NN\Ot-ooooC'f')\"Q
0000000000000\0"1
'"
~
"
~
P<
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
z z z z z z z z z
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
oU d) (l) d) 0 Q.) Q) iU iU
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
e ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ 00 ~ 0 ~ N M ~ ~
~OO~ ~O ~OO ~O ~O ~~ ~~ ~~OO ~O
d)~~~ Q.i~ d)~~ Q.i~ o;~ Q.i~ UV1 d)~N (l)~
~ UNN~ u~ 0__ u...... 0_ O~ O~ 0__ 0_
~ ~\D\O"""" ~\D ~"D\D ~\D $:1\0 ~l() $:Il() $:INN $:l\D
_ d) I I I iU I (1) I I !U I !U I Q) I iU I (1) I I Cl) I
8 &8 g g g.g ~g g &8 g.g g.g &8 &8 g g.g
= oNNO 01)0 d)NN ON (l)- d)~ OM \1)00 (l)........
Z OONNO 00\0 OONN OON WOO OO~ OO~ 0000 00........
~ ~~~q ~~ ~~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~q9 ~~
""Ej 0........_........ 0........ 0........_ U..-l (.)0 00 00 0_0 0......
y ]888 ~8 ~88 ]8 ]8 ]~ ]~ ]88 ]8
-< 0000 00 000 00 O~ ON ON Oo~ 00
~
=
~ 000 0 00 0 0 0 0 00 0
- ...................... ........ ................ ........ ........ ........ ........ ................ ........
~ 000 0 00 0 0 0 0 00 0
d ~~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~
~ NNN N NN N N N N NN N
~ ........................ ........ ................ ........ ........ ........ ........ ................ ........
~ --- - -- - - - - -- -
~. MMM M MM M M M M MM M
~ 000 0 00 0 0 0 0 00 0
d ~V)g~ 888gB gg gg ~~ gg 8gg g
= . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
O ~-~~ 00 ~~o ~~ MM NN ~~ ~~N l()
d 000000 l()l() NNlO 00 NN ~~ ~~ ~........~ M
~ l(')_O\D NN MM ........ ........
.... n n
.... ~~
:@
....
] $:I ~
~ 0 ObJ) ~
~ S d .-'.g S ~
'0-4 0 $:I u :::E .>-c'-+-> M
0. 0 o.>s::;: I Od.) 0
"'CI 0 tf) OJ);>-. CI). 0 Q) ..
~ U en ......enen rIlen <~ ~"'d ti ~ ~~.-I
+..> $-j Q) Q.) - Q) Q) <l:; Q.) H.......
! Q ~~ S~~ ~ ~~ ~ "aa <~ ,
&""" >Cl ';:ClCl 'UCl ./:15 .3 0 :B~~ f'lotao 0
I.... I:rJ I:rJ b.I) ~ 0.. Q) 0.. 0.. .- 0.. i=: c..::j '""'"" +-' H .- .- .......
ofi~~ Q).- -.-.- ~.- 00 b.I) ~ as ~~ 0
o H ~ ~ t; .g g.~ ~ u ~ U r? = a go ~ e '"=::I ~ ~
..... ,.S > ~ l-< ~ l-< l-< 0 l-< i=: ~ 0 .;:: rn Q) 0 ~ ~ ~ .......
iOo'l ~ h 0 .. ::.. Q) .. n Q) Q) .. =: Q.) .. 0 _ .. ~ .. l-< . , .. l-< .. E:l .-I
o .~~ ~ p~~ ~~~~ ~.~~ _-~ "'-~ ,,~~ Ooo~ 05 _
~ 2aaU_ ~S+-' ~asQ -a- ~.g- .~~- ~~- _.-1- bb 8
~ ~88&~ ~i~ ~ii~ li~ ~B~ ~O~ ~~~ ~~~~ ij ~
~ g~~~~ Q)o~ Q)oo~ ooo~ ~s~ Q)B~ ~=~ ~~~~ ~ ~
~ i~~~e ~~e ~~~e ~~e ~8e ~~e ~~e ~~~e ~ g
....
P<
..14
<>
~ oj OJ) "
~ ~ ~ ~ < ~ ~ ~ 0
~ p ~ ~ 0 ~ . ~ j b
Z ~ .~ Z ~ ~ '@ ~ lJ g,
::;s ::;So ~ ~ ~ ~ ::;s z a
~ ~<<~ ~.-I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~~ 0
...... OOOON o~ o~~ 0 0 0 0 OMM o~ U
o ~O"""'.-I ~~ ~~....... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~oo ~~ I
> 500~ 50 5N....... 5 5 5 5 5NN 5....... ~
~ >oo~ >::;s >~~ > > > > >~~ >~ <
""
-
"
~
>><
0 0 0 0 0
~ 0 0
Z Z Z Z Z
Z Z
oi::j oi::j oi::j oi::j
oi::j oi::j oi::j oi::j
" " " " "
" " "
., :g :g :g :g :g
:g :g :g
c.J
= " &l " &l &l
" " &l
~ P'I P'I
P'I P'I
~ ~ :r: :r: a :r:
~ :r: ~
~ ~ ~ <<: ~
~
'0 t- ~oo '" 0
- '" '"
t-o t-'" r----t()t() t()1() V) 00'" 00'"
00'" ool(')t()lt"'l
.. '" ..- ..NN Qjggggg ..0 ..-
.."" ..000
... ,,0 ,,- ,,-- ,,0 ,,-
,,'" d)"d'""d"<<:::t"
,,- ,,- ,,-- o ~ ~.-c.--l........ "'"
,,- ,,- u.............-I.--I
" "'0 "'0 "'0'0 $:1"0\.0\.0\0\0 "'0
"'0 "'0 =\0\.0\.0
,.Q " , " , " , , d) I I I I I " ,
" , " , l!.) I I I
S ;:>0 ;:>0 ;:>00 ;jOOOOO ;;>0 ;;>0
&8 ~ooo
0'0 0'0 0'-'" QiONOOO 0'0 0'0
eTO 0 N
i "0 "00 ""'''' ouN-.::t'Mo:::t'M "'"
"00 ,,- OUOM-.::t'
"'''" '" 00 "'-- rnN.-c.-co:::t'o:::t rn 00
'" 00 "'''" m\O_,......c
~"t ~"t ~"""" ~o:::tvo:::to:::t'o:::t ~"t
~"t ~"t ~o:::to:::to:::t
.... ' , I I I I I
, , ,
"0 "0 ,,-- 0.--1.--1.--100 "0
"0 "0 0_....._
c.J "'" "0 "00 "gOOOMC"f') "0
"0 "'" oUooo
< ON ""- ""-- u.-c.-c.-c.-c- ""'"
DG ON 0888
U'D Uoo OOONN U'D
"
....
=
!:l 0 0 00 00000
0 0 0 000
.... - - -- _.-c_.-c........
- - - ---
= 0 0 00 00000 0
0 0 000
., ~ ~ ~~ ~t:!~~~
~ ~ ~ t:!~t:!
S '" '" '" '" NNNNN '"
'" '" "'''''''
>> - - -- ......-c.-.--. .......
- - - ---
= -- -- -- -- ................---
-- -- -- -- -- --
~ '" '" '" '" MM("f')M('f')
'" '" '" '" '" '"
0 0 00 00000 0
0 0 000
.... 0 '" '" '" '" 00 _ '" t"--O"Il(')M"d"OO
00 "'''' 00 000
= 0 """" """" -",,," t"--vt'--t-t-"'d"
00 "'''' 00 '0,,",,"
= or; ~~ o\~ MO~ ~~~...o\QO\
tr)t,r) ~<o::f ..n..n 1.,.)"";""";
0 '" -- """" "''''''' t--'D '"
"""" '" '" "''''
S -
-- """"
<<:
"
"
I"-<
"
.9
..,
gp CI] .~
~
g .10
.~ .- S
en
Sil il 1:"0
" '"
1;1, 0 >>[iJ '" '" ,jl<<:
.9 '?
-0 .~ .~
en -
" - " OJ<<:
en
P'I '" -S'D 0._ r3:a
" en '" '" -
g.u
" " " "
d(l " 0.0.. ._ rn
.-.- .""" ,
~ '''OJ ;:> ;:> "I"-<
8 --- 0
"0 ~d(l en
0.0.0.
~E-< E-<OO ~E '" rn ~'"
U g.g.g. -
~ ~
0
10 " 0: IZI en en 0 0 .- '"
>><~ .... '" rn '" ~
~ ~ .. ~ " l!.) 0) 13.) c::l. c.. I"-< ....
_VJ tS
= ~.<;: .. 'g Z .. +->'_'_'_ Q) d) il .g ..
.s.~ .. Ul ~ ~ ~ -
-a o 'i5:a-ao O-a ;:>-. rI.l .. -
0 [iJZ'E! ",~'E! (/)d<3 S Oju'E! ~~~ ""s'E!
~~~o --
~ "0 frg.g.g.88'E 8<"0 0::;E::;E::;E
'"
Po. "O~ S....~ S--g--g~ "00 0
E-< o "'''''''tE ij:iE-< :g_E-< >>....E-< ::S':::f-I
o::l (l) d) ll) ~
'C 5~~ ]cS~ d)d)A.l...!::4 o~ stS~
::;E,,~ ~
c.J ~ B888oo~ sEEH en
" ~ b:h g t:: en u '€""...." .a"''' "~" '" OJ "
;:1
'" e 0..0" ij:itEij:itEuu1! ~ "
" 0"",, 0~1! OOO~ 0.13 ~ ~~~ ..@
~ ~ ;g "-
!:l - ""
ZP'lU z>><u z::;E1L:u OOOOUUU Ol"-<U o>><u
>><~u >><>><>><>>< 0
8
>><
~
"
~ g. -
8< "
0 ~ "
0 ""
'" 0 j
OJ ~ U
'* [iJ fr.................-c........ ......
:;;'0 - ....
iEooooo
G- "
Z ~ '" '" 00000
~- Bt-t-t- OJ
0 0 0 00\00\__ 0.
g. ~
Z Z Z ooot-t-\O\O 0
o~ >>< ;i;~~~
., i5 ;..; i-:N_ .. 00 o:::t ,.....( t- I:-
i..:C"f') .. '0 ;..; ..-............. 0
c.J tsot'-o-- Ci~
1-<-......-
'S 0", 000 "dOOOOl()l()l() 0",
.g ONNN U
"00 "d", "0",'0 ~_N\O\O\O "0_ "0",
"'d___ ,
~ !Jo "'" 0:00 \1)0\0000 0:00 !J'"
" 5000
>-:SB "", """"" >0____ "0 >-~
" >lr:Ilr:Ilr:I ~
... >-'" >--- l() l() l() l() tr) >--
>- '" '" '"
'"
~
"
~
p..
o 0 0 0 0
z z z z z
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
o:u 03.) o:u (l) 03)
~ - - - - -
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ "" " " "
.. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
.s: ::r::::r:: ::r:: ::r:: ::r::
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~oo ~~ ~o ~~O ~ooooooo
0000000 <=> 0 0 0 0 0 .. _....-4 .. _ ..""" ..0 N .. M M ('f') ("I') M M M
.. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ UOO oUN 03.)0 u-O 03.)0000000
------------- UMM u_ 0("1') 0__ UNNNNNNN
,.Q~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~ ~N ~~ ~~~ ~~~~~~~~
I I I I I I I I I I I I I Q) I I 0 I iU I 03.) I I o:u I I I I I I I
~ 0000000000000 ~OO ~O ~O ~OO ~OOOOOOO
~ OOOOOOOMOOOOO ~OO ~O ~O ~OO ~ONNOM__
= OM~-N~~NNM~-N dJ_O 00 d.)~ 03)0000 d.)O~~O~~~
Z ~OO-MN-__OON~OO_ OO~~ 000 OO~ 000000 OO~--~___
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~ ~9 ~~ ~~~ ~~~~~~~~
~ _0______0_00_ 000 u_ 00 000 00__0___
~ ~~~~~~~~~~=88 ~~~ ]8 ]= ]88 ]~88~88S
< o~oOOOOO~ON~O UNN 00 UN U~~ UNOONOOO
~
'"
e 0000000000000 00 0 0 00 0000000
= ------------- -- - - -- -------
0000000000000 00 0 0 00 0000000
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~~~~~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~~~~~
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~~~--
~ ------------- -- - - -- -------
~. MMMMMMMMMMMMM MM M M MM MMMMMMM
~ 0000000000000 00 0 0 00 0000000
= ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~ ~~ 88 ~~~ ~g~~Mg~
= .............. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
o ~~~~~NN~-~~~N~ MM~ ~~ 00 ~~~ ~M~~MMO
~ ~ -- ~- N~M MM~ MM 00 ~NO _
~ - -- NN -
... . .
-... -~
"
>
o
""
~
<=>
8 ~
N ,,~
- .8 ~
. ~ C; &0 M
~ .S ~ -_ 0
~ Vl . ro Cf.}" if. ..:.;
tnVl tntntnVltntntntnVltn __ ~ g;:;E d ~!=:l00 _
~ ] ] ~ ~ ~ ~ ] ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 .8 S - c:: ~ 0 ~ C ~ I
0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. 0.. ~ ~ ;:j tI'i' .9 c:: .~ I,.... 0 0
g. g. g. g. g. g. g. go g. fr g. g. g. U5 ~ 's g S.g .~ B ~ ~ E, 8
Cl)r/J:CI)ClJCI)ClJCI)lZIrnCIJClJCI)CI) ~ '.;:::rn ~ ;:l c:: c::1--l N
~$-oI-<J-cJ-cJ-cJ-c!..i$-o$-oI--.4$-o$-o ~ ~P:: ~Io-( ..oVl(J'l 3iUN........~' e ~
== 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 .. ~ __ ~ .. ~.. 5 ~> .. 'r:: .~ .~ .. S () * * u U1 1"'\ ........
o ~~~~~~~~~~~~~g ~oo] o~ ~ ~ ~----~ SOC::~O~ I--l _
'€. :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s :;s 2 _'" {g {g 0 :;; 8 0 .3 ~ 0 i5 ~ ~ 0 0 'S .g .9 'S g ~ :. g
.....c ~ 0) iD ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ (I) ~ (I) ~ d) I;"""'" :j:j 0 0 ~ 'Cd N f-I ~ <C; ~ u) CIl f-t U ;::s i:d ~ ;::s?" -a ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~.z3 JJ u u ~ ~ '"5 7j .~ 0 7j .~ d d ~ t;j S U5 f;.i S.9 ~ ::q .~
~ t;jt;jt;j(J'lt;jt;jt;jt;j(J'ltnt;j~t;j~ c::~~~ I~~ .-........~ ~VlVl(l) ~S~~S~~~ ~
~ ooooooooooooo~U 2~n~ 2~~ ~o~ ~~~~ ~O.~.~O=~.~. ~o
~ p..p..p..p..p..p..p..p..p..p..p..~p.. p..p..p..U p..~U p..~U p..~~uou~~up..uu 0
...
p..
{l
"
.<1
:j:j ~ tn U
" 00 ~ .!:; \:::l ...
~ ~ J-c co: Vl (l)
Q ~ ~ t- ~ ~ ~ l:' l:' l:' l:' l:' l:' ~ S .....:l .~ @ ~ N N N N N N N 1:i
Z ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~oo a~~~~~~~ 0..
