Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-10-27 WK ANDOVER CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP MEETING – OCTOBER 27, 2026 MINUTES The Workshop Meeting of the Andover City Council was called to order by Mayor Barthel, October 27, 2026, 6:00 p.m., at the Andover City Hall, 1685 Crosstown Boulevard NW, Andover, Minnesota. Councilmembers present: Rick Engelhardt, Karen Godfrey, Scott Schue, and Jonathan Shafto Councilmember absent: None Also present: City Administrator, Sarah Cotton Director of Public Works/City Engineer, David Berkowitz Recreational Facility Manager, Erick Sutherland Fire Chief, Jason Baumunk Finance Manager, Lee Brezinka Associate Planner, Aidan Breen Others REVIEW SUNSHINE PARK SKATEPARK SURVEY RESULTS/26-34 Mr. Berkowitz presented the staff report and explained the Council is requested to receive and discuss the Sunshine Park Skatepark survey results. Julia Brueckler, American Ramp Company, presented and reviewed the survey results. She also provided information about her experience in this industry. She commented the great thing about skateparks is the versatility different features provide for people of all ages and abilities. Mr. Berkowitz commented on the great experience working with American Ramp Company and the expertise and excitement they bring to the project. Councilmember Shafto asked how the bowls are drained for snow and water. Mr. Berkowitz replied there would be drainage holes. Councilmember Shafto asked about the cost to install a half pipe. Ms. Brueckler commented they could share that cost following the meeting tonight. She explained how that feature could be added as a future expansion. She stated if the Council agrees with this design, they would send quotes for the phase one and phase two designs. Mayor Barthel thanked Ms. Brueckler for her time and presentation tonight. Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 2 Jordan Landers, American Ramp Company, commented they have enjoyed working with the City on this project. DISCUSS ANDOVER CITY COUNCIL CONCERNS ABOUT FIBER PROJECTS Mr. Berkowitz presented the staff report and explained the Council is requested to discuss City Council concerns about fiber projects and direct staff on how to respond to the fiber companies with the concerns. Councilmember Shafto commented he supports a requirement for a new utility company coming to a Council worksession to go over their plan as proposed by staff. He stated that could also apply to a project with a large footprint, as that could apply to an existing utility provider. Councilmember Godfrey agreed and noted it could also help the Council to answer questions posed by residents and improve the ability to set proper expectations for residents. Councilmember Engelhardt agreed it would be helpful if they attended a meeting to receive answers to questions. Councilmember Schue stated up until now there has been no requirement. He asked what would prevent the company from coming into the community if they did not attend a meeting. Mr. Berkowitz replied the City could withhold a permit if the company chose not to attend the required meeting and noted if the utility company completed work in the right-of-way without a permit, the City would take legal action. Councilmember Schue asked if there would need to be any policy changes to make this effective. Mr. Berkowitz replied he would simply add the language to the permit application. Mayor Barthel confirmed the consensus of the Council to add the requirement for a new utility company to attend a City Council workshop. He recognized that businesses are competitors but noted that in this situation the companies are digging up people’s yards. He stated that if businesses do not want to work together, perhaps they do not belong in Andover. Ms. Cotton commented that statutorily she did not believe the City can restrict access to the right- of-way. Councilmember Shafto asked if there is any ability to advertise when an area would be available to utility providers and once that window closes, it could not be opened again for a period of time. Mr. Berkowitz replied the City would need to do that through a moratorium. He explained how permits are currently being issued and how the City is trying to control this activity. Councilmember Shafto commented it seems that this issue will continue to get worse as more companies come in and repeatedly tear up yards. Ms. Cotton commented once there is competition in the market, she believed that requests from other companies will die off. Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 3 ANDOVER COMMUNITY CENTER UPDATE Mr. Sutherland provided an overview of the Andover Community Center (ACC) operations, including facility usage, resident benefits, recreation programming, and community events. Councilmember Schue asked if there have been any complaints about the activity passes and whether 15 is not enough. Mr. Sutherland replied they have not received any complaints about that. Councilmember Godfrey asked about the stability of the packages and whether those are expanding each year. Mr. Sutherland commented that additional people set up household accounts each year, estimating a ten percent increase each year. He stated they actively market the program. Councilmember Shafto stated he supports 15 passes and continuing to offer the household accounts program. Mr. Sutherland provided additional information on the offer that is made to local Andover businesses to hold up to two meetings per month for free at the Community Center and noted that residents also receive a discount on room rentals. He provided additional information about the increased options for check-ins. He stated the walking track has been the most impactful option for residents of all ages. Mayor Barthel echoed the comments about the popularity of the walking track for people of all ages. Mr. Sutherland continued to provide a review of different events and activities. Ms. Cotton asked if the Council would like to expand the tree lighting and decorations more to City Hall or keep that more focused on the Community Center. Councilmember