Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-11-10 1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304 (763) 755-5100 FAX (763) 755-8923 WWW.ANDOVERMN.GOV Andover Planning and Zoning Commission MeetingAgenda November 10,2026 Andover City Hall Council Chambers 7:00 p.m. 1.Call to Order 2.Pledge of Allegiance 3.Approval of Minutes –October 27,2026, Regular Meeting 4.Public Hearing:ConsiderOrdinance Amendments to Titles11, 12, and 13related to reassigning the duties of the Andover Review Committee –City of Andover (Applicant). th 5.(Continued discussion from October 27meeting):Consider Ordinance Amendments to Title 12 related to definition changes/deletions/additions (Duplex, Triplex, and Quadrominium; Dwelling, Duplex; Dwelling Two Family; Kitchen Facilities; Accessory Apartment; etc.); requiring a Conditional Use Permit for accessory apartments; not allowing water connections toguest houses; removal of Dwelling Units of Employees on Premises in Residential Districts; removal of Dwelling Units in Commercial Industrial Districts –City of Andover (Applicant). 6.Other Business 7.Adjournment STAFF REPORT Agenda Item #3 TO: Planning and Zoning Commissioners FROM: Peter Hellegers, City Planner SUBJECT:Approval of Minutes DATE: November 10, 2026 REQUEST The Planning & Zoning Commission is requested to approve the October 27, 2026,regular meeting minutes. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION REGULARMEETING –OCTOBER 27, 9 2026 10 11 The RegularMeeting of the Andover Planning and Zoning Commission was called to 12 order by Chairperson LoehleinonOctober 27, 2026, at7:00p.m., at the Andover City 13 Hall, 1685 Crosstown Boulevard NW, Andover, Minnesota. 14 15 Commissioners present:Chairperson Nick Loehlein, Commissioners Roger Grout, 16 Scott Hudson, Chuck Naughton, Nicole Wicklund, and 17 Ryan Winge. 18 19 Commissioners absent: Jonathan Weinhold. 20 21 Also present: City Planner Peter Hellegers and Community Development 22 Director Joe Janish. 23 24 25 CALL TO ORDER 26 27 PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 28 29 APPROVAL OF MINUTES 30 31 Motion.The Chairassumed amotion to approve the September 22, 2026,Regular 32 Session Meeting Minutes as presented. Motion carries with Commissioner Hudson voting 33 present. 34 35 PUBLIC HEARING – Consider Ordinance Amendments to Title 13 Chapter 4 36 Shoreland Management Related to Definition Changes (Duplex; Triplex; and 37 Quadrominium; Deck; Impervious Surface; etc.) removal of references to Natural 38 Environmental Lakes; removal of zoning districts that no longer are used; correct 39 references; modification to height of structures to allow 35 feet instead of 25 feet; 40 increase size of guest cottage to allow up to 900 square feet – City of Andover 41 (Applicant) 42 43 Community Development Director Joe Janish presented the proposed amendments to the 44 Shoreland Management Ordinance. Other proposed amendments included updating the 45 definitions of duplexes, triplexes, quadrominiums, and decks to align with other sections 46 of the City Code. Staff also proposed eliminating obsolete references to Natural RegularSession Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 2 1 Environmental Lakes after confirming with the DNR that a previously identified wetland 2 did not require that designation. 3 4 Commissioner Ryan Winge asked whether the revised impervious surface definition was 5 consistent with other City regulations and the DNR's definition. Mr. Janish explained that 6 the language came from the DNR's updated model ordinance and was more restrictive in 7 certain respects. He confirmed that the City had historically treated gravel driveways as 8 impervious surfaces. 9 10 Commissioner Roger Grout questioned whether the impervious surface definition required 11 both greater runoff quantities and increased flow rates or whether either condition 12 independently qualified. Mr. Janish offered to seek clarification from the DNR regarding 13 the wording. 14 15 Chair Loehlein questioned whether the revised deck definition could create ambiguity for 16 structures that did not satisfy all the listed characteristics. Mr. Janish explained that other 17 definitions, including those addressing porches, could apply and that staff could interpret 18 classifications when necessary, subject to an established appeal process. 19 20 Chair Loehlein opened the public hearing at 7:15 p.m. Motion carried by unanimous 21 consent. 22 23 No members of the public were present, and staff indicated that no written public 24 comments had been received. 25 26 Chair Loehlein closed the public hearing at 7:15 p.m. Motion carriedby unanimous 27 consent. 28 29 Commissioner Nicole Wicklund thanked staff for consulting with the DNR and for their 30 efforts to ensure the proposed amendments complied with applicableregulatory standards. 31 32 Chair Loehlein identified minor capitalization corrections in the revised residential 33 dwelling definitions. Mr. Janish agreed to make the corrections. 34 35 Commissioner Grout asked whether the Commission was being requested to recommend 36 approval or denial. Mr. Janish confirmed that a recommendation to the City Council was 37 appropriate and explained that the Commission could recommend individual changes if 38 desired. He emphasized that the revised impervious surface definition was connected to 39 the proposed height increase, while the shoreline buffer requirement was connected to the 40 larger guest cottage allowance. 