~ - ........ ~ ........ ~ ~ - ........ ~ ~ ........ .-I ........ .. 0\ ~ .. .. .. .-4 ~ .. N N N N N N N S
c:J -~~~""""~-""""~"""""""".-I_ J-c~~ J-c J-c $-o~~ J-c~"d"~~~~~ 0
'0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .g ~ ~ .g ~ .g .g ~ ~ .g go go &; &; &; &; go ~
;> 0000000000000 5~~ 500 5 50000 goooooooooooooo p,
~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~ >~~ >~ > >~~ >8888888 ~
'D
~
"
gp
~
o 0 0 0 0 0 0
z z z z z z z
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
0) IU 0) 11.> 0) iU 0)
~ - - - - - - -
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
= 0: 0: 0: 0: 0: 0: 0:
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
" U U U U U U ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
0000 ~~~~~~~ ~O ~O ~~ ~~O ~~ ~~
~8~8 ~g~g~g~ ~~ ~~ ~~ tl~8 u8 u8
~ C"lNNN O~M~~~~ U~ O~ O~ OO~ O~ O~
~ ~~~~ ~~~~~~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~N~ ~~ ~~
,.Q I I I I 0) I I I I I I 0) I 0) I <l.) I oU I I 11) I iU I
e g 8 ~ ~ &g g g g g 8 &8 &8 &8 &8 g &8 &8
= ~~~~ ~mMMMMM uo 0;0 0;00 O)O~ O)~ 11.>('1")
Z 0000__ ~~~~~~~ OO~ OO~ 0000 OOON OON W~
~~~~ ~~~~~~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~9~ ~~ ~~
o 00-- 0000000 00 00 00 0__ 0..... 00
~ ~8~8 ~~~~~~~ ]~ ]~ ]8 ]88 ]~ ]~
< ~~oo u~~~~~~ UM UM U'D Uoo Uo UM
"
....
'"
9 0000 000000 0 0 0 00 0 0
~ ____ ______ ....-4 ....-4 _ __ _ _
~ 0000 000000 0 0 0 00 0 0
a ~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~
n ~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~
= ---- ------ - - - -- - -
^. ~~~~ MMMMMM M ('Ii M MM M M
~ 0000 000000 0 0 0 00 0 0
= ~g~~~ ~~~~~~~ gg gg ~~ ggg ~~ g
= ..... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
O -M~-~ ~~~~~~- MM NN ~~ ~~~ ~~ ~
d ~ ooooooooooooN 00 ~~ ~~ -~~ 00 0
!:l l() '..0\0 1..01..0 I MC'Ii -- .....
< ~~ ~~
;:l ;:l
U U
'E)8e~8~
(!.) 000) 00
.f:jN......f:jN;->
oo_OOrn_rn
SR 0 ~~ 0 ~~ ~
~ 8aCl)8aCl)
~ ~ ~~iS~~iS u
~ ,-0 QQ"'OP-ts:::"'OP-t ._ M
Q 0....... 0 0 l1) - 0 Q - .S ~
I 8 .~ .~ P-t p'~ P-t P u-
..... +-:l '-" td C,,) cl6 ,- C,,) o(J.- "'0 "'0 .....t
gg 0 O:E~UE~U "" ~ ~ '
__ H C:rn~cdVl-cd +-:l +-> a 0.. 0
P-t ~ Q ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .S ~ d) 8
~~ I ~glUQ8lUQ ~ ~ ~ ~__ t~ ~~ N
lUoU("f")_ rnl1):g~lU~~ rn rn 0 ]lUOO "t)~ lUlU ~
= 0: 0: '* '* .. ~ ~ 00 .... ~ 00 .... .. ~ ~" .. ~ ~" .. 00.. ./:l ./:l .. :> U .. ] 1i! ~
.s .g.gQS:::'il c:...... ...,S..... ...,S'il Cd 'il _ov Cd . ~~d Cd u~ -
~ lUUOO...... ._lU~CI)u~CI)+-> +-> +-> ~...... 0000;-> Vl~...... '-CI) 8
.& ~~ii~ ~~~......~~-~ ~o~ ~o~ b ~ lUu~~ 'ao~ ~o ~
~ ........~~~ ~ooU~ooU~~ g~~ g~~ ~ ~ s~.~ g~~ 0:- $
~ lU oU u "'0 0 0 CI) 0 0 CI) u ._ 0 0 'l:"'^ 0 0 a t u ....... ~ ~ 0 r~_ U 0 cd ~ _ 1
~ ~ 1;j U l1) U lU _ _ :> .- _ > Q) ~ ~ Q) O!J ~ oU ..s::::: +-> oU a .!::l ,!::l u - Vl U ~ a t:
~ iSiS~~O ~~~~~~~O ~~O ~~O ~~O ~~~O ~~O ~~ 8
....
~
~
<>
"
~ ~ ~ ~ .... <;) ~ 0
f13 t-- g :s ]" ~ ] E
Q N N N N u ~'So t-l-c , r~ {.) :::I
Z 00000000 Q) Q) d) () ~.~ 0..
~~~~ ~ ~ ~ 00 0000 CZl CZl a
~ ~~~~ i-:~~~~~~ i-: ~ i..:~ ~-- i-: i-: 0
... ~r-r-r- O___NNN 0 0 OV) 000 000 0 U
Q OO~~~ "'O~~~~~~ "'0 "'0 "'0_ "'ONN "'000 "'0 I
> ~oooooo 5MMM'=:t'=:t'=:t 5 5 5'=:t 5..o~ 50 5 ~
~ ~~~8 >~~~~~~ > > >~ >~~ >~ > ~
t-
~
"
~
p.,
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0
z z z z z
z z z
oi:j oi:j oi:j oi:j
oi:j oi:j oi:j oi:j
" " " " "
" " "
" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
c.>
~ &J &J &J " &J
&J " &J
~
~
~ p:: p:: ~ p:: ~
p:: ~ p::
" ~ ~ ~
~ ~
~
a ~ N '"
\0 t- oo '" a
a a ~oooo
",,,,,,, 0'\ V)lt") l.()1J') "'''' ",,,, ~'" ~'"
~'"
.. o:::t' """ ..0000 ..~ ..a ..a ..N
..a ..NN..-IN
... "NN 11)0000 ,,~ "a "..,. ,,~
"'" (1)00100
,,~~ g~{2f2{2 ,,~ gf2 ,,~ ,,~
,,~ ONNC"f')N
" "\0\0 "\0 "\0 "\0 "\0
~\O\O\O\D
.c " , , Q) I I I I " , " , " , " ,
" , 11) I I I I
8 ;::saa ;::saooo ;::sa ;::sa ;::sa ;::sa
;::sa ;:10000
O"'aa cr'oooo O"'a O"'N O"'a O"'a
O"'a cr<NNON
= ,,~~ Q)V).-IO_ ,,00 ".... ,,\0 ,,~
"N 11>0\0"\00\
Z "'..,...,. U)..-l.-ll.()..-l ",00 "'~ "'~ '" '"
"'N (/)--\0-
~......,. 7j!:!!! ~'1 ~'1 ~'1 ~'1
~'1 ~<o:::t''':::i'',"",,''':::I''
..... ' , I I I I
"aa "a ,,~ ,,~ ,,~
,,~ 0.-.___
c.> ""'''' ]0000 "a "a "a "a
"a ~oooo
c.> ..c;~~ (.)..-1--.-1 ..c;~ ..c;~ 08 e8
..c;~ u--.-I..-I
~ UNN 0000 U\O Ua Ua
0000
"
.....
..
~ aa 0000 a a
a a a 0000
.....
" ~~ .......-1_.-1 ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ...-1__.-1
aa 0000 a a
a a a 0000
" ~~ ~~~~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~~~~
8 N N
N N N
~ ~~ ---- ~ ~
~ ~ ~ _........-1.-1
-. -. ---- -. -.
-. -. -. ----
~ '" '" MMtr)('r') '" '"
'" '" '" MMM('f)
aa 0000 a a
a a a 0000
..... a t- ~ 00 OOOlt")ll1 ..,...,. aa
\0 \0 aa ..,...,. No:::t'O\-
" a 00 ~ '" ooos:---t-- \0 \0 t-t-
"'''' 00 00 aa -\000:::1"
= or) O\~\Q o..ndodc-ri ..0..0 dd
~r...: r:-...:a:--: ..0..0 tri.....;oOO
0 a t- "'t- N\ONOOO\ '" '" \0\0
NN '" '" ~~ "d"1(')t'--o
8 ~ 'o:::I"I:'N.. NtnN.......-I.. '" '"
00 00 ~~ ~~
~ ~ ~
"" '"
" " .... ~
"
" " "
'" '" .S '6h
'0-4'_ +-> Q)
" " " 0
1J ~ ~ 5.8 '"
.9.9 " "" '0
'Ol",,,,U i::; a
'" '" :E .S
~
'" '" .g
i'Q ~~~~
" " = 0.0 8 b.O
~
<3 " " "
<3 ,
" " .~ .g :E .2 "
" <3 I ro ro:"-' 11) a
" 0 0 E-< .~
..s <1~~ ~~
~uu --o"Q "
~
.:a gj s H --:.~
a
r'l-< I-< BE-< " "
"" 8CJCJ~~ S
8~c2 ~ :E .~ :E '" .- " f.I) .~
~:E "
" " " .... "Q 1: .. :E ~ ..
ao 0 0 d ~
.S -;j "ss-;j o ~.~ ~ .. '0-4 .. ::J 0 .. il-5-;j
~888o
~ ~ .~ .~ ~ ....-a1l ..c;d ocus g..g>1l
-.
..... ~ ~ 11) d)'- "Or.f1(5 ~ <Zl 0 O'E+->
("\INN......: '"
E fr 0 a
"" "tti.=:.=:E8 5~E--i p., i::;>E-< d'lp.,~
~ ctj 0 :E ~ ~ ~~ ~
.;:: [;; S 0 0 0 E-< ~<ZlE-< ",,(1:1 E-< ~
c.> ~ ~" ,,~ '" .~ U U U ~ S . ~ ""'~ --o,,~
B~~ ~"~ ~222~ '"
'" " Old" 8 o~ 0 ~ il: " " '" 5h " .s .~ g
: ~ ~ ;:1
" " (I) CI.l l'I) Q) '" " [;J 0...1J 'c di..r::
[;J <Zl " ..0..0..0
..c; 15PlPlO ._ ~._ ~._..c; 0'- ~ :>~..c;
'H
~ U E-<p.,Up.,uu E-<:Eu ~::JU ::lPU
uu :>zO ~&&&:E 0
0
....
p.,
~ -l1
~
"
0 "
a 0 ..c; ..c;
'" [;; "
N .... 0. ~l() ('f) 0 00 U
., "
~
~ "
a 0 ::;s I I I I B
~ '" '"
00 ~ 0000
z " ~
<Zl~ " ~aaaa
" .s ~
~ l() iii l() In ;::s
15 ~ !3r::
~aaaa ~
E:;OOOOOOl(') :>
I I I I
" ~("f')\O i-.:('r) ;.: 15~ ;.:
;.: .. C"f') "':::I'" l.() \0
c.> ~C'f1C'f1C'f1\O
1500000000
.~ --0"'''' "Ol.()lt)l.()l.() 0\0 0", 0",
0\0 "0.....-(.....-(.-..... U
0 --0", --0", --0 a --000
--000 s:::oooooooo
6 "t-N s:::t'--t'--t'--r--- 500 "'" 5a 5a
5"" ,
"N'" u.....-(.....-(.....-(.....-( "a l!)C'f1C'f1C'f1C'f1
~
:>0000 :>:E:E:E:E :>;;:: :>:5 :>~
:>g; >C'f1C'f1MM
.... t-t- :>..,. l/') l.() It')
l.()
00
.-.
"
~
"'"
c c c c c
:z: :z: :z: :z:
:z:
.c; .c; .c; .c;
.c;
'" " " " " "
'" :g :g :g :g :g
CI !::l rIl !::l !::l
!::l
'" ~ ~ ~ ~
...
~ ~ :Ii 0 :Ii ~
'" ~ ~
~ <>::
..". '" \0 r- oo
:=:0 0 0 0 0
00 .-.0 .-. .-. .-.0 .-.0
N'-' .-. ..N ..0 ..N ..N
... 00 ~O ,,0 "N "'" ,,0
N'" u", u .-. u..". u.-. u .-.
'" \0\0 !::l\O !::l\O [3"f1 !::l\O !::l\O
..Q 00 " , " , " , " ,
e ,,0 ,,0 ,,0 ,,0 ,,0
'-'0 0'00 0'0 0'0 0'0 0'0
= 0\ 0 ,,0\ "00 ,,0 ".-. "..".
Z .-. \0 "'.-. '" 00 ",0 "'.-. "'..".
.."...". .'4'1' .'4'1' .'49 .'4'1' .'4'1'
.... , ,
.-. .-. u .-. Uo Uo u .-. Uo
'" 00 "0 "0 lJ'" "0 "'"
'" .-. .-. ..c::.-. OG ..c::.-. ..c::.-.
< 00 UO UN Uo UN
'"
....
~
~ 00 0 0 0 0 0
.... .-. .-. .-. .-. .-. .-.
.-.
CI 00 0 0 0 0 0
'" ~~ l::! ~ l::! l::! l::!
e N N N
N
>. .-. .-. .-. .-. .-. .-.
.-.
~ -- - - - - -
~ "'''' '" '" '" '" '"
00 0 0 0 0 0
.... "''''..". \0 \0 0\ 0\ 00 00
"'''' ""'00
CI .-.\00 '" '" '" '" 00 00
.."...". r-O
= ..cC'ioq: 00 r-..:r:-..: .;:.;: dd
r...:r...: 0'-'
0 \0 r- .-. .."...". 00 NN 0\ 0\ 0\
0\ .-.
e Nr- .-. .-. \0 \0 NN
'" '" 00
<
cv)
..".
.-.
'"
lil
U
@ "'-
E5
~
,,~ '0
.Sl oil u ~
1:: u ..s ~
'"
".-
~
"'~ oj) '0 i
0; .-.
"- lib!) c
.'4 .-.
~"'" ..c::
u ,
u
.. "
~.rf @J2
~cJ 0
'" "
.-.
t " ....
tl'O :Ii 0 ~
0
S ~:g '"
"- l::!
of;> t " .'4 0
CI " '" ",.- U ....
.-.
,....-.( OU .. ~ti,..:..; ~~ .. '0 :;E .. >> .. "'O..c ..
" " .-.