Schue stated while he does like decorations, he would not want to see too much burden placed on staff. Councilmember Godfrey stated in the past, there was discussion of the committee about moving the tree onto the City Hall property so that it could be seen from the road, but it was determined not to be feasible. She stated she would prefer to keep the event on one property/campus. Councilmember Shafto stated he would not want to make anyone decorate but would not want to stop someone who may be excited about doing that. Ms. Cotton commented they do not have the decorations today, so they would need to purchase lights and decorations if that were the direction. Councilmember Engelhardt commented if they do move in that direction, perhaps they allow Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 4 residents to bring in an ornament to share. Councilmember Schue stated that he likes the idea of community involvement, noting most residents have decorations they would be willing to part with. Mayor Barthel commented if there is a group of residents who want to put up decorations, that would be great, but questioned what would happen the next year when those residents do not want to volunteer, and the burden falls onto staff. He commented the event is currently set up for the Community Center and believed they should leave it at that. He noted they could place a large wreath above the door if desired. Councilmember Godfrey noted a local florist may be willing to donate a wreath. Ms. Cotton confirmed the consensus of the Council that if they want to do something, they could, but they should keep it simple. She noted they will not pursue the concept of accepting donated decorations at this time. Mr. Sutherland noted additional offerings they have made to community groups, such as hosting photos for local youth sports teams at no charge. He noted a recent data request related to how users are prioritized and provided background information. Mayor Barthel stated as a Councilmember, he does support the policy of providing first right of refusal to those who have rented the previous year. Mr. Sutherland commented they do have a history with those groups and the goal is to fill the available times. Ms. Cotton asked if the Council is still comfortable with staff using those factors in guiding the decisions towards ice and field house time. Councilmember Godfrey commented these are guidelines for consideration and recognized that staff has the ultimate decision. Councilmember Schue asked about the appeal process for someone who believes they were wronged in that process. Mr. Sutherland stated the appeal used to be heard by the Advisory Committee but noted that process has changed and reviewed the current appeal process. Councilmember Schue stated with that process, he is comfortable with the process continuing. Councilmember Shafto referenced the afterschool program being run by the Community Center and asked for an update. Mr. Sutherland stated year to date he has sold eight student activity passes through that program. He noted the previous year they sold 27. He noted last year the cost was $100 per trimester, but this year it was $100 for the entire school year. He also provided an update on staffing. Councilmember Shafto noted he continues to receive positive feedback from people outside of the community who come to the Community Center. He noted the ancillary benefit that the businesses in Andover receive from people who come to the Community Center for events. Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 5 Mayor Barthel commented on a summer camp he participated in at the Community Center and how incredible the staff was to work with. FIRE DEPARTMENT STAFFING MODEL DISCUSSION Fire Chief Baumunk presented the staff report and recommendations regarding Fire Department staffing. Staff is requesting authorization to proceed with filling one previously budgeted full- time position and transitioning to an updated duty crew operational model. Councilmember Godfrey asked about staffing on holidays. Fire Chief Baumunk provided an update on the rotating schedule, which should make things a bit more fair. Mayor Barthel noted the cost of the duty crew was cut in half, with coverage changing by only two percent. Ms. Cotton commented that Fire Chief Baumunk was able to benefit from the data that has been gathered to make smart adjustments. Councilmember Schue appreciated the flexibility in the approach, noting that they can continue to make adjustments as the data becomes available. He believed that Fire Chief Baumunk is doing a great job creating balance. Councilmember Engelhardt noted positive comments that he received about the Fire Department involvement at the middle school in support of the football game. The Council supported the staffing model as proposed. RFP FOR JOB CLASSIFICATION, COMPENSATION, AND TOTAL REWARDS Ms. Cotton presented the staff report and explained that after direction from the September 2, 2025 closed meeting, staff recently conducted a competitive Request for Proposals (RFP) process for a comprehensive Job Classification, Compensation, and Total Rewards Study. Based on staff evaluations and interviews, staff recommends selecting Baker Tilly to perform the study for a fixed fee of $25,000. The purpose of this item is to review the selection process and receive City Council consensus to finalize a professional services agreement for formal approval at the November 4, 2026 City Council meeting. Councilmember Shafto asked if there would be an additional cost for the tool that will allow the City to continue to evaluate job positions. Ms. Cotton replied there is no additional cost; it is included in the package, and provided additional information on how the tool would work. Mayor Barthel commented he was happy with the proposed cost compared to some of the other costs. The Council supported moving forward as proposed. Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 6 2027 BUDGET DEVELOPMENT PROGRESS UPDATE Mr. Brezinka presented the staff report and provided background information on the 2027 budget st process. He noted since the adoption of the preliminary levy on September 1, finalized estimates have reduced the proposed levy to $23,111,401. This represents an 8.75 percent increase in the City’s gross tax levy and a 6.23 percent increase in the City tax rate. He provided additional updates on the 2027 budget process. Councilmember Godfrey commented the health plan is still very generous to employees while managing the costs for the City. Councilmember Schue also appreciated the work that staff has done to put together this package, recognizing that healthcare costs are a challenge for everyone. Mayor Barthel confirmed the consensus of the Council in support of the proposed healthcare package. DISCUSS SIGNAGE IN PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY Mr. Berkowitz presented the staff report and explained the City Council is requested to discuss signage placed in the public right-of-way and provide direction to staff. Ms. Cotton provided additional information on input from the City Attorney on the challenges in the ability to issue fines or citations for this issue. She stated they could send letters advising the company on the sign that they are out of compliance with City Code and if there are repeat offenders, a more legal letter could be sent as a follow-up. Mr. Berkowitz stated the process would be similar to the code enforcement process and the process for meter replacement, noting that it is fairly effective. Councilmember Godfrey asked if there are problems with many companies or just a few companies. Mr. Berkowitz replied there seem to be just a few companies peppering signs along the right-of-way. Councilmember Godfrey commented she has also noticed signs on the power poles and asked how those would be regulated. Mr. Berkowitz replied those poles are still typically within the right-of- way. Councilmember Shafto commented he does not want to be in the position where they are making this a high-priority proactive effort, but perhaps the effort is focused on a few locations to keep removing signs. Mr. Berkowitz agreed they could begin by removing the signs and then follow up with the letters if the issue continues. Councilmember Engelhardt stated he has run into quite a few residents who pull signs and bring them to the recycling center. He noted those signs are typically replaced fairly quickly. Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 7 Mayor Barthel stated Mr. Sutherland had a huge problem last year with kids wreaking havoc all over the Community Center, so this year they created a membership, and that problem has been resolved. He commented he is not interested in sending the legal letter and would prefer the route of an administrative fee. He stated he is tired of these companies making the community look bad by placing their signs all over. He noted it is also disrespectful to the businesses in the community who follow the rules. He suggested that a letter be sent and then they start issuing administrative fines. He noted if there needs to be an appeal process, that could be to the City Council. Councilmember Schue believed that the sentiments of the Mayor are shared by the Council. He stated the process proposed by the Mayor would follow similar paths for other violations and has shown a record of success. Councilmember Godfrey stated the activity is prohibited in City Code and agreed that the next step would be to identify this issue as a code enforcement issue. She stated there could be a blurb in the next newsletter on this topic to remind people of the rules. Councilmember Shafto stated he generally supports this if they can handle it administratively. He asked how garage sale or youth sports signs should be dealt with, noting that he would not want to be aggressive about those. Mayor Barthel stated that those signs would be removed in less than ten days. Mr. Breen provided additional information on code enforcement and noted these instances would be occurring on City property and typically violations are sent to the property owner. He provided additional information on that process and noted that letters could be sent, but there would not be the same bite because the violation is occurring on City property. He noted some challenges that could exist for issuing citations. Councilmember Shafto asked and received clarification that the current process is just for staff to remove the signs. He stated it seems that it could be difficult to issue administrative fines, but perhaps the additional step of sending letters would be enough to resolve this issue. Ms. Cotton commented on the different types of signs that exist throughout the community and noted there would need to be equal enforcement. Mayor Barthel commented the signs are the property of the company on the sign. He believed that a letter should be sent requiring the company to pick up their signs within ten days, and if the signs are not removed, the City should charge a fee per sign to pick them up. Councilmember Shafto asked if the City would have the right to destroy the signs once collected, as there is a cost for a company to make signs. Mayor Barthel confirmed the signs can be destroyed because they are placed on City property. Mr. Berkowitz noted additional challenges with fining, as if the fine is not paid, it could not be assessed to a property. Mr. Brezinka noted those companies would eventually want to pull a Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 8 permit, and it could be specified that all fines must be paid to pull a permit. Councilmember Schue noted that some businesses placing signs in the right-of-way are typically located outside of Andover. He commented he would view nonprofit and garage sale signs differently. He stated garage sale signs will be removed before a letter is even received. Ms. Cotton commented that staff would need clear guidelines that could be applied equally. She stated a nonprofit would simply need to engage with the property owner and ask to place the sign on that property rather than within the right-of-way. Councilmember Shafto commented he has run nonprofit programs before and never placed a sign in the right-of-way. He