41 42 Motion by Commissioner Grout, seconded by Commissioner Naughton, to recommend the 43 City Council approval of the proposed amendments to Title 13, Chapter 4, including the 44 discussed clarification regarding the impervious surface definition. Motion carries by 45 unanimous consent. RegularSession Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 3 1 2 Mr. Janish indicated that the amendments were anticipated to proceed to the City Council 3 on November 17, 2026, subject to scheduling changes. 4 5 PUBLIC HEARING – Consider Ordinance Amendments to Title 12 related to definition 6 changes/deletions/additions (Duplex; Triplex; and Quadrominium; Dwelling, Duplex; 7 Dwelling Two Family; Kitchen Facilities; Accessory Apartment, etc.); requiring a 8 Conditional Use Permit for accessory apartments; not allowing water connections to 9 guest houses; removal of Dwelling Units of Employees on Premises in Residential 10 Districts; removal of Dwelling Units in Commercial Industrial Districts – City of 11 Andover (Applicant) 12 13 City Planner Peter Hellegers presented proposed amendments to Title 12 involving 14 residential dwelling definitions, accessory apartments, kitchen facilities, guest houses, and 15 employee dwelling units. 16 17 CommissionerWinge expressed substantial concern regarding the proposed accessory 18 apartment definition. Questions centered on how the City would distinguish an accessory 19 apartment from a conventional residential addition or a duplex. Mr. Hellegersexplained 20 that the intended use was similar to a mother-in-law apartment: additional living space 21 incorporated into an existing single-family residence for a family member or another 22 household. Unlike a detached accessory dwelling unit (ADU), the proposed accessory 23 apartment would remain connected to the principal residence and would not have a 24 separate exterior entrance under the proposed language. 25 26 Commissioners questioned whether the presence of a second family, separate kitchen, 27 bathroom, independent living facilities, or exterior entrance should determine the 28 classification. 29 30 Commissioner Naughton suggested that the definition should address independent living 31 space and the facilities necessary to accommodate a second household. He expressed 32 concern that the existing wording did not adequately distinguish an accessory apartment 33 from a standard addition. 34 35 Commissioner Hudson discussed the example of a walkout basement containing 36 bedrooms, a kitchen, a bathroom, and an exterior entrance. He questioned whether such an 37 arrangement would constitute an accessory apartment or duplex under the proposed 38 definitions. 39 40 Mr. Hellegers and Commissioners discussed the significance of separate entrances, 41 physical separation, and utility metering. He clarified that separate utility meters were not 42 necessarily required for a duplex. 43 44 Commissioner Wicklund recommended that staff consult the City Attorney on using the 45 term "family," noting that household arrangements and family structures vary RegularSession Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 4 1 considerably. Mr. Hellegers acknowledged the concerns and indicated that additional 2 review with the City Attorney and comparison with other communities' ordinances would 3 be beneficial. Mr. Janish stated that if Commissioners experienced difficulty interpreting 4 the language, residents would likely encounter similar problems. 5 6 The Commission also reviewed illustrative examples of attached and detached accessory 7 living arrangements. Commissioners observed that the examples did not consistently 8 reflect the proposed restrictions, reinforcing the need for clearer definitions. 9 10 Chair Loehlein opened the public hearing at 7:42 p.m. Motion carried by unanimous 11 consent. 12 13 No members of the public were present, and staff reported receiving no written comments. 14 15 Chair Loehlein closed the public hearing at 7:43 p.m. Motion carriedby unanimous 16 consent. 17 18 Chair Loehlein summarized the Commission's concerns regarding the unclear distinction 19 among an accessory apartment, a residential addition, and a duplex. Commissioners 20 generally agreed with that characterization. 21 22 Chair Loehlein also suggested revising the proposed definition of kitchen facilities to 23 avoid using the term being defined within its own definition, while retaining "kitchen 24 sink" where appropriate. 25 26 The Commission next considered proposed changes to guest house regulations, 27 particularly the prohibition on water connections. 28 29 Commissioner Grout requested clarification regarding the differences among an ADU, 30 guest house, and guest cottage. Mr. Hellegersexplained that guest cottages are regulated 31 under the Shoreland Management Ordinance, while guest houses are addressed under Title 32 12 performance standards. A guest house is a detached accessory building intended to 33 provide sleeping accommodations without kitchen facilities. He explained that the City 34 Council had expressed concern that guest houses might be converted into rental dwellings. 35 Staff proposed removing water connections to prevent theinstallation of kitchen facilities, 36 although the restriction would also eliminate bathrooms. 37 38 Chair Loehlein expressed concern that a building intended for guests would be impractical 39 without restroom facilities. 