0 ~~] .- "" ti~] i3 "'-,," ..c::.o -
.- ..... >-. ro 1U~...... .:i!~] ~ g '"
.... !3"'o a:: e '0
Q. ~O c ~ l!) 0 , _ c .!::: P-c 0 0
.- .-.E-< g pE-< ;;;:"'E-< <>::~E-< ~ -", E-< <>::E-<E-<
~:z: ~
... 2i'l~ ""g~ '.'4 iit;-tj >.t)~ ~
"" U".'4
'" " b!) U ~ iB g :::$ ~l!) " U U ]]
;.:l
'" .0.0" ~ U " ""J2lJ _u"
~ ""..c:: "..c:: ~cJ ~;;;:CJ ::>C..c:: C c
"-
~~U ",U :>-< U NooU E-<E-< c
8
"'"
.'4
'0
u
"
'g " ~ '"
cJ
\0\0 1;; .= ?;
, , Uoo ~ ~ ~
t
00 "00
0 00 "'N
-a
'" '" ~~ "" ~ '3
Z 00 c
~
, , :>-< :>-< N
'" r- r- .. 00 13"=:t ;.; ;.; ;.;
c
"" 00 r- 1>\0
'0 .-. \0 C C C
U
00 \0 '0'-' '00\ "d '0 "d
,
6 "'..". 50 !::l'" g g !::l
'" '" ,,0\ "0
~
... '" '" :>~ :>S :> :> :>0\
-
"
gp
p..
o 0 0 0
z z z z
~ ~ ~ ~
ou 0.> (!) d)
Q.) - - ....... -
C) ~ ~ ~ .g
~ = = = =
... P'I P'I P'I P'I
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
_~ N~~ ~O_ ~O
..N ..__ ..00 ..M
(1).....-l (1)00 l1>-N Q)N
~ u_ UMM UOOM UM
~ ~~ Q~~ Q~N Q~
_ (l) I (1) 1 I iU . I (l) I
~ ;::sO ::sac :::soo ::sO
~ 0"'0 c:r'0 <o::t' 0"'00 0"'0
= UN OUMN d)~O o.>N
7 ~M ~~- 00-0 0000
~ ~~ ~~~ ~~9 ~~
., () ...... (,,) 0 ...... () ...... ...... {) 0
U 0)10 iU"d"O 000 iUo
~ ~_ ~__ ~-- ~N
~ Uo U~o Uoo U~
"
....
eo
e 0 00 00 0
- ...... -- -- ......
~ 0 00 00 0
~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~
e \0 \0\0 \0\0 \0
~ ...... -- -- ......
~ ~ -- -- -
^. M MM MM M
~ 0 00 00 0
d ~~ ~88 ggg $$ ~"d"
= . . . . . . . . . . .
O ~~ NON ~O_ ~~ \0
EI 00 N"d"\O 000- ~~ ~
~~ ~N\O -~~ "d"~ ~
-<lj ~~ ~~ .~~ NN M
\0\0 __ __ 0000 00
-
'\!)
~ 'i5
"
" .j:l
_._ ~ <Zl
--= ~ ~
8 .0
" -o::M '"
~ '~B ~
d) A-4" g '> t:: 1:: ~ &3.. M
.S l-< .- ~ 0 0 1a 0 U) _
l-c oU t> 0.> 0. c.. ~ .- ~ ......
~ Sp<Zl _"" "i'; ~ .
b di3 !a il Ol 'G ~ ~ tl ~ i:i --= 0
~ ~~~ coo ~ ~u ......
~ ~~ ~o(!) ::S~~ ~t ~~ 0
00 "'~ Su~ 00000 ~>""'O M
....-4 a'3 r./) ctS d.> 0 U 0 0 ~ [) U l-< :::::.
- ., =: H 0 .. ~ ~...... .. c:l ....... ...... .. 000 .. iU d) ......
~ 0 ~_~ ~o~ ~oo~ C ~ ~~ _
,,"\ 4--l ;: 0 0 ..... ~ (IJ N .,.... .t:: N N ..... ::s 0 -- u a 0'"
..., 0 C-I NO rnQ);>-.O -?-OJ>-.O 0_0 $-c9 '-'
- 0 ~ ~~~ ~~~~ &~~~ U~~ az .
..0 .. :;g CJ U ~"'" :1l " "'" 0 ::I "",,, 0 _ "'" _ _ .~
.- '"'" ~ ~ '0 ::I g ::: 0 ~ ~ b $-c l-< g .1:J "i:: ~ .s .a H
\ov ~ Q,J R a.s::l Cd c: ~ .s::l l!) ~ .g ...s::::: (\) ~,.J::l 0 0 C+-t
>.. u ~ ~ <l;....,U ~M~U ::E~~u ::E-o::u ~~ g
Cd () ::: &::
~ <l.l . "'"
~ 0 ~ u
rJ.lU::; - - ~ = e
~ $-4 ~ '5"~ g g ~
S<l.l - u:1l u u "
~ C/l..-l 0 00 +->
~ ~M Z ~ ~ t> ~t'- a
R 0.. lS :: ".. ::g 8 ~ 8 ~ ~ ~
......, d ..0 "0 .~ E)t'- 13 0 Ci 0 E)N U
Q o~ i-:2 0 "'O~ ""d N "'0 N "tjgj I
.....,.; U ~ "8 ~ 5 ~ 5 13 5.g 5 8 Poi
~ ~p.. ~ >- > ~ > ~ >0 <l;
~
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Council Members
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrato
FROM: David D. Berkowitz, Director of Public Works/City Enginee~
SUBJECT: Approve Resolution Rejecting Bids/lO-3/2010 Crack Sealing - Engineering
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
The City Council is requested to approve the resolution rejecting the bids for Project 10-3, 20 I 0 Crack
Sealing.
DISCUSSION
In the past, the City has not had a favorable experience with the low bidder for this project and, despite
the bid amount, staff does not believe the low bidder is the "lowest responsible bidder." Staff therefore
recommends that the bids be rejected.
The City of Coon Rapids prepared the final plans and specifications and administered the bid opening
through the previously approved Joint Powers Agreement. Bids received are as follows:
Contractor Andover's Portion
Precision Seal coating $24,309.00
American Pavement Solutions $31,080.00
Fahrner Asphalt Sealers, Inc. $39,294.00
Astech Corp. $39,516.00
Allied Blacktop Co. $48,840.00
Engineer's Estimate $29,970.00
If the rejection of bids is approved, staff will send the project out for quotes and bring the results back
to the City Council for approval.
ACTION REOUlRED
The City Council is requested to approve the resolution rejecting the bids for Project 10-3,2010 Crack
Sealing.
Respectfully submitted,
Q.....;e0. ~
David D. Berkowitz
Attachments: Resolution
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RES. NO.
MOTION by Council member to adopt the following:
A RESOLUTION REJECTING BIDS FOR THE IMPROVEMENT OF PROJECT NO. -
10-3 FOR 2010 CRACK SEALING.
WHEREAS,pursuant to the Joint Powers Agreement with Coon Rapids, bids were
received, opened and tabulated according to law on February 26, 2010 at Coon Rapids
City Hall with the 3 lowest bid results as follows:
Contractor Andover's Portion
Precision Sealcoating $24,309.00
American Pavement Solutions $31,080.00
Fahrner Asphalt Sealers, Inc. $39,294.00
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Andover
to hereby reject the bids as shown.
MOTION seconded by Council member and adopted by the
City Council at a reqular meeting this 16th day of March , 2010 , with
Council members voting in favor
of the resolution, and Council members voting
against, whereupon said resolution was declared passed.
CITY OF ANDOVER
ATTEST:
Michael R. Gamache - Mayor
Michelle Hartner - Deputy City Clerk
\.
@
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Council Members
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator 0
David D. Berkowitz, Director of Pub 'c W rks / City Engineer~
FROM: Jason 1. Law, Assistant City Enginee
SUBJECT: Award Bid/lO-04/2010 Sealing Coating - Engineering
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
The City Council is requested to receive bids and award the contract for Project 10-04 to Allied
Blacktop for the 2010 Seal Coating Program.
DISCUSSION
The street seal coating program is an effective and cost efficient means to prolong the life of the
City's street infrastructure. In past years, the streets in one of the nine maintenance zones were
seal coated. Due to budget constraints, with the exception of the extreme south easterly portion
of Zone 7, only areas that have recently been constructed or reconstructed and have not had a seal
coat application will be seal coated this year. The 20 I 0 Seal Coat areas are shown on the
attached maps.
The City of Coon Rapids prepared the final plans and specifications and administered the bid
opening through the previously approved Joint Powers Agreement. Following are the bid results:
Contractor Andover's Portion
Allied Blacktop $220,218.00
Fahrner Asphalt $235,702.00
Asphalt Surface Technologies $248,302.00
Pearson Brothers $255,402.00
Engineer's Estimate $233,000.00
BUDGET IMPACT
This project has been identified in the City's 2010-2014 Capital Improvement Plan. Funding
will be from the Road & Bridge Fund and Construction Seal Coat Fund.
ACTION REOUlRED
The City Council is requested to approve the resolution accepting bids and awarding Andover's
portion of the contract to Allied Blacktop in the amount of $220,21 8.00 for Project 10-4,2010
Seal Coating.
Attachments: Resolutio~id Tabulatio~ Location Maps/"
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RES. NO.
MOTION by Council member to adopt the following:
A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING BIDS AND AWARDING CONTRACT FOR THE
IMPROVEMENT OF PROJECT NO. 1 0-04 FOR 2010 SEAL COATING.
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Joint Powers Agreement with Coon Rapids, bids were
received, opened and tabulated according to law on February 26,2010 at Coon Rapids
City Hall with results as follows:
Contractor Andover's Portion
Allied Blacktop $220,218.00
Fahrner Asphalt $235,702.00
Asphalt Surface Technologies $248,302.00
Pearson Brothers $255,402.00
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Andover
to hereby accept the bids as shown to indicate Allied Blacktop as being the apparent low
bidder.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED TO HEREBY direct the Mayor and City Clerk to enter
into a contract with Allied Blacktop in the amount of $ 220.218.00 for
construction of the improvements; and direct the City Clerk to return to all bidders the
deposits made with their bids, except that the deposit of the successful bidder and the next
two lowest bidders shall be retained until the contract has been executed and bond
requirements met.
MOTION seconded by Council member and adopted by the
City Council at a reqular meeting this 16th day of March , 2010 , with
Council members voting in favor
of the resolution, and Council members voting
against, whereupon said resolution was declared passed.
CITY OF ANDOVER
ATTEST:
Michael R. Gamache - Mayor
Michelle Hartner - Deputy City Clerk
OOOCN
0000<0
f_NOcif'i"":
Q)ttl~<OOOfh
.cO"lt_M_~<or:tft
E~~~~~
_ 'l"'""fhfhN
~ <I> <I>
C
00>0)00
l!!.goq,,:C!
=a..g~~
D.. .'t::'
C
::>
00001"'--
OOOCI.O
CD _ooNN"":
(,)Ct,lC'OOCONOtA-
fa CU '0 CO.N..C'\J.. ~
'C.-J-I'-CO'VClO
::sg' LOLOM'IIf'
U)- -r-EA-EA-N
o <I> <I>
'" C
ftS,cQ>OO.....
-aCJ.2C!"'":~
.. I-Gl a: ,... C'\l C'\I
c( ...6'7Efltfl
'2
::>
00000')
0000...,.
cOccioN"":
~~~_b_~.~Efl
aJ-~~~~
(I) tA-.....EflN
..: <I> <I>
~
CD Nf'--.LO
CID'VON
.c.go~...t-
caQ:6'7EflEfl
lL_
'2
::>
00000
0000<0::2"
cOoocci"":
__(")ooo_EA-
_mOOT""'N
.sON~~O
~1-.....<ovN
CJ .....EA-EA-N
co <I> <I>
iii
~<1>"""oo
.- 0 I'- l() 0>
~itg~~
'2
::>
000000
Q) OOOov
- .....
ca_OOOO.....
eRSVO<.OOEfl
._ 0: N.O.r--..O
W7nl-re~~~
..... fhtfl N
.. <I> ...
.~
Q)WOOO
C1lUCOI.OCO
.~;t g~~
c==
we
::>
000
,,-000
+-0' co co N
:O;~c6~
ffi~NT""
::>
o
>-
:t::>-(ij(ij ~
5UJc.9c.9 en
o
(,)
o
~
-
<0
~
'" .
_ '0
..... ~ :-=~
c~ '0. (00,-
0''''''' ctI - 15 Q.)
;:; e a:::: ~ 0 E
~a.. c: Q)U~
,g<<5 g !EC5~
co 8 (,) "8 Q) ~
t-..... :2U)a.
"Clro 0 NN
'-Q.)'?;- Nchd,
~ CI) .- <i: cr: cr:
410 8. LL(jU
>~
00" ---
-g~ ~ c-m-m-m
<(0 Q.l .2.5CC:
o~ 8" :g.~~~
~a.: UJ ~ 'E 'E 'e s
._.:2 Q) ::s ::s :J 0
OU co OLLU.U.1-
a, C I T Y 0 F .... Capital Improvement Plan
r\NDOVE~ Project Name: 2010 SEALCOAT PLAN
CITY PROJECT 10-04
I ~""TA'" ~,J"f" l bU ~ ~ ''''$1 A'" I I 1<1 '/ I~ I I L.JI
1/" ~~o,v"l.-~,~ /"" .,0..[
,,0;" ~'IIIJt;::;:;:., ".\-- '~
...6~ ",' 'I .' , ."" 777, . '\ \, . '! '
" ~ =3J:;;;t! t: ---m~ -- ~ .....""L,I~, i-- ' I
!Il cm~'TrcRToi I- ....., y- ~..:.~ J J i-
~. -'~"."t-=r:;~,,,,,,,,,.,,.. ..=1........ = r~,,,, '- -. . (
. ~ --->rZ-::iffit~I~" .,;;:t~'D ""~.Y~....\ '1/7--
... I III I 1 ffi I=F' r / ","" y,/ / ""'--l r... .
ill[1 . , " ;;;;: , ':/., "''''' 'h 1---\ ~ RT\ L.-,.,.",
'!"i" I--J ,4.J.&],.,.<,,:. I I l- 0:: ,'. , V';zt:
~~ 1= re,; , 1 ~W~r,i~e-;:"'\~"": ~ ~~ ~ Uh~U
, ~i~"""o'''_o 1/ ~ ~ l '<.::-tH~
" ~ l: ~' " ~~tiiN~ ' ~ I, ~~~ __; E-ui~~~~' OAK Hlww.
-. \:(fjifJ I- ,Y ~ ;" . " mnY "
I'H++HW ~ ~ ~~ 9;:~v -t: !
[:)'" .r--. '~~,IIW- /~.,:: ~ ;;;;;;;;r",^",: ....,. }:i
7r 'NV', ~ 0"'~'<, ~'? I--- :)-
m,.,,,', \,,~.." =:J.{J _ IV ~ ."""",~~ ';."'j)'~~ I--- r- ~,i',:1-
t:::J 9 "" d,N ~0J. 'i 1 '<fJ' ,.",,,,,- \ . --- '- - Ft'T':'
; I ==io:1'~rTj > L-..I'\, III ,I. j I , ~- f- - .,,;:,,
l1lIl j I! j r II ~r I / / :::::::J...!t..0 i.1:'" ,;t.ho~'.o "';r. _" T
~. " I" 11111 ;{@.; ~rl::: ~1-f1';<f"'" ~. r ._ - - -'1'1" ,'~':
-: - " '<l<~~:;:' ]~". ~ ~ ' '\...1 I I I I I j I I I
~ > f5l :f,. y;."- ~~o"",
t-.- a: ~ "^
I-;-~ 5 ~" :1 ~o"'" .... "'... /' I "
'" ;; r-.. "ooJ'. ~ ... A' .../' ~
fow' -- I I ~ , ?;-o ';So.',' ':
I- ]1" ~,. !;;.~" ~~"'<. ~ ~""""""'"' ~ 1
~- "0 ~~.'-.,: 0
I- _ l>:~ ~ VII I j T I r; 1
II llllT r:::.; II I ry r
, 1\
" ['.">ON ~ \ \
~I{~' ~ \\
j 0~ V~ ~ ~
.. V:::--4 ~ V
:::l -,
~x ~ ,
s...o-$~ " ""
I I..""'" - · ~
i'i Ii l~ T
II \ II! 111,11,.'1 ~ I II I I I ./ ./ -tIn \
N Location Map
lEG END .~, ~",,,)ilr.l'h .~~
(;I Project Location T (~" L ~ ~
Q Lots/Parcels ~i 'l' . ,pl<. ,
Park '4 I-~ u;: ~
o 650 1,300 2,600 r -:;~ h: ~ I k-
Water J.., ~~"'bJ
~~cl~y ~ -~.~
~ City Limits ::m h \
1 OF 4
C I T Y 0 F ~ Capital Improvement Plan
NDOVEl~ Project Name: 2010 SEALCOAT PLAN
CITY PROJECT 10-04
~~JII r r
--.--.. 161STAVE
; \-41 .1
:\ ~,<;)
- 0/ 0)1
tJl " ---1
:::: ~ ~ I -............ mE.
l \ 61-~,IE.l=~JJ
~ r /Cf\ =
J:
- ANOKACO HWYRIW PLAT 02 I '-..,J, 1-
cLksllEdTO
"- - T" ,''1
" _ --':>-- COrv\M
~ ~ 58' AVE =llf:luCfGE - l.!~\)....\",os j si~
v \_ ,,,0 c~o'i>s ~("\
~Y--""- ~ <:).{
l----r $ yY--"-" H f--
~~ ~~ ,
~ ",\0V> -.- r=
_ '~;S+ht{Ef I
1 ~ tIlllrllll/IIIIIHIIII
0"- z ~
~~o~Y--\\)~- (f) ~ aJ1) ~ EEtf3 ~
5'!'ll Gm~f<7 ~ I
u r--, ~B) 155TH LN ______....