believed the rules should be enforced equally. He recognized that campaign signs are a murky issue, as someone could easily move another candidate’s sign in vengeance. Mayor Barthel believed that the rules should be applied equally to all parties. He agreed that staff could determine the actual staff time involved to determine an appropriate fee. Councilmember Engelhardt suggested that additional language be added to the permit information for contractors that educates them on the rules for signage. Mr. Berkowitz noted the demands that this could put on staff. Councilmember Shafto commented if they send the letters, that could solve the majority of the problem on its own. Councilmember Godfrey noted a large percentage of code enforcement violations are resolved upon receipt of the first letter from the City. Mayor Barthel commented if the process is too burdensome, the language should just be removed from the City Code. Ms. Cotton believed there was good direction provided by the Council, and staff will work to develop a draft letter and next steps for enforcement. DISCUSS ROLE OF ARC IN CITY CODE Mr. Breen presented the staff report and explained the City Council is requested to review and consider the proposed changes to the role of the Andover Review Committee (ARC) as specified in City Code. The Council agreed with the proposed changes in assignment to staff as presented. Mr. Breen provided more specific examples of current assignments to ARC and how those would be proposed to be reallocated. He asked if the Council would like there to be a Board of Design Control. He noted if that is the desire, he would recommend that the Planning and Zoning Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 9 Commission be designated in that role. He stated the alternative would be to remove that step and the decisions of the City staff could be appealed to the City Council. Councilmember Godfrey asked if there is currently a Board of Design Control and if so, how that has operated. Mr. Breen replied that ARC has acted in that role. Councilmember Shafto commented he would prefer to designate the Planning and Zoning Commission to that role. Councilmember Godfrey agreed. Mr. Breen explained he would delegate the decision to the Planning and Zoning Commission. The Council agreed that the City Council should then act as the Board of Design Control. Mr. Breen asked if City staff should be used or whether the individual staff positions should be identified. It was the consensus of the Council that the term City staff should be used. Mr. Breen moved to the topic of private airfields and asked if that language should be kept. Councilmember Schue asked the number of private airfields within Andover. Mr. Breen replied there are none. Councilmember Godfrey provided information on private airfields that were approved in other communities for a resident to fly their homemade glider. She noted that was done using the variance process and that the community did not need a chapter of detail. Mayor Barthel commented there are people who have ultralights and believed that the language should remain. Councilmember Godfrey believed the language should be deleted entirely and should anyone come to the City with that type of request, it could be handled as a zoning variance. Mayor Barthel asked if that could be done if the use is not allowed. Mr. Breen commented a variance is not allowed for use. He stated that currently the use falls under a Conditional Use Permit (CUP). He stated that if the language is to be kept, it needs to be assigned to a City staff member. Mayor Barthel confirmed the consensus of the Council to leave the language as it currently exists and designate the City Administrator as the responsible party. OTHER TOPICS Mr. Berkowitz stated the Sheriff’s Department has requested a location for a drone station. He noted a potential location for that activity but noted there is a lack of power and fiber at that location. He asked if there would be interest from the Council in allowing that use at that location before the Sheriff’s Department goes too far down the path of planning. Andover City Council Workshop Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 10 Councilmember Godfrey asked if there is a reason the drone station could not be located on the Sheriff’s Office campus. It was noted that location would not allow a drone to reach the northern part of Andover. Councilmember Schue commented the drones used by the Sheriff’s Department have multiple emergency response purposes. Fire Chief Baumunk confirmed the drones that would be used would be auto-launched to scenes ahead of responders to provide real-time footage and better plan for response. Mayor Barthel asked if the Sheriff’s Department would pay for power and fiber connection. Mr. Berkowitz noted that the originally proposed location would have had availability of those utilities, but an extension would be required at the location proposed by staff. He stated they could price that out, but did not want to get too far into that process if the Council did not support the concept. Councilmember Shafto asked if the location would provide service to only Andover. He asked if there are similar drone stations in other communities. Mr. Berkowitz stated there are agreements with other cities to install similar stations. It was confirmed that this station would cover Andover and perhaps some of the border area. Mayor Barthel noted the benefit that service would provide to the Fire Department. He confirmed full support of the Council for that concept. FUTURE AGENDA ITEM REQUESTS None. COUNCIL COMMITTEE UPDATES Councilmember Godfrey noted the upcoming Community Education Advisory Council meeting that will take place this Thursday from 3:30 to 5:00 p.m. in Anoka. She stated she is unable to attend and asked if someone could attend in her place. Councilmember Engelhardt volunteered to attend. ADJOURNMENT Motion by Shafto, Seconded by Schue, to adjourn. Motion carried unanimously. The workshop meeting adjourned at 8:44 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Amanda Staple, Recording Secretary