~ '- '----I ffi --.... " '"
- tlJlW II j --........::: ~I '5l~i "'....'"
> I ""~
II j j I ~I _ ~s""1-'
NIGHTINGALE ~ \- ~!>-Y" CL L/ / _ >>~0
,Y ~ ~ ,0/ j j I I I I I\.") ---:~~rl---...'<J
ES)ATES 2ND ~L 1J l---i w -,,"1-'l rzJ r-;:::,
N Location Map
LEG END w*, ~,,"~~~, .1(ts
(;I Project Location T ~~ --.... " ~ ~~
Q Lots/Parcels ~I 'E . ~ ~ ~ ,.,
Park II II-- 1 ~
o 337,5 675 1,350 ;-:l~ J' . ~
Water bl ~~ EtWI
Right of Way Feet ..-c ~~ ~
o City Limits Ji ),.-., \"
2 OF 4
a, C I T y 0 L~ Capital Improvement Plan
""\NDOVE~ Project Nam : 2010 SEALCOAT PLAN
,..I. CITY PROJECT 10-04
~ ~~~~"'0 r=il,'ff]:i""'(iJ:jAI I ~k~sJ:-j~J,,- H 1"J}.
" 0 ~ ,<r-- II _ I--es_ ~ ~
~ >~~ W -IFF
~ iin-~ --.j-...., j-C
AKS -( ~ -., z '"' "ME I-- i'.. "\, J" t:-i
'~ 0/11 r--IY-Y-- --- ! l
~" ~ !@ f- I-- _ ' r-----,,~,cl'.i
",01 ~ V1lJ I-- -- J.Jt- --, I-- s J $.~
~'fS61 , :E ".1] '--- '- ~t-At-~OlI~o~ L f f I--'r---Cjflil,tJ::;.,
) .-" ,," 1-10T ..l ---., ;:::--v ~ ~
KENSINGTON S 1 --I ~
'I 1ilJ) 'i-L'"-.I ...J, I _~
e-r2'V7m " '" ~ 11
~ " OL
v'
~ \' ~. ,
"\ a: ~: Idi."s
~i)1 ~ =~ ~ i.'l ~l/
'\ ' F k ~ \/"r,:;;-
/, r:= ~, Ll .Ll'l.tl?)~ I 7"-
/ ill P.-\RKSIDE AT --- ~ '~.'
~',~ L-',':3 F -n J~ /lfI..T)f' \, .,r)'-
~ ~ '( \ "
" ,\ ........ '
m);-MA';{OBf.m: 14- ~ ~ ~ -l \
'lOo .-. I-- _ ""-
)..p . - ~ ~ 'r- '''''':s ./}.
~ . r- ~ 7" ~0~"tlt'V~! h 13 ,gvc r----
\ "r- t- \ ~'V~l/ ( r f'--
..l...- r-- r-- %i1<>.,-1- ~
.':.'0. J- NORm 5 c::=t. J I- I
I ~ aj ~ I r-- '<::
V 6 '-- :r<\\~
~ ~ /,f $/'
f- q:j:E If IJHR .!~ p~
f'., 1:J f'
~ r- "l, ~ ,
BUNKER LAKE BLVD " I v;r ~ "'>-.
ANDOVE~1. Jf . BUNKER LAKE BLVD
'IARKETP:~"lA'Cr: H n I tAm'ONlNA6Dr--- 1 '
EASI I fT TI-
:'\ J,,- I
N Location Map
LEG END w~c '""'" t-&::n~~ :~ ~
(;I Project Location T r~ ---., vl't: ::;:<;1 ~ r )
s l~n ..~ <:;;<U.- 'Ir-
Q Lots/Parcels ~J jjj ",.".; ~ . ~'r
1'111 ~.
~ !~ ~~ ~
o 400 800 1,600 ~ i} = ] I .<b .{o-
Water . . "'il~~ q
Right of Way Feet
o City Limits ~'
30F 4
('21 C I T Y 0 F ~ Capital Improvement Plan
r~NDOVE~ Project Nam : 2010 SEALCOAT PLAN
CITY PROJECT 10-04
I 'I:~,,- ~f''''<'' 7 ~~ff
11" q""~,, w
. / / I I ~ "'00",2;,,, "" ~ I
L -.; ~: .' y ~!-.._'-, ~
I '., i I--
!J 7; ___ <r/~;. """". . ,
---i .,,, ,,; ~ 2\ J~ - i'1\
~ / /; I l ~ ..J;~ /-~:;r-
~J \ ""
~~ ,~~;,,9~\', " ~
~ -; 1
lJ v~,:, t----. ~ I,Q';-
~< ~"".,,~
'~ - ~ 7
r 1 - ~ ,"" ,., >--
"'1'0 t= ~ -PlNEr"ADD{ ~ \ -
1 I T - ---.Jl \
~-= ". . !(
_ a.
_1- ~
-- - ~
r r - r1 ~
1 "',, , fit l
f--- ~ I I
_ ~ --1l -n c- LI III '
\ /. - J \ ~f
N Location Map
LEG END WAE r/~~~ ~~ :1(,~
(iI Project Location T (f -\'--'v~fu ~ ~
Q Lots/Parcels ~'r ~ J '~~ 1.
liS tm.ih'l ,.~.
Park
~"",",'..,."..,. 0 550 1,100 2,200 ~~ id-~:a:h= ~ .<b k-
..' Water. '- IL ~ ,.,.:<;T
. ~ -< Lj.'+-U
Right of Way Feetf"'lllC'l. ~~);. do
o ~~b h
40F4
@
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CJ.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Council Members
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
David D. Berkowitz, Director ofPu orks / City Engineer~
FROM: Jason J. Law, Assistant City Engineer
SUBJECT: Award Bid/lO-OS/2010 Pavement Markings - Engineering
DATE: March 16, 2009
INTRODUCTION
The City Council is requested to receive bids and award the contract for Project 10-05 for the
2010 Pavement Markings.
DISCUSSION
As a portion of the annual street maintenance activities, all roadway lane lines and pavement
markings are repainted on the City streets. Over the course of the year the lane markings fade
and it is necessary to repaint them for safety reasons and to guide traffic on our busier streets.
The City of Coon Rapids prepared the final plans and specifications and administered the bid
opening through the previously approved Joint Powers Agreement (bid concurrently with seal
coat project). Following are the bid results:
Contractor Andover's Portion
Traffic Marking Service $19,488.75
AAA Striping $21,975.00
Fahrner Asphalt Sealers $24,114.00
Engineer's Estimate $20,400.00
BUDGET IMPACT
The project has been identified in the City's 2010-2014 Capital Improvement Plan. Funding for
this project will be from the Road & Bridge Fund.
ACTION REQUIRED
The City Council is requested to approve the resolution accepting bids and awarding Andover's
portion of the contract to Traffic Marking Service in the amount of$19,488.75 for Project 10-05,
2010 Pavement Markings.
11;:ttoo
Jason 1. Law
Attachments: ResolutiO:;;: Bid Tabulation/
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RES. NO.
MOTION by Council member to adopt the fOllowing:
A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING BIDS AND AWARDING CONTRACT FOR THE
IMPROVEMENT OF PROJECT NO. 1 0-05 FOR 2010 PAVEMEMENT
MARKINGS.
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Joint Powers Agreement with Coon Rapids, bids were
received, opened and tabulated according to law on February 26,2010 at Coon Rapids
City Hall with results as follows:
Contractor Andover's Portion
Traffic Marking Service $19,488.75
AAA Striping $21,975.00
Fahrner Asphalt Sealers $24,114.00
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Andover
to hereby accept the bids as shown to indicate Traffic Markinq Service as being the
apparent low bidder.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED TO HEREBY direct the Mayor and City Clerk to enter
into a contract with Traffic Markinq Service in the amount of $ 19,488.75 for
construction of the improvements; and direct the City Clerk to return to all bidders the
deposits made with their bids, except that the deposit of the successful bidder and the next
two lowest bidders shall be retained until the contract has been executed and bond
requirements met.
MOTION seconded by Council member and adopted by the
City Council at a reqular meeting this 16th day of March , 2010 , with
Council members voting in favor
of the resolution, and Council members voting
against, whereupon said resolution was declared passed.
CITY OF ANDOVER
ATTEST:
Michael R. Gamache - Mayor
Michelle Hartner - Deputy City Clerk
l!! a a a
~ a a
Gl - ,.... M "l'
';; I/) a ,.... ,....
Gl 0 0> N ,....
CIl <..l r-: cD "l'"
- ,.... N
';; <17 <17 <17
~
Co
~ CD <0
(') <0
.. Gl oj M
u
Gl 'C ,.... a
E 0. ,....
~ -
'" '2
LL ::> <17 <17
a a a
a a a
- tri 0 tri
I/) I"- a I"-
0 <0 '<t 0>.
<..l cD '" ,....
,.... N
~ <17 <17 <17
a a
Gl a a
u ,...: 0
'C ,.... 0>
0.
-
'2 <17 <17
::>
<0 a <0
I"- a I"-
Gl - oj 0 oj
u I/) <Xl a <Xl
'~ 0 a '<t '<t
Gl <..l "l'" '" oi
CIl ,.... ,....
Cl <17 <17 <17
C
:i2 <0 a
.. '<t a
'" Gl "l' 0
:!! u
'C ,.... 0>
u 0.
iE -
E '2 <17 <17
I- ::>
a a a
a a a
.S! - 0 0 0
'" I/) a a a
E 0 CD <Xl '<t
:;:; <..l '" "l'" 6
III ,.... N
W <17 <17 <17
III
".. a a
Gl a a
Gl Gl cO 0
c u
'5> 'C ,.... <Xl
C 0.
w:!:
c <17 <17
::>
~ <0 a
I"- CD
:;:; 0>
C
'"
::>
0
Ii)
0
0 .l!l '" '"
,.... '2 c c
o 0
- ::> ro ro
u
.S!. (j) (!) (!)
0"0
Q:'Q.
'" '"
~o:: ~ OJ
.- c c
<..l 0 c :52
-0 :g ..
~() '"
'" :E
.5O@ :E "0
~a Q) .0
C"',.... ~ E
O:!!<a >-
~1:~ CIl CI)
IllGlN ro ro
"SEal 1il 1il
..c Gl c .E .E
III > Q) - -
..."'0. ~ J::
0.0 .!!1 .~ .!!
-Co(/) E EES
.- O-C .S! ::> ::> 0
IONCii LL lLl-
@
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and City Council
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
David D. Berkowitz, Director ofPubhc orks/City Enginee~
FROM: Todd J. Haas, Assistant Public Works Director
SUBJECT: Approve Resolution Accepting Donation/Federal Cartridge
Companyillawkridge Park/Bleacher/09-18 - Engineering
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
This item is in regards to a donation that will be made by Federal Cartridge Company that will be
used to purchase a new 5-row bleacher for one of the soccer fields at Hawkridge Park.
DISCUSSION
Dave Henderson from Federal Cartridge Company will be at the meeting to present a check in
the amount of $5000 on behalf of the employees that contributed.
Until the fields are graded and ready to be used, this bleacher will be placed at the existing west
soccer field for now. City staff will place a sign directly on the back part of the bleacher
recognizing the donation from Federal Cartridge Company.
ACTION REOUIRED
The City Council is requested to approve the resolution accepting the donation from Federal
Cartridge Company which will be used to purchase a new bleacher at Hawkridge Park.
Respectfully submitted,
~~
Attachments: Resolution'/
Cc: Dave Henderson, Federal Cartridge Company (copy sent bye-mail)
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RES. NO.
MOTION by Councilmember to adopt the following:
A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING A CONTRIBUTION MADE TO THE CITY OF ANDOVER
FOR ONE BLEACHER THAT WILL BE INSTALLED AT ONE THE HAWKRIDGE PARK
SOCCER FIELDS, PROJECT NO. 09-18.
WHEREAS, any contributions that are to be made to the City of Andover must be
accepted by the City Council; and
WHEREAS, the contribution from Federal Cartridge Company for a bleacher is to be
installed at one of the Hawkridge Park soccer fields.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council to hereby accept the
contribution, which is to be purchase 1 bleacher on behalf of the Federal Cartridge
Company and is to be installed at Hawkridge Park.
MOTION seconded by Councilmember and adopted by the City
Council at a regular meeting this 16th day of March, 2010, with Councilmember's
voting in favor of the resolution, and
Councilmember's voting against, whereupon said resolution was declared
passed.
CITY OF ANDOVER
ATTEST:
Michael R. Gamache - Mayor
Michelle Hartner - Deputy City Clerk
(j)
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304 . (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . W.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Councilmembers
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrat
Will Neumeister, community;elo
FROM: Courtney Bednarz, City Plann
SUBJECT: Consider Resolution Denying Conditional Use Permit/Clear Wireless
LLC/Andover Lions Park - Planning
DATE: March 16, 2010
INTRODUCTION
The Council directed staffto prepare a resolution for denial ofthe conditional use permit
application to locate a tower in Andover Lions Park at the March 2,2010 Council meeting.
DISCUSSION
The findings of fact in the attached resolution are based on the discussion at the March 2nd
meeting. The review criteria for conditional use permits are shown below.
Review Criteria
12-14-6 B. provides the following general criteria for granting conditional use permits:
1. In granting a Conditional Use Permit, the City Council shall consider the
advice and recommendation of the Planning Commission and:
a. The effect of the proposed use upon the health, safety, morals
and general welfare of occupants of surrounding lands.
b. Existing and anticipated traffic conditions, including parking
facilities on adjacent streets and land.
c. The effect on values of property and scenic views in the
surrounding area, and the effect of the proposed use on the
Comprehensive Plan.
ACTION REOUESTED
TheC is asked to review and approve the attached resolution.
Attachments
Resolution
Location Map
Cc: David Hagen 10715 39th Avenue North Plymouth, MN 55441
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RES. NO.
A RESOLUTION DENYING THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REQUEST FOR A
WIRELESS INTERNET ANTENNA INSTALLATION FOR CLEAR WIRELESS, LLC
LOCATED AT 13960 PALM STREET NW LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS CITY PARK, HILLS
OF BUNKER LAKE 5TH ADDITION, ANOKA COUNTY, MINNESOTA
WHEREAS, Clear Wireless, LLC has requested a conditional use permit to install a 120 foot tall
tower, antenna array and associated ground mounted equipment on the subject property, and;
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission held a public hearing pursuant to the requirements of City
Code 12-14-8, and;
WHEREAS, City Code 12-14-6 provides criteria for the review of conditional use permit
applications, and;
WHEREAS, the Council finds the request does not satisfY the review criteria of City Code 12-
14-6, and;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Andover hereby
denies the conditional use permit application with the following findings:
1. The proposed 120 foot tall tower and associated equipment would negatively affect the
scenic views of residential properties in close proximity to Andover Lions Park.
2. The unique shape of the park results in limited contiguous area to achieve the park land
site selection criteria of the Comprehensive Plan. The existing park facilities and
remaining natural areas are configured to maximize the use of this limited space. The
addition of a 120 foot tall tower and associated equipment in this limited area would
negatively affect the use and enjoyment of Andover Lions Park.
Adopted by the City Council of the City of Andover on this _ th day of ,2010
CITY OF ANDOVER
ATTEST: Michael R. Gamache, Mayor
Michelle Hartner, Deputy City Clerk
Conditional Use Permit
~NDbVE~ Clear Wireless LLC
Incorporated Andover Lions Park
1974 13960 Palm Street NW
Jc,;"/;.,-:.>, .... '.j~/<v! 1"";:.T'i..t:O::l~ i~ 1"'1 ,'... ,.' '~-11~ ",' /':/.6 \ \ ",I", ''''\~I'''I '
,/~",~~f!. ~:~-.7fi5"~~_~f....!::) \".1 ~J:...i ~ I ~ i ~.r~.'.ri.'.).1...4...2..7.......~, f.1.....4.....2..?....~...i 14292 ~lOj/of "~""1lA- ~ \/~F:-~~e~ > \ ~II ~ I ~ ~ I ~~ 1~4263
~~/t;;,~O,~..J;:'VJiJ/iPf!l ,14fN]~tNt~IFl;:114266j 114267 14280RI~~$IO"~' 9~/ \ ,';.~'i.6/': , 14
/~" j}~1 li!j I'" r;.:J,!":'I "'I il18:!e 1;b1'NT',.. '. ,14255. 14268''''1 ,,"',~ ~ 1/ '\r:I;/ 1~<<> ,,,, 1"']"']0 <<> I'"
/-~~/~/-.-.>_. '-~~_~!ft/XJ/ti-;,~"-lli_~..i,~,I~:~I'~!g::I~I;g-TmN-) f1"4243' 142561-; 142~)>~~ ' 9:,96. \.~~~\bc'?~~,~',(JJ~ [!:::jfe Ie it ~ r::
~/~i i ,__. -'.",cv/ ! 1'- 'T-'-J."-.::: ..-_I....IC>> '..""._n_"". 1 \b,"'t 7,>/, ---___ . /- '].b. I
/4;. .ll~~~lk.1<:.'M.)?j2rIf.j .Il.~.....r~. 1~!iif'M.!;:=I=!~!~ il....4....2.....3....1..: 1424411<1'~~~ '~"'l '1~~ bl i1!::;; :g]~];;;l~ I
~/~~/&/kf/~/9;~//8/v;,~ {>~"---l'~-L-~L~.L~:~ JE!~:~ J f1~21.9, ,14232" ~"~~^~~~.9 v~ ,x 14 ~/~ I r:/f'-,f'- f'- f'-,f'-
'-'.~ / RJ, !(Ji"ii;<-'":: I~'j.t:t' ! 1 "'.'O'-T... ,.,.,,,,..1.,,,.. '142071 14220\ ,,g~,\~~v: ~ ~'~ ' 1BO ~ '" 1 r I I' ,
/", -__~/CV"I_-,--- _ . 0) co"'_'" 1.___,,"....-' ~R'.9 t ,V'.... CD NO
~/;;--;___._ ~-~l~/~/~-rr::../ L....I...~!.~I~if8::$ r~~fr6T'o;'---<o' :1..~1.~.51 I "',<9>""," ~~ '" <9 ~~ f 14178/;' :!: I ffi ~I~I~ t::!i
ji!2/ff./~/;f/~'i!'0./.~ / ~1~1.-.~1:ilf..!::.i;:J~j,~I~] 1141831 !ij ",> " ~ / 141661 114161'14188'~: l;;!~!~ OJ'
,<j~/~."'!t;/"'l"'rv. ,..... .1-....... d::l~i ~1'~liOj,~I:;;1 141711 ' " q" ", ,14152! 1414714156rn!e ~j~,~ ~,
-., j..../!<l ".-. ...~J~~ ~~Io 1'1 '., <%," '.,' ~138 I '
......~ '~/!!I/;lj/. 0,1'.01'1..,;;1-'......,.,'=,::::::.,.:::...:0::) ,-14159 ,\,,,~ /c 1<11'-, 14133141441:2 I '
'-----.j'" (\/1 T- mN '0 ~-"'" , i---__._, \ .o'? j. '<' I 1-1 co CD N I
...'!::,I;:YI~_~! :::1~i~i!rgr[~-I.;;'T'n.--.T--..1 1,.r~4147,' \~~ ~/'*Y~7jr778~ 14i25-:1413211~~~I~~[If'!I'
".1,,1,.....:.... CO')'coi"'I\I"f \ '-. '-.?-.....7'if. sr7a~ ! ~ 11
.,.,.,.:":..".~,::I::;:.~l/"'.?'" 'lI> \ ''<''1.,,0,g~ <9 ~I"'''' -'~ 1- "'I~",I",II
'-J ....! T-; 0) '- 1 p 4n", -..... v v (") IN -I 0) f'- I() 'It C':l 1 N
I ---'- '~"L l ~ \1082~.J.---.: ~ \ _/~ ~ -....._:~~~ ~ (CO I co [co co f'- ~ :...f'- ......,L...... 1 I"'"' j
. 'L',:...'" '/; '/; 14078 ! '; , 141 ::dAV~
_'0"""',:,. ,_, /"- 'co 'It 0 CD N C) ~ NIO COlCD
; ....) '.. """ ..,," ,'.""", """eo'"""..'"... P t t' I / 14068 I I ill I':g I...j gj I :: ] '" I <<> ] ~ '" I... 'I'" ] ~
! ~ / --.-r '''._ / 0 en la " - \ \ ,I Q)...... ...... 1...... ...... J I"'"'l f'- f'- f'-j
j~//~ /81// ./ / \ \ \ \ \ (01;:; CO').... 0) ...... l.O I I I
Ff['.N~,./~!~. 'p>../. . . Tower \, \""f<\~\"'] ~1"')aljl:lII"']~lgl:gI~1 745 170
r-.""..----z "'::/ N-? 9../---7.'.1"'-'" Location \ \ \~\\~\..>\ _ ~ co 1 _~ co I f'-I~ I~j
iCOI~l--"'" ~/~/9.f /! -1____.. l.P: $\">\ \/ '
1i:i/~1~~ 'Y/JU;'i~I"'!tJ, \ '%~ "'v ,j)\"'\~lo'18I", I r 1 140THLN
t~t'~'f.~~//~~!~P~I!} /! Ig /~7/~'7"iTKi ,g~~ .. ~ ~<~\~ ~,~ l"'.,:g l~ i ~ i ~ I ~ I ~ I~II ~ 1 ~ I ~ II ~ r
\~,~';~ / ./~ / f'._. ,.-------L.____.i-/::::/ :!J/~/ l I~ i ~ \<& \i5l~t'tJ'Q~ '-.,~ n,t'tJ 'J40401!;;: ,
lH.I..(A~f-\,..i\~.~~~~);(~N~~;;r~'i~.";jL:{~l~/E.. .]I,~......ICI / o~.. ,~:.:: ,"' '~~&~~~Q~~:~~~~4034~ I.r 178~{71/~18\~1 ~
i I (") (")\~_)/~.o..:>.. "'~.! 1::;'1';;:,/"1:1- 10......, '_'_..n...............'-' \ ~ -v" "-:, ('V:~.~\ -" ;1'\402.8\ 14035 _I '-r-..lv \-
H. ,......'................~............'.'..". "'" ~/ ::r.. ,..,.., "."'.... ~.~.,.I..i!!.../. It) ! ..(..___,..... '. )-.-.. 996 ~y ~~\bt~ \~ I (14023j774\. 7,,~,",j ~J J
',~..................,....~ 'Z~ If '\ q,,,, \/)~. ~ I I co / ~ I :g 1',\ 0 ".~~<:> ,,}J'-;, 114018: i i~"" T.~
'd 13963.. '1:L14007\,/(14.-'1 r~ :: 5!h082 ~ I ~",~,,,,':>.'l:., 14011 (g Iii!'; ! ~O'J>
.0013949, / t"'O~6/ /0;;1.'."'.'\':.1 \.",O,\..'Zj40061 113999 '" I" 01~
~ffi."'13935! Redwood Park l!.J:~88.J (1'~."'.'.. /~.f=i~j ~/~<:>~~//.I ~O {;>,%><.~';',g;i 1113987: 13~74 ,o;l13981/
.. C:f'" I' /'-.l,j,/o?'j (3.9TH.L.' / I 13982' \ ",,,,~ '!if ,13975" ]/13971/ '1
'-1........1...3919 I 13977...~~0. J..;13B4.3...I.'.,",rO.i~'-139391 //,l,,,~ 9~~ 113983[ c;; )775"" II"
.00............ ! u'B<.'-.0k,! "'I~I '" 1 t.....". 9~" '0\"'\'" \ ~ ~ . "'13961 'I
E '..13907 I .. ... '!f::jZ.?,g 8&1,],n '.1 :::i:::'.;: i 1139051 ~'!l,'p,"'''',~;r\~9''' \ , '0'. 1.3
..... .,.... .' 1.'= dJ, ,.,,1 I ,.,..,1 '!l, \, ,1394 ' .
81 /13893 r iT TT-rJ.?BOO~@!?il1~{.. \ 81 ;;;'[ ,138711 r- '" ",1_ " ''',13944:?J 13941' 6!:;J1 r ii1 I 113941) /
:....n._____....,__.....: I ' , ," ... f ., l7,.'- 1-'....' C). .m..._........n,. & co...... CD I() r-.. ~ j- I 13928~ 13925 0) I (
61 113879!",1 ire! !~I 1~~/7jff},~:::\",Lg) /13837 -a0l "'> "','" "','" i!l11it/i!2":/~_1393113910a:i I ~ I /13931, ~1393
..4./ !13B~5) fJ. I.. IS. I~. I. rei ~ I" ~!~. {a;, ~.::~,~// 'o;/i€\_p3803,i '" "'q // 1~~!~ p'-VJ:';>" '#",~~~,'_1138921 i13905'1~" \~/ /1!9~4
...' .,..----"..,.__J.. _.'.T-I. ,i .~.!... ..:t:J :138""'62 .1.'4/ .. ~I" .'13~/. ./ ~! 0.:..,.1,1....3..797] 13880 13881 co I() 1 :!I J:i 1--""""" \" / o.A~ I 113887[1'! ...../ J'
, ,
_",_. ""T- I ,ro.,138, ':;:-"""" /i .c. ~ T- '..,~........"..---; - 0) 0) Ch '--'~/!V ~ \~ ,?>u\ 13874 C' --":';"1 ~
81 (~--"r'"'T6T'05''' ~.--~~_..,!..,..--_.._..._../g3-"~~(:?45/ lli1;;;13'78'B!uJ.1~!~~~ 138.70 ~3871 II) - I lOj~r;,~'o\ \ "/ /"1 I 13867i cf,I-\~1 /"t'tJOj b<
; !~ i~i~lrer;"."'. l..~!~".'''/'b\~~\'~$a1 /1;'.-i13784!~...~.~...7...8....!1.! 13860 ~~. ~ ,,<a ';--~rob.\ \\~'Ot511138561 113849J "/ \7 \ ,t'tJq,r;:J
~.' I-..~...,ii,.-.;.JI"'-)T:_l.~j ~ i~ ,I{ji~~) \ ~ \ ?61?y" /r;.?f!J13.7....:;.....i'::> ~~?~3 ~ ~fO~~_~ ~ ~ :: ~qj \~ nA2~1 \1:)'0:)91 13838j r1138291/ & / \
! iT- 1001(l)iT-IO)i,.::,Lr-"'I"Y_\ \~_>,..-- /..............,.16',1..__...8) r1 --'1 ~ - I;) ~ 1 \130"'" I I )851 r [!j I --
...'.....L~."..I..~I.~i1!. IT-."'."..,':re. !..Ci$i~'!ii\.\~'6~tl.\ - ./.,--;...\ ,...................".1..3.7....7.4.1 r--~n'Z.,.1 - ~ ~-~~ (Q \\8 f 0"0 \ \13821 ~'(13811 T- 1 /-
. ... --''-...L......j.:<7_J::JT-'~ \/ (,::t \'" \ '48 11'..3'7--""1 11~773 : ~ if ()\ ~ I ~ \'\:)u,," \ -.......... /"
I '--.....-r-."..- .. .,..__1....,.._ /,.' \ m "0'1 \ I 68) " ----....".--~ N ~ ~'" I l I \'IE -" \ ~ ........k-:I( /"
i ~i~i13784'ti513'785r1'3"';8".lt;("-- \,\31B6\ \~'''\.';\''~r~'.I~-3764'.! t_.1_?.!~~J ,,~/ ~ 13BTH ~v~ \ o:l \ CR \ ~\ ~ \6".------- a.~'\IQ /
I T- iT- I'"'---_...._ij.l i Ii 8!.' '......."'.1 'CD I ~I cA i....: J I 13763' . \~'\cD (0 (p \ ~ I m 0 \ ../,/(-. r --....-:'
gj..rl....~.."i!~.!?~i/!-~773;f3t14...)ln~.~~~.~.~!.~.~ IE.. \. ~TR~t.tr~~~/-.....-.....~--..J .t \~\'O lc:P \(51 l >1 ~ \~R\..~)'yl.4" ."
~ ~,13760 13 .'.,~...J;o \":13754 ...13......,'1'::;:, \ ~137$7 ' .. BUNK\;. / r,
i ' 7,61'...... \ o! ....... I r 1 I I ~ \~ \ 0 ; ...
.L'....N..'..........".i............-- /.----...... :~ /"-d'" ;8,"'''0'''\ Oi~ '::t'\~ '0' to" ! ................ d<.::(..'.".' ';:;;o-~:.,
. """'''"''''''~CY -""~ .,/ ~ ......" ~>: r:!. . 'I ~ 1-;' \ cA . 0 \ 0) .\.,..~......~--.....-,.. i" rj;>;J>' ',:-;-;';.,:-
!. 1 ! I ~ ~....., / ff I -...... .......' ."'. \ ' .... t ~ut~J--..."' ,.,." I I.........'".?::,'<:/\ ~.... '.'."~~"
i ~ ~ I ~ \ ~ va I'" ~ 113741'\1". ~...~ ~ .......... j' \ I CL"~' .:." ;'::-:"
I?Pl~L!:'~t1'... ............. ..... ". I, 1 .,:Jr;t:.,;;,~"~~,::,,
..(...... I \ . />., . ......
I ',;:;1..4..&':); .:~;{ t':q;z
i \ (1'...8~::;~f;;J~~~,..;~;::;':
_ Location Map
N
W-</-E
S
@
C I T Y o F
NDOVE
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304 . (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CJ.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Councilmembers
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
FROM: Captain Tom Wells - Anoka County Sheriffs Office
SUBJECT: Anoka County Sheriff's Department Monthly Report - Sheriff
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
Captain Tom Wells & Crime Watch Coordinator Laura Landes from the Anoka County Sheriffs
Office will be present to provide the Council and the citizens of Andover with an update on law
enforcement activities within the City. Attached is a copy ofthe February 2010 monthly report.
DISCUSSION
To be verbally presented.
ACTION REOUIRED
For Council information.
Respectfully submitted,
Captain Tom Wells
Anoka County Sheriff s Office
Attachment: February 2010 Monthly Report
0)/09/2010 17:43 7537574579 ANOKA CO SHER PATROL PAGE 02/03
CITY OF ANDOVER - FEBRUARY 2010
FEBRUARY JANUARY FEBRUARY
ITEM YTD 2010
YTD 2009
Radio Calls 607 676 1,283
1,299
Incident Reports 647 651 1,298
1,539
Burglaries 2 4 6 7
Thefts 37 27 64 51
Crim.Sex Condo 0 I 1 5
Assault 8 1 9 10
Dam to Prop. 10 12 22 25
Harr. Comm, 11 13 24 21
Felony Arrests 2 3 5 2
Gross Mis. 1 0 I 1
Misd. Arrests 35 16 51 40
DUl Arrests 5 9 14 23
Domestic An. I 1 2 14
Warrant AIr. 10 5 15 24
Traffic Arr. 202 199 401
487
DUIOFFENSES:
DAY
OF Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
Saturday
WEEK:
t' I 18:35 I I 22:19 I I I 00;52 I
I
01:27
02:03
03/09/2010 17:43 7537574579 ANOKA CO SHER PATROL
PAGE 03/03
CITY OF ANDOVER- FEBRUARY 2010
COMMUNITY SERVICE OFFICER REPORT
&M I FEBRUARY [ JANUARY I YTD 2010 ~ -::=Y ~
Radio Calls 79 86 165 192
Incident Reports 80 88 168 94
Accident Assists 4 4 8 18
. Vehicle Lock Out 11 22 33 56
Extra Patrol 127 128 255 429
House Checks 0 3 3 1
Bus. Checks 13 9 22 59
Animal CampI. 28 13 41 45
Traffic Assist 10 21 31 19
Aids: Agency 132 148 280 382
Aids: Public 27 28 55 105
Paper Service 0 0 0 0
Inspections 0 0 0 0
OI:dinance Viol. 0 2 2 0
(j)
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304 . (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Councilmembers
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
Will Neumeister, Community Deve
FROM: Courtney Bednarz, City Plann~
SUBJECT: Public Hearing/2010 Natural and Scenic Area Grant Application- Planning
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
The Council directed staff to proceed with this grant application. A public hearing and an
approved resolution are two elements of the application for this grant. Please note that the
minutes of this meeting are also required to be submitted with the grant application.
Additionally, The Open Space Advisory Commission suggested that an application be submitted
to LCCMRfor 2011 Funding at their meeting last Wednesday. This would be a backup plan for
funding of the same property. A public hearing is not a required element for submission of an
application. A resolution is an optional element to show support for the project. The initial
submittal deadline is April 9, 2010. Therefore, the Council will be asked to consider a resolution
supporting an application for funding through LCCMR at the April 6, 2010 Council meeting.
DISCUSSION
The following information is required to be available at the public hearing for the Natural and
Scenic Area Grant Program:
1. Project scope and the type of activities involved
The project is acquisition of approximately 33 acres of rural agricultural property as
shown on the attached map.
2. Implementation schedule
The acquisition would occur once a 50% match is obtained through the Natural and
Scenic Area Grant Program, presumably in the late summer of this year.
3. Overall cost and the proposed financing for the project
The cost of acquisition is still under negotiation. City funds for this project originated
from the Open Space Bond Referendum approved by residents in 2006.
4. Costs to be assessed to community residents
Project costs will not be assessed to residents. City funds for this project originated from
the Open Space Bond Referendum approved by residents in 2006.
5. Other associated project costs such as maintenance expenses, etc.
The intent is for the land to be maintained in a natural state. Any future projects that
require more than staff can provide will be determined when other funds, volunteers, and
opportunities can be assembled.
ACTION REQUESTED
The Council is asked to hold a public hearing and to approve or deny the attached resolution
authorizing the grant application to the DNR Natural and Scenic Area Grant Program. Please
note that this resolution is in a form that was provided with the grant application packet.
Attachment
Resolution DNR Natural and Scenic Area Grant Program
Map
Respectfully; submitted,
1. '~
ourtn y Be arz .
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTYOFANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RES. NO R
A RESOLUTION APPROVING APPLICATION TO THE MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF
NATURAL RESOURCES FOR THE 2010 NATURAL AND SCENIC AREA GRANT
PROGRAM
BE IT RESOLVED that The City of Andover acts as legal sponsor for the project contained in
the Natural and Scenic Area Grant Program Application to be submitted on March 31, 20 I 0 and
that the City Planner is hereby authorized to apply to the Department of Natural Resources for
funding of this project on behalf of The City of Andover.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that The City of Andover has the legal authority to apply for
financial assistance, and financial capability to meet the match requirement and ensure adequate
management and protection.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that The City of Andover has not incurred any development
costs described on Item 4 and has not entered into a written purchase agreement to acquire the
property described on Item 4.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that upon approval of its application by the state, the City of
Andover may enter into an agreement with the State of Minnesota for the above-referenced
project, and that The City of Andover certifies that it will comply with all applicable laws and
regulations as stated in the grant agreement including dedicating the property for natural and/or
scenic uses into perpetuity.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the City Planner is hereby authorized to execute
such agreements as are necessary to implement the project on behalf of the applicant.
I CERTIFY THAT the above resolution was adopted by the City Council of The City of
Andover on March 16, 2010.
SIGNED: WITNESSED:
(Signature) (Signature)
(Title) (Date) (Title) (Date)
9\NDOVEi4 2010 DNR Natural and Scenic Area Grant Application
Incorporated Location Map
1974
- Subject Property
N
W-<?-E
S
C I T Y o F @
NDOVE
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayo, ""d CounciImomebe" ~
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
Will Neumeister, Community Develop nt Director {-1/ ~
FROM: Angie Perera, Associate Planner ~'\.tf
DATE: March 16,2010
SUBJECT: Consider City Code Amendment! Adding Section 9-13 & Amending Sections of
Title 12/Wind Turbines.
INTRODUCTION
The City Code does not currently regulate wind turbines and the City has received a few inquiries
from residents wanting to erect small residential/non-commercial wind turbines (aka: Wind
Energy Conversion Systems or WECS) within residential districts. The City Council has
previously discussed this item and suggested moving forward by obtaining feedback from the
Planning and Zoning Commission through a code amendment similar to that of the City of
Oakdale's City Code on wind turbines.
DISCUSSION
The Planning Commission reviewed a draft code amendment and their feedback was summarized
in the staff report that was presented recently at the February I ih City Council meeting. The
minutes from that meeting are attached with this report for reference. Based on direction given by
the City Council staff has separated the three types of wind energy conversion systems (WECS),
revised the draft language and summarized the proposed changes below.
Summarized Draft amendments as proposed:
Page I
. Separated Residential, Commercial, and Roof Mounted WECS into separate sections
within this chapter. (Sec. 9-13-4, 9-13-5, and 9-13-6)
Page 2
. Removed Windmill definition and referenced agricultural and decorative windmills as
being exempt within the definition for Wind Energy Conversion System (WECS).
. Included a definition for Roof Mounted WECS.
. Included language that prohibits Roof Mounted WECS inside the Municipal Urban Service
Area (MUSA) (Sec. 9-13-3, 2b).
I
Page 2-3
. Section 9-13-3, General Standards apply to all three WECS rather than duplicating this
entire section within each of the separate sections for each of the three WECS.
Page 3-4
. Included Section 9-13-4 for Residential WECS.
. Included $300,000 liability insurance under permit requirements.
Page 4-6
. Included Section 9-13-5 for Commercial WECS.
. Included $500,000 liability insurance under permit requirements.
Page 5-6
. Included Section 9-13-6 for Roof Mounted WECS.
. Included $300,000 liability insurance under permit requirements.
. Prohibited within MUSA area and only allowed outside of MUSA area on lots of at least
two and a half (2.5) acres in size (Sec. 9-13-6, A.).
Page 7
. Included exceptions for agricultural and decorative windmills in Section 9-13-7.
Page 8
. Included height exemptions for WECS under the minimum district requirements (sec. 12-3-
5.2.g.)
Page 9
. Included for reference purposes only.
Page 10
. Included WECS into table of permitted, conditional, and prohibited use chart.
ACTION REQUESTED
The Council is requested to review and adopt the proposed ordinance as drafted (or with
modifications) and also adopt the summary ordinance that will be published in the Anoka Union.
Attachments
Summary ordinance for publication
Draft Ordinance Amendments
Minutes from the February I ih City Council Workshop meeting
2
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
ORDINANCE NO. SUMMARY
-
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CODE SECTIONS
BY ADDING CHAPTER # 13, WIND ENERGY CONVERSION SYSTEMS
TO TITLE 9 AND AMENDING TITLE 12, SECTIONS 12-12 AND 12-3-5.
STATUTORY AUTHORIZATION AND POLICY
Statutory Authorization
This ordinance is adopted pursuant to the authorization and policies contained in
Minnesota Statute 462.
Policy
Chapter # 13 of Title 9 is being added and minor amendments are being made to chapters
# 3 and # 12 within Title 12 of the Andover City Code, amending language for
establishing certain provisions for Wind Energy Conversion Systems (WECS).
GENERAL PROVISIONS AND DEFINITIONS
Jurisdiction
The provisions of this Ordinance shall apply to the City of Andover.
Enforcement
The City Administrator or his/her designee shall have the authority to enforce the
provisions of this ordinance.
Interpretation
Interpretation of the provisions ofthis ordinance shall be held to be the minimum
requirements and shall be liberally construed in the favor of the governing body. A
printed copy ofthis ordinance is available for inspection by any person during regular
hours of the City Clerk.
Adopted by the City Council ofthe City of Andover on this 16th day of March, 2010.
ATTEST: CITY OF ANDOVER
Michelle Hartner, Deputy City Clerk Michael R. Gamache, Mayor
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTYOFANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
ORDINANCE NO. -
THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ANDOVER DOES HEREBY ORDAIN AS
FOLLOWS:
CITY CODE TITLE 9: BUILDING REGULATIONS
CHAPTER 13: WIND ENERGY CONVERSION SYSTEMS
CITY CODE TITLE 12: ZONING REGULATIONS
CHAPTER 3: ZONING DISTRICTS AND MAP
CHAPTER 12: PERMITTED, CONDITIONAL AND PROHIBITED USES
ENUMERATED
(Strikeouts are language to be removed and underlining represents new language to be
added)
TITLE 9
Chapter 13
Wind Enerav Conversion Systems
SECTION
9-13-1: Purpose and Intent
9-13-2: Definitions
-< 9-13-3: General Standards
9-13-4: Residential WECS
~ 9-13-5:
Commercial WECS
~ 9-13-6: Roof Mounted WECS
ys. 9-13-7: Exceptions to the Requirements of this Chapter
9-13-1 : PURPOSE AND INTENT: The purpose of this chapter is to
promote the safe. effective and efficient use of alternative enerqv sources and
systems as the technoloqv becomes available. The purpose of this chapter is
also to establish predictable and balanced requlations for the establishment of
commercial. residential. and roof mounted WECS in the locations and
circumstances under which the use may be established without detriment to the
public health. safety and welfare of the neiqhborinq property owners and
occupants.
9-13-2: DEFINITIONS: The followinq words and terms shall have followinq
meaninqs when used in this chapter:
WIND ENERGY
CONVERSION SYSTEM (WECS): Anv device such as a wind charqer, or
wind turbine. which converts wind
I
~~fA~
). ~
,. c
~"'A'"
enerqv to a form of usable enerqv.
Windmills used for aqricultural purposes
such as for pumpinq water or feedinq
livestock and decorative windmills that
are less than thirty five (35) feet in
heiqht shall be excluded from this
definition.
COMMERCIAL WECS: Means a WECS of forty (40) kilowatts or
more in total name plate qeneratinq
capacity.
RESIDENTIAL WECS: Means a WECS of less than forty (40)
kilowatts in total name plate qeneratinq
"fII.~~ ROOF MOUNTED WECS: capacity.
Means a WECS mounted on top of a
Stf. WECS HEIGHT: buildinq, as set forth in Section 9-9-3.
The heiqht of the tower/pole plus the
rotor radius.
9-13-3: GENERAL STANDARDS: The followinq qeneral standards are
requirements of the three types of Wind Enerqv Conversions Systems (WECS):
Residential WECS. Commercial WECS. and Roof Mounted WECS that are
requlated within the City of Andover.
1) No more than one Wind Enerqv Conversion System (WECS) shall be
permitted per lot.
2) WECS PROHIBITED:
a) WECS shall be prohibited within the City of Andover on any parcel
located within the Scenic River Way or on any land within the
Waste Disposal Enqineerinq (WDE) Landfill site.
b) Roof mounted WECS shall be prohibited on any parcel located
within the City of Andover's Municipal Urban Service Area (MUSA).
3) SETBACKS: The setbacks shall be at least the followinq distances:
a) From the nearest dwellinq, school, business or other habitable
structure: 300 feet or 1.5 times the heiqht of the WECS, whichever
is qreater.
b) From the nearest public riqht-of-wav: 300 feet or 1.5 times the
heiqht of the WECS, whichever is qreater.
c) From the nearest property line: 300 feet or 1.5 times the heiqht of
the WECS, whichever is qreater. In no instance shall any portion of
2
"f.U^~.v,:
.. -
i-" ~P.w
. .
'. '\,
the WECS extend over any property line, includinQ the full arc area
created by any blades used in the system.
d) From recreational fields: 300 feet or 1.5 times the heiQht of the
WECS, whichever is Qreater. However, in no instance shall any
portion of the WECS extend over any blades use in the system.
e) No portion of the WECS, includinQ the full arc area created by any
blades used in the system, shall extend over any aboveQround
power line or drainaQe and utility easement.
4) The WECS shall be eauipped with both a manual and an automatic
brakinQ device capable of stoppinQ the WECS operation in hiQh winds.
5) No WECS shall have affixed or attached IiQhts, reflectors, flashers or any
other illumination, except for those devices required by the Federal
Aviation Administration.
6) The WECS shall be filtered, shielded or otherwise be desiQned and
constructed so as not to cause electrical. radio frequency, television, and
other communication siQnal interference.
7) All obsolete and unused towers and equipment shall be removed within
twelve (12) months of cessation of operation of the site, unless the City
Council Qrants an exemption or an extension by amendinQ the conditional
use permit.
8) WECS installed in accordance with the reauirements of this chapter shall
not Qenerate power as a commercial enterprise, as defined by the State of
Minnesota Public Utilities Commission. Power can be sold back to the
distribution Qrid but no "wind farms" are allowed.
9) Noise. All WECS shall complv with the Minnesota Pollution Control
AQency (MPCA) standards for noise and those standards set forth in Title
5, Chapter 6 of the City of Andover's City Code.
10)AII WECS shall comply with all applicable state and federal reQulations,
standards, includinQ the uniform buildinQ code as adopted by the state of
Minnesota: national electrical code as adopted by the state of Minnesota:
Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) requirements; and Minnesota
Pollution Control AQency (MPCA)/Environmental Protection AQency (EPA)
reQulations (hazardous waste, construction, stormwater, etc.)
11 )Violation; Revocation of Permit: Violation of any provision of this chapter is
Qrounds for revocation of a conditional use permit for a WECS and/or
removal of a WECS.
9-13-4: RESIDENTIAL WECS:
3
A. LOCATION: Residential WECS shall be allowed as a conditional use on
parcels of land meetinq the setback requirements listed in Section 9-13-3 and in
accordance with the permit and requlations established in this chapter.
B. DESIGN REQUIREMENTS:
1) Blade arcs created bv the WECS shall have a minimum of thirty (30) feet
of clearance over any accessory structure or tree within the full arc area
created bv any blades used in the system.
2) The WECS. includinq the blades, shall be qrounded and shielded to
protect aqainst natural Iiqhtninq strikes in conformance with the National
Electrical Code.
3) The WECS shall not include a tower-c1imbinq apparatus within twelve (12)
feet of the Qround.
4) The WECS shall displav a siqn posted at the base of the tower, not to
exceed two (2) square feet in area. The siqn shall contain the following
information:
a) A warninq of hiqh voltaQe,
b) The manufacture's name,
c) An ememencv telephone number.
d) The emerQencv shutdown procedures,
e) Additional siqns may be required on the basis of individual
applications as safetv needs dictate or as identified in the
conditional use permit.
C. PERMIT REQUIREMENTS: A conditional use permit and a buildinq permit
shall be required prior to the erection of each WECS. An approved conditional
use permit shall be required prior to obtaininQ a buildinq permit. No existinq
WECS shall be phvsicallv altered without requirinq an amendment to the
conditional use permit unless it is beinq removed from the property or throuqh
standard maintenance that does not expand the arc area or the heiQht of the
structure of the approved conditional use permit.
1) Conditional Use Permit: A conditional use permit shall be required for
, each WECS in all zoninQ districts unless otherwise noted. Such conditions
shall at a minimum: a) meet the permit and requlations established in this
chapter and: b) the applicant for the conditional use permit shall deposit
~. with the City Clerk a policv of liability insurance indemnifvinq the applicant
from liabilitv for personal iniury or property damaqe in the sum of at least
< $300,000. The policv of insurance so deposited shall contain a clause
obliqatinq the company issuinq the same to qive at least thirty (30) days
written notice to the City before cancellation thereof, the conditional use
and buildinQ permits to be automaticallv revoked upon the lapse or
termination of said policv.
4
2) Buildinq Permit: A buildinq permit shall be required for the construction of
a WECS.
9-13-5: COMMERCIAL WECS:
A. LOCA TlON: Commercial WECS shall be allowed as a conditional use on
parcels of land with a minimum of at least five (5) acres in size and in accordance
with the permit and requlations established in this chapter.
B. DESIGN REQUIREMENTS:
1) Blade arcs created by the WECS shall have a minimum of thirty (30) feet
of clearance over any accessory structure or tree within the full arc area
created by any blades used in the system.
2) The WECS. includinq the blades. shall be qrounded and shielded to
protect aqainst natural Iiqhtninq strikes in conformance with the National
Electrical Code.
3) The WECS shall not include a tower-c1imbinq apparatus within twelve (12)
feet of the qround.
4) The WECS shall display a siqn posted at the base of the tower, not to
exceed two (2) square feet in area. The siqn shall contain the following
information:
a) A warninq of hiqh voltaqe.
b) The manufacture's name,
c) An emerqency telephone number.
d) The emerqency shutdown procedures,
e) Additional siqns may be required on the basis of individual
applications as safety needs dictate or as identified in the
conditional use permit.
C. PERMIT REQUIREMENTS: A conditional use permit and a buildinq permit
shall be required prior to the erection of each WECS. An approved conditional
use permit shall be required prior to obtaininq a buildinq permit. No existinq
WECS shall be physically altered without requirinq an amendment to the
conditional use permit unless it is beinq removed from the property or throuqh
standard maintenance that does not expand the arc area or the heiqht of the
structure of the approved conditional use permit.
1) Conditional Use Permit: A conditional use permit shall be required for
each WECS in all zoninq districts unless otherwise noted. Such conditions
shall at a minimum: a) meet the permit and requlations established in this
chapter and; b) the applicant for the conditional use permit shall deposit
with the City Clerk a policy of liability insurance indemnifyinq the applicant
from liability for personal iniury or property damaqe in the sum of at least
5
~
~.< $500,000. The policy of insurance so deposited shall contain a clause
obliqatinq the company issuinq the same to qive at least thirty (30) days
written notice to the City before cancellation thereof, the conditional use
and buildinq permits to be automatically revoked upon the lapse or
termination of said policy.
2) Buildinq Permit: A buildinq permit shall be required for the construction of
a WECS.
9-13-6: ROOF MOUNTED WECS:
A. LOCATION: A WECS sited on top of a buildinq shall be allowed as a
conditional use only on parcels of land outside of the City of Andover's Municipal
Urban Service Area (MUSA) with a minimum of at least two and a half (2.5) acres
in size and in accordance with the permit and requlations established in this
chapter.
B. DESIGN REQUIREMENTS:
1) The WECS must be less than ten (10) kilowatts qeneratinq capacity.
2) The WECS shall not extend hiqher than fifteen feet (15') above the
maximum heiqht allowed for the structure (ie. principal, accessory
structure's maximum heiqht plus 15 feet) in which the WECS is mounted
on.
3) Each WECS shall comply with applicable provisions of the Minnesota
State Buildinq Code.
4) Certification of compliance by a state professional enqineer is required.
C. PERMIT REQUIREMENTS: A conditional use permit and a buildinq permit
shall be required prior to the erection of each WECS. An approved conditional
use permit shall be required prior to obtaininq a buildinq permit. No existinq
WECS shall be physically altered without requirinq an amendment to the
conditional use permit unless it is beinq removed from the property or throuqh
standard maintenance that does not expand the arc area or the heiqht of the
structure of the approved conditional use permit.
1) Conditional Use Permit: A conditional use permit shall be required for
each WECS in all zoninq districts unless otherwise noted. Such conditions
tJ shall at a minimum: a) meet the permit and requlations established in this
chapter and; b) the applicant for the conditional use permit shall deposit
(W.+. ( with the City Clerk a policy of liability insurance indemnifyinq the applicant
from liability for personal iniury or property damaqe in the sum of at least
$300,000. The policy of insurance so deposited shall contain a clause
obliqatinq the company issuinq the same to qive at least thirty (30) days
written notice to the City before cancellation thereof, the conditional use
6
l!
..(..
.;"~l>
~ . .
'Ifi-- . '~"\,k
1J
" ~.~
":.:. :~
. '/' . fJ :4J.-i'
i'?:
"
..
and buildinq permits to be automatically revoked upon the lapse or
termination of said policy.
2) Buildinq Permit: A buildinq permit shall be required for the construction of
a WECS.
9-13-7: EXCEPTIONS: Exceptions to the requirements of this chapter shall
include windmills used for aqricultural purposes such as for pumpinq water or
feedinq livestock and decorative windmills that are less than thirty five (35) feet in
heiqht. Said such exceptions shall be allowed provided that they meet the
followinq:
1) Windmill is not detrimental to the public health, safety and welfare of the
neiqhborinq property owners and occupants.
2) Windmill does constitute a Public Nuisance as outlined in Title 4: Public
Health and Safety, of the City Code.
7
TITLE 12
CHAPTER 3
12-3-5: MINIMUM DISTRICT REQUIREMENTS:
B, Maximum Height:
1. Principal Structure Height: A Conditional Use Permit may be granted
to allow principal buildings to exceed the height limits imposed by
provisions of this title provided it is determined that:
a. Adequate fire protection and other safety features are provided.
b. The height and bulk of the building will not destroy a scenic or
appropriate view, will not shut off light and air from surrounding
properties, or otherwise be detrimental to the public.
c. In no event, however, shall any building occupy more than the
permitted percentage of lot area as provided in this title. (Amended
Ord. 314,10-4-05)
2. Exemptions From Height Limits: Height limitations shall not apply to
the following:
a. Barns, silos and other agricultural structures for rural agricultural
uses,
b. Church spires, steeples, belfries, cupolas and domes
c. Chimneys, flagpoles
d. Public utility facilities
e. Transmission towers and antennae subject to City Code 9-12
f. Parapet walls extending not more than four feet (4') above the
height of the building. (Amended Ord. 314 10-4-2005)
-7 q, Wind Enerqy Conversion Systems (WECS) subiect to City Code
Title 9, Chapter # 13.
(see chart on following pages)
8
<r:
>l-<>l-<
<r: U><><U U
>l-<
~U <r:
>l-<>l-<
~ <r: U><><U U
0U >l-< & <r:
h- U >l-<
U ~ u><><u U
00.
k-
~ ~ u><><U U
'"
.... '"
E~ _ <r: u><>< >l-< >l-<
~.- ~ >l-<
...;l
~ u><><
o >l-<
~
OJ
~ U
-;;<";l u><>< U
..,!. is:S
~ U
~ ~~ u><>< U
rFJ Q....
~ N~
00 · U
>:;;l ~ lfl U"""""" U
~ ~'y; , r-. r-.
~ gp.9 '" ~ .... ~ ~
Eo-< :=:"t<i~o:IE~
..... 0) ~.9 '2 ~ 'y; '" U
E9 ~ggjou~ "7' U><>< U
..... ~~o:I{J01)o:I ~ >l-<
~ Q) Od-
o 0. .. 1l ~ ." " ~ U
~ ~~~ ~~ ~ U><>< U
~ "a ~ e '"..8 <l) ~ >l-< >l-< U
M~ ~~~Zoo~ U ~
~~ ~~~~z'u~ <";l U u><>< U
10;"'< ~0...;l 00....., ~ >l-<>l-<
~~ ,.<<
~~ U
~Z ~ U >< >< U U U
.=0 ~ ~ >l-< U
uE= 0
.....
~ ,,~ ". ~
Z .9 ~ <l) ~ -0 -B ._
O ::::.... "d _~'+-< <)
<l) "C 0 "'''do g
U ~ Q; U ~g~ o::l
~ ;<;:: ~ ;;;<)~ <)
~ <l):S:8 <l)o~ iR
~ "a.Cl U ~""'C ~
Eo-< '.;:l e ~ ~ o::l (;>1:: S
.... 3, .. -ii ~~. _ ~ ~ 0
~..... :;s .-6 ]I 'c; g t;:: ~ ~ -@ ~ g .9
I en - -- ~ s::: Q <U._ 0._ ~
..... ~ .. . - o::l <l) ~ <l) ::::..... o::l
'<l) ~.... ..<:: ~..<:: o::l o::l t>
'O~"I1fL ~ :;:" i h ~ 1i>.g .9 ~ ~ 8
.... .. 0 "0 ~"~ ~ 0 0 ._
A!J ;:: ..<:: 0 .... s ..... -, V'l 0 0 c;
n "~ u~ ~~ll~e ~..
~ · 0 ~< ~~8~_ 0 80 <l)
~ e Q __r:/J -~~-<l) o::l _
Q) U ~ ~ 't:: o::l ~.- <l) ..<::..<::._
'" ~"d ..... <l)~,<=< ..... c:: .n
on · ".9.. EO '''o~. .. 0
<l):j:l :'~....._;> "'<l) ~ S
;> ,- ~ ~ Q) 2 .- ..... g t;:: ~"t<i._ 0
.. '0 ~ ~ E ~.; ] S ~ g.o I >., '" ~ ~ ~ 1:: "S
.... · ~ · .. - o. - Ol~ ~ 0 . ~ 0 "
Q) <l) .i:: >l-< OJ 9 g 9 g ~ '!;:E I ~ '.g I::' '" ~ I _ I,,::, 0
'__&a.. g..o_ ~ "'~o>" "_ "-'B" ~";;8<;:
· 'IQI'C .... · < " '" " :l: ~ -8 - "~ _.. ~ . . 00 "jj 0...,
.. '" .. ~ .". "".8.= "" 0 ~.9 8 · ~ ~ ~ " 0
Plp)r... ~ Jl s] 8 · .!! ~ 2 ';'.:: :l... 'E " @ >i .~ ~ ~"i< 8 q
~ <l) .- '.;:l .;::: a ~ "'" J, '" ~ .2- <l) <) ...., 6' <l) ~ o::l 00 I::: .s ~ (.)
:j:l .- :::: -, ., <l) Q) Q) <) ~ ~ <l) o::l.... ._ ~ <l) <)
~ '-EE~~,"<> ""..~"o~.o.oo.B"i:l",.".
"'" <l) ~ 0 , - Q;.y; ~ ::s .... ......;: 0. 9 .~ (]) Q) l::l 00 u::l "- i _ "~
- · · .. o. 0 .. 0 -.. . Ii ~.. 0 > '" 0 _ . 8 ~ ~ .. ..
~ >l-<<U>l-<@.! -d' .nEl....~-o"do::l~.g..g..g~~"'O~~o::lE
· ,..0...e .!! ~11"JI~~~III.lj~::~
e ~~~'~~E01::"S"S~o::laiaauuu
'" "dbJ~~,;;i<l)~<r:<r:<r:<r:o:I_
~ <r:<r:<r:<r:",~
,~)f".\~t}~*~~'
~\)
. JinO
\,..
~~) aU
C;,~ . "
t..- "'JY"d
.h'2~
2,~rc
~
. ": .
-
hi ~
>< U U >l-< >l-<>l-<
>< >l-< U >l-< >l-< >l-< >l-< UI
>< U UI
>< U UI
>< >l-< UI
>< UI
U >< UI
U >< UI
U >< UI
U >< UI
U >< UI
.
U >< UI
3 <0
..-
-
~
>< UI """"""'- '"
U J
'+-< /ew{ ~
0
~ ~ ~ ~
- e
~ ~._ "d
0) a.S ~ s
~ ~ e 0 0
"d ,- '" "d .n
a "d <l) a <r:
~ ~ ~ ~ r:/J
~ & t;:: o::l o::l ~
^ ~ '" ~~~
o::l B (5 en V ;... Q)
'" '" o::l "d <l)"<::
;s" - 0 o ;> .....
o::l ..<:: I 0"- e
S 0 fii '" ~ .-
].€ '" ._ Q...c:
.~ OJ U..<::.- .t::
..<:: ~ ~C:::~~ ~
~ Q) '0 0
'" .... 'S 00"d
..... ;s's: 0 ,--""r:/JE
.- ~ ..<::
"a o <l) '" '" 0 00 ........ t::.-
'" .......<:: ~ ~ Q} e .... ,- P-
'-' <l) <l) .....
- ..... ~ ~ "d <l)<l)"d"<::
'" o::l ~ +J "'9 <1) 0 -.....
~ 15'- <l) Q} a k1!]E
.9 s.~ :g :g -
'" '" '" "," r:/J U'- r:/J
.... ";:i ";:i '" ~ ~U
<l) .;::~ <l)
;> 0 0 .~ 0\ S ~
~ "'a) 0 0 0 .S '"
0 "d ~ '" lU~Q)
~ ~ ~ ~ <l)
0 <l) .... 'i "d '-' '-' ..0 '" ;>.t:: t;J "d
<l) .no <l) '" I':i E- <l)
'" '" <l)
S ~gf <l) '" 0 0 <l)" ~ o..<::r:/J.....
0 8. ~ :s :5 "d 'y; U.t:: ~ S
'-' 11
..<:: S:.e '" '" <3 <3 '" ~ ~ 0
..0 ...c: or;: Q} Q} '" ..0 .... <l) S
's .~ ~ OJ OJ ~ ~ OJ ~ ~ <l)0~,+-<
'" '" ~ ~ o::l ~~"dO
~ ~ jg <l) <l) ~ ~ 0 o '" w.~ <l) ~
<3 <3 ';::: .;::: .~ ..<:: <l) "2 ....
, '" 0 <l) - "d ._
0 ,- :E <l) ~ t;J 0
<l) '" ..<:: 0 .S e ~ 0)
~ '" .... <l) <l) "'a) 0 ~~ ~ 0 g.t::I)
::J g :> :> :> :> :> o .... '"
/""
f
!
1
i
!
i
,
,
1 ~
~
\
,
,
1
t
\
,
,
,
i
,
~
. !
~. ~:
\;. i
Q ; ~
-.).'tI ,...#",-,,10('''.... I
"'" , t
t !
'(L j
" ~
"\~ '" ",',,-Ji"
"-
...
.,. I
,
~ \
!
,
~ ~
I
~ ,
,
'...~#J-
,
". 'j
>>
i" . ,
. . ....,.
~""'...,.'"..;;.~c,<"-
,
.
I
>
I
\
i
!
,
'~ t
j
. i
'.. /
'''_'.",-,c:>.'#~'
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes - February 17, 2010
Pa e4
~ WIND TURBINE DISCUSSION
Ms. Perera stated she is checking as to whether the Council is still interested in regulating wind
turbines and if so, what lot restrictions are the Council looking for. She stated she had spoken with
the City Attorney and it was his recommendation that the Council either approve or restrict them in
the City before somebody challenged the Ordinance,
Councilmember Knight stated he would be in favor of a moratorium until there is an inquiry for a
wind turbine. He asked if the windmills on the farms within the City would be affected. Mr.
Dickinson responded for agricultural purposes windmills are allowed, as long as they are not
generating electricity to be sold to the grid. He noted a moratorium was stating that the City was still
in the process of looking at wind turbines. He did not believe a wind turbine would be requested
within the next couple of months and with a moratorium there is a process that would need to be
followed and the Council must have a conclusion at the end ofthe moratorium,
Mr. Bednarz indicated a moratorium could be for 18 months and then it could be renewed for
another 18 months.
Councilmember Trude expressed concern that somebody could come in and build whatever they
wanted before the City had regulations. She believed there is a gap in the Ordinances regarding wind
turbines.
Councilmember Jacobson stated due to the density of the lots, in the southern part of the City wind
turbines are not practical due to the topography. He noted in the northern part of the City on a 2.5
acre lot with restrictions, a lot of those lots are also not suitable. He indicated if this is a conditional
use permit process, the cost would be around $1,000 for a CUP which would price most of the
people out of entering an exploration of placing a turbine. He indicated he is not in favor of wind
turbines as there is not enough wind around the City and a person would not recover their money by
putting a wind turbine in.
Mayor Gamache stated a moratorium set an expectation that something is going to be done. Mr.
Dickinson recommended adopting what the Council currently had and if Council wanted to make it
stricter they could do that in the future. He noted what the Council had before them is very strict.
He stated a wind turbine needed a 12-15 mph average daily wind speed and Andover had an average
daily wind speed of approximately 9 mph, so it would not be cost effective for a resident to put one
in, one put in would be more of a personal statement.
Councilmember Jacobson recommended staff separate the residential and business sections.
Mr. Dickinson asked if they should all be conditional use permits. Council agreed they should all be
CUP's.
- ,,-
@
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.C1.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Council Members
CC: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator orks/City Engineer"J:::iP:b
David D. Berkowitz, Director ofPu
FROM: Todd J. Haas, Asst. Public Works Director
SUBJECT: Consider Appointments/Coon Creek Watershed District Vacancies-
Engineering
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
This item is in regard to recommending to the Anoka County Board of Commissioners an
individual or individuals to serve as a manager on the Coon Creek Watershed District (CCWD).
DISCUSSION
There are two managers (Warren Hoffman and Bill MacNally) whose term expires on May 27,
2010 for the Coon Creek Watershed District Board. Both Mr. Hoffman and Mr, MacNa1ly have
requested to be reappointed to serve on the CCWD board.
The City of Andover has received one request from Charles Ellis, who is a resident of Andover
and resides within the CCWD, would like to be considered for the board (see attached e-mail).
An article was placed in the current Andover newsletter for those that were interested in serving
on the board and Anoka County had previously placed a public notice in the Anoka County
Union and Forest Lake Times.
ACTION REQUIRED
The City Council is requested to consider submitting a letter recommending an individual or
individuals to the Anoka County Board of Commissioners as to serve on the Coon Creek
Watershed District board.
Respectfully submitted,
&&:~
./ ./ ,/
Attaclunents: Coon Creek Watershed District Letter, Map, and e-mail from Charles Ellis
COUNTY OF ANOKA
OFFICE OF COUNTY ADMINISTRATION
GOVERNMENT CENTER
2100 3RD AVENUE STE 700 . ANOKA, MN 55303-5024
(763) 323-5700
January 25,2010
TERRY L. JOHNSON
County Administrator This letter sent to elected
officials of the City of
Andover.
The Honorable Mike Gamache
Mayor, City of Andover
2815 134th Avenue NW
Andover, MN 55304
RE: Coon Creek Watershed District Appointment
Dear Mayor Gamache:
In accordance with the provisions of Minn. Stat. S 103B.227,Anoka County in January 2010
published a notice that the terms will expire for managers on the Coon Creek Watershed' Di~trict
Board of Managers. The notice publication requirement applies because Coon Creek Watershed
District is considered a watershed management organization. The published notice must state that
persons interested in being appointed may submit their names to the appointing authority, which is
the county board, for a watershed district appointment. For your information, a copy of the notice is .
attached.
In appointing a manager to the Coon Creek Watershed Qistrict, Minn. Stat. S 103D.311 is also
applicable. This statute requires a county board to appoint a manager for a watershed district from a
,list of persons nominated jointly or severally by the municipalities within the district if a list(s) is
submitted 60 days before the manager's term of office expires or to appoint a manager who resides
iri a city that fails to submit a list. If there is a desire of jointly submitting a list for the manager
appointment, you may wish to confer with affected cities and jointly submit the list. The cities with
territory located in the Coon Creek Watershed District are Andover, Blaine, Columbus, Coon
Rapids, and Ham Lake.
In order for names submitted to the county to be considered a list under the statutory definition, the
list must contain the names of at least three nominees eligible to be appointed, To be eligible for an
appointment, a nominee must reside within the watershed district boundaries, be a voting resident of
the district, and not be a public officer of the county, state, or federal government (except that a soil
and water conservation supervisor can be appointed). The county board may choose to appoint
someone who is not on a list if the person resides in a city that did not submit a list.
FAX: 763-323-5682 Affirmative Action I Equal Opportunity Employer TDD/TTY: 763-323-5289
,.
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN pursuant to Minn. Stat. ~ 103B.227 and ~ 103D.311 that
vacancies will occur on the Coon Creek Watershed District Board of Managers due to the
expiration on May 27, 2010, of the terms of Warren Hoffman and Bill MacNally. Term of the
appointments is for three years, Managers are eligible to be reappointed. Persons interested in
being appointed to serve on the Coon Creek Watershed District Board of Managers may submit
their names for consideration to the Anoka County Board of Commissioners, the appointing
authority. Minn. Stat. ~ 103D.311 permits the cities in the district to submit a list(s) of
nominations to the county board. If a valid list(s) containing at least three eligible nominees for
a manager's position is submitted at least 60 days prior to the expiration of the terms, the Anoka
County Board of Commissioners is required to make appointments either from the list(s) or to
appoint a manager who resides in a city that fails to submit a list. Since a list may be submitted,
persons interested in being considered for appointment may wish to contact their city to request
to be included on a list of nominations, In the absence of a valid list, the Anoka County Board of
Commissioners may appoint any voting resident of the Coon Creek Watershed District who is
not a public officer of the county, state, or federal government.
s/.
Assistant County Attorney
PUBLISH IN: Anoka County Union, January 22,2010
Forest Lake Times, January 28,2010
cc: Bobbie Koehler
Bob Parta
Terry Johnson
Diane Eichinger
"
Coon Creek Watershed District
Legend
CJ COMMISSIONER DISTRICTS
- HYDROLOGIC AREAS oK
COMMUNITIES w+~
ANDOVER
BLAINE
l1l1I COLUMBUS 8
COON RAPIDS
~f~ HAM LAKE
.;-~~~
March 25, 2009
Todd Haas
From: Charles Ellis [ I]
Sent: Tuesday, March 02, 2010 12:00 PM
To: Todd Haas
Subject: Appointments to Coon Creek Watershed District Board
Hello, Mr. Haas,
I'm interested in this appointment. I have lived in Andover for 16 years at 3122 153rd Ave. NW.
We have our own well and large gardens so the quality of Anoka County and Coon Creek Watershed water are
important to me on a personal basis. More than that though I have a longstanding interest in water issues and in
watersheds in particular.
I'm a writer, a docent at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts and a seasoned volunteer. My education includes 6
years post-college and I have a doctorate. My time is my own to schedule so I will be able to attend all
meetings of the Board.
If you would like to speak with me personally, my phone number is I .
1
@
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304 . (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CJ.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Council Members
FROM: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
SUBJECT: Schedule April EDA meeting
DATE: March 16, 2010
INTRODUCTION
The Council is requested to schedule an Economic Development Authority (EDA) meeting at
6:00 pm before the April 6, 2010 City Council meeting.
DISCUSSION
Tentative agenda items for an EDA meeting have been identified as follows:
1. Purchase Agreement/Letter of IntentJProgress Review
2. Parkside at Andover Station Update
3. TIF Project Fund Discussion - continued
4. Andover Station Maintenance Discussion
5. Other Business
Other items may be added upon request, or the meeting will be cancelled if no new
information comes forward on the identified agenda items.
ACTION REOUlRED
edule an EDA meeting at 6:00 pm before the April 6, 2010 City Council meeting.
@
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Council Members
FROM: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
SUBJECT: Schedule April Council Workshop
DATE: March 16,2010
INTRODUCTION
The Council is requested to schedule a Council Workshop for the month of March for a number
of miscellaneous business items.
DISCUSSION
Potential agenda items for a general April workshop have been identified as follows:
1. Code Amendment Discussion - Exterior Storage of Commercial Vehicles
2. Code Amendment Discussion - Recreational Vehicle Storage on Rural Lots
3. Community Education Partnership Discussion
4. 2010 - 2011 Council Goal Discussion
5, 2011-2015 Capital Improvement Plan Discussion
6. 2010 Budget Implementation Progress Report
7, 2011 Budget Development Discussion
8. Other Topics
Other items may be added upon Council request.
ACTION REQUIRED
Schedule an April Council workshop, a suggested date is April 27th at 6:00 pm or another date
and time acceptable to the Council.
'-
@
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304 . (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 . WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor and Councilmembers
FROM: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
SUBJECT: Administrator's Report
DATE: March 16,2010
The City Administrator will give a brief verbal update on various items of interest to the City
Council and to the residents at the meeting. Listed below are a few areas of interest:
1, Administration & City Department Activities
2. Update on Development Activity
3. Update on CIP Projects
4. Meeting reminders
Upon receipt of the meeting packet, if a member of the Council would like an update on a
particular item, please notifY me so an adequate update can be made.
~\NJJ
DATE March 16,2010
ITEMS GIVEN TO THE CITY COUNCIL
. February Building Report
.
PLEASE ADDRESS THESE ITEMS AT THIS MEETING OR PUT THEM ON
THE NEXT AGENDA.
THANK YOU.
G:ISTAFFIRHONDAAIAGENDAICC LIST. doc
1-3-
16 #f3
CITY OF ANDOVER
2010 Montbl Buildinl! Reoort
I
I
TO: Mayor and City Council
FROM: Don Olson
FEBRUARY
BUILDING PERMITS PermillPlan Tax
Total Valuation
10 Residential $ 22,797.82 $ 957.50
$ 23,755.32 $ 1,915,000.00
Single Family 9 19,513.41 818.50
20,331.91 1,637,000.00
Septic I 3,284.41
139.00 . 3,423.41 278,000.00
Townhome - -
- -
- Additions - -
- -
- Garages - -
- -
2 Basement Finishes 200.00 1.00
201.00 -
- Commercial Building - -
- -
- Pole B1dgslBams - -
- -
- Sheds - -
- -
- Swimming Pools - -
- -
- Chimney/StovelFireplace - -
- -
Structural Changes
-
- Porches - -
- -
- Decks - -
- -
- Gazebos - -
- -
Repair Fire Damage
-
Re-Roof
- -
2 Siding 150.00 1.00
151.00 -
3 Other 1,175.66
27.72 1,203.38 55,440.00
I Commercial Plumbing 322.16 5.50
327.66 11,000.00
3 Commercial Heating 425.10 6.13
431.23 12,250.00
I Commercial Fire Sprinkler 74.66 1.81
76.47 3,620.00
- Commercial Utilities - -
- -
- Commercial Grading - -
- -
- I
22 Total Building Permits $ 25,145.40 $ 1,000.66 $
26,146.06 $ 1,997,310.00
PERMITS PermillPlan Tax
Total Fees Collected
22 Building Permits $ 25,145.40 $ 1,000.66
$ 26,146.06
- Ag Building - -
-
- Curb Cut - -
-
- Demolition - -
-
- Fire Permits - -
-
- Footing - -
-
- Renewal - -
-
- Moving - -
-
21 Heating 1,750.00
10.50 1,760.50
6 Gas Fireplaces 450,00
3.00 453.00
18 Plumbing 1,175.00
9.00 1,184.00
15 Pumping 225,00 -
225.00
- Septic New - -
-
I Septic Repair 75.00 0.50
75.50
9 Sewer Hook-Up 225.00 -
225.00
9 Water Meter 450.00 -
450.00
- Sewer Change OverlRepair - -
-
- Water Change Over - -
-
9 Sac Retainage Fee 189,00 -
189,00
9 Sewer Admin. Fee 135,00 -
135.00
10 Certificate of Occupancy 100.00 -
100.00
10 License Verification Fee 50.00 -
50.00
- Reinspection Fee I - -
-
12 Contractor License I 600,00 -
600.00
- Rental License - Single -
-
Rental License - Multi -
-
- Health Authority - -
-
-
-
151 TOTALS $ 30,569.40 $ 1,023.66
$ 31,593.06 $ 1,997,310.00
Total Number of Homes ITD 2010
14
Total Number of Homes ITD 2009
3
Total Valuation YfDI I 2010
$ 2,785,082,00
Total Valuation ITD I 2009
$892,920,00
Total Building Department Revenue ITD 2010 $
44,917.58
Total Building Department Revenue ITD 2009
$24,573.88
C I T Y o F
NDOVE
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. . ANDOVER. MINNESOTA 55304. (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923. WWW.CI.ANDOVER.MN.US
TO: Mayor & Council Members
FROM: Jim Dickinson, City Administrator
SUBJECT: Supplemental Agenda Item for March 16,2010 City Council Meeting
DATE: March 16,2010
The City Council is requested to receive the following supplemental information.
Closed Session
Add-On Item, Discuss City of Andover Highway Right-of-Way Plat No.3 (Supplemental)