40 41 Commissioner Grout agreed, saying that if the City permitted guest houses, they should 42 function as guest accommodations, including bathrooms, while potentially continuing to 43 prohibit kitchens. 44 RegularSession Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 5 1 Commissioners discussed whether the proposed restrictions would effectively transform a 2 guest house into a bunkhouse and whether eliminating the guest house provision 3 altogether might be preferable. 4 5 Mr. Hellegers explained that the City's single-family rental licensing process included 6 exterior inspections but not routine interior inspections, limiting the ability to identify 7 unauthorized interior modifications through that process. 8 9 Commissioner Hudson recommended postponing action until the City Council clarified its 10 intent rather than immediately eliminating the guest house provisions. Staff agreed to 11 consider alternatives, including revised language, retaining bathrooms, renaming the use, 12 or removing the provision. 13 14 The Commission also considered proposed elimination of Sections 12-14-13 and 12-14- 15 14, relating to employee dwelling units.Mr. Hellegers indicated that one existing use was 16 known under the provisions proposed for elimination. Mr. Janish explained that removing 17 the ordinance authorization would not immediately terminate an existing lawful use. 18 However, the use could become legally nonconforming, and discontinuance for one year 19 could prevent its resumption. 20 21 Commissioner Hudson indicated that he did not object to eliminating the provisions 22 provided that the existing occupant or use would not be immediately affected. 23 24 The Commission expressed general support for the proposed deletions but determined that 25 the entire Title 12 amendment should return for further consideration. 26 27 Mr. Hellegers recommended continuing the item to a future meeting to allow additional 28 review, possible consultation with the City Attorney and City Council, and preparation of 29 clearer ordinance language. 30 31 Motion by Commissioner Grout, seconded by Commissioner Naughton, to continue 32 consideration of the Title 12 Ordinance Amendments to a future Planning and Zoning 33 Commission meeting. Motion carries by unanimous consent. 34 35 OTHER BUSINESS 36 37 Community Development Director Janish provided an update regarding two matters 38 considered at the previous Commission meeting. He reported that the City Council had 39 approved a variance request and that the applicant may already have received the 40 associated permit. 41 42 Regarding an interim use permit application involving land reclamation and material 43 brought onto a property, Mr. Janish reported that the applicant had withdrawn the 44 application. He indicated that the material had been removed and that staff anticipated 45 inspecting the property the following week to verify that the site had been cleaned up. RegularSession Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – October 27, 2026 Page 6 1 2 ADJOURNMENT 3 4 Chair Loehleinadjourned the meeting at 7:43p.m. 5 6 7 Respectfully Submitted, 8 9 10 Sue Osbeck, Recording Secretary 11 TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc. STAFF REPORT Agenda Item #4 TO: Planning & Zoning Commission CC: Joe Janish, Community Development Director FROM : Aidan Breen, Associate Planner SUBJECT: Public Hearing: Consider Ordinance Amendments to Titles 11, 12, and 13 related to reassigning the duties of the Andover Review Committee – City of Andover (Applicant). DATE:November 10, 2026 INTRODUCTION Consider a proposed change to City Code Titles 11, 12, and 13 to reassign the duties of the Andover Review Committee (ARC) to appropriate City Staff members and remove the Andover Review Committee from City Code. BACKGROUND At the August 25, 2026, City Council work session, Planning staff were given direction to remove references to the Andover Review Committee from the City Code, as it no longer optimally serves the administrative and decision-making functions assigned to it by various sections of the Code. Staff now present the full extent of City Code’s references to ARC, summaries of the duties assigned to ARC, and staff’s proposed changes to the City Code to remove ARC as an entity. This report will address the proposed changes to the Titles regarding Subdivisions (Title 11), Zoning (Title 12), and Planning and Development (Title 13) in Andover City Code. Other proposed changes to Titles 1, 5, and 9 will not be presented to the Planning and Zoning Commission, as they pertain to other functions of the City. City Staff reviewed the proposed changes and re-assigned duties with the City Council at the October 27, 2026 City Council work session. In this meeting, a number of changes were discussed and Staff was given direction to proceed with a formal code amendment for the following changes to Titles 11, 12, and 13: In situations where ARC is directed to review information, replace all instances with “City Staff”. (Many references throughout Titles 11, 12 and 13) Remove the definition of the Andover Review Committee (§11-1-4) In situations where decision-making authority is granted to ARC, re-assign the duties as follows: o Decide if curbing or traffic safety islands are necessary in off-street parking areas – Reassign to City Engineer (§12-4-8-E-9) o Decide building prohibited building exterior materials may be used as an accent material on a specific building – Reassign to Building Official (§12-14-15-B-2) o Decide whether roof pitch or roof materials may deviate from code standards for architectural purposes – Reassign to Building Official (§12-14-17-C) o Remove the Board of Design Control as an entity in City Code, allowing decisions of City Staff to be appealed directly to the City Council. (§12-7-7) o Remove reference to ARC in appealing approved Commercial Site Plans. Plans are reviewed by “City Staff” and appeals are heard by City Council (§12-15-4-K, 12-15-4-L) o Approve/Deny lot splits in the Rural Reserve District – Reassign to Community Development Department (§13-1B-16-A) Some minor changes unrelated to ARC: o Ensure that the naming of the Planning and Zoning Commission is consistent through City Code, adding “and Zoning” to the Commission title where necessary (Many references throughout Titles 11, 12 and 13) o Change single reference to “Zoning Administrator” in 12-15-10 to “Community Development Director” who is assigned as the administrator earlier in Title 12. This makes the reference consistent with zoning decisions in the chapter. (§12-15-10-B) ACTION REQUESTED The Planning and Zoning Commission is asked to hold a public hearing and make a recommendation to the City Council regarding the City Code Amendments to Titles 11, 12, and 13 reassigning the duties of the Andover Review Committee (ARC) and removing ARC from City Code. Attachment(s): Text of proposed amendments to City Code Titles 11, 12, and 13 The following modifications to Title 11, Chapter 1, Section 4: 11-1-4:DEFINITIONS: For the purpose of this title, certain words and terms are hereby defined as follows: ALLEY: A public right-of-way which affords a secondary means of access to abutting property. No alley shall be allowed. ANDOVER REVIEW COMMITTEEConsists of a representative of the following departments: (ARC): Administration Building Engineering Finance Fire Community Development Police/Public Works (Amended Ord. 355, 9-18-07) --- PLANNING COMMISSION: The Planning Commission of Andover The following modifications to Title 11, Chapter 2, Section 1: 11-2-1:SKETCH PLAN: A. Procedure: Prior to platting any tract of land, the subdivider may prepare a subdivision sketch plan for review and comment by the Andover Review Committee (ARC)City Staff, the Planning and Zoning Commission and the City Council. A public hearing by the Planning and Zoning Commission shall be held in accordance with Chapter 12-14-8. A Sketch Plan Fee shall be required of the subdivider for the submission of a sketch plan. Any review time by the ARC city staff shall be billed towards the subdivider. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) B. Compliance With City Provisions; Modifications: On the basis of the subdivision sketch plan, the ARC City Staff, the Planning and Zoning Commission and the City Council will advise the subdivider of the extent to which the plan conforms to the Comprehensive Plan, design standards of this title and to other ordinances of the city, county, and state. There will be discussion on possible modification necessary to secure approval of the plan. (Amended Ord. 10, 2-15-1972; amd. 2003 Code; Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) C. Submission And Review: The sketch plan shall be submitted and reviewed in accordance with the following procedures: 1. The applicant shall submit a Sketch Plan Review fee as defined in the Fee Schedule adopted by Ordinance by the City Council. 2. The subdivider shall submit ten (10) copies of the sketch plan to the City for review by the Andover Review Committee (ARC). The ARC City Staff, who shall review and comment on the sketch plan within ten (10) days of the submittal by the subdivider. 3. After the public hearing and the Planning and Zoning Commission review and comment, the sketch plan shall be placed on the next available City Council agenda for Council review and comment. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) D. Required Information: The subdivider shall provide the information as listed on the Sketch Plan application. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) E. Additional Requirements: The subdivider shall be required to show adjacent property and any other property as determined necessary for proper review as required by the ARC City Staff, the Planning and Zoning Commission, and City Council. (Amended Ord. 10, 2-15-1972) (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) The following modifications to Title 11, Chapter 2, Section 2: 4 11-2-2:PRELIMINARY PLAT: A. Minimum Lot Size: There shall be no conveyance of land described by metes and bounds if the conveyance is less than five (5) acres in area and three hundred feet (300') in width; except as allowed by City Code Section 13-1. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) B. Procedure: Prior to platting and subdividing any tract of land into more than two lots, the following procedures shall be followed: 1. ARC City Staff Review: a. The subdivider shall file ten (10) copies of the preliminary plat with the City for review by the Andover Review Committee City Staff. b. The Andover Review Committee City Staff shall review preliminary plat submissions pursuant to Minnesota State Statutes and the City Code. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) 2. Fee: At the time of the filing of the preliminary plat, the subdivider shall pay a preliminary plat fee as defined in the Fee Schedule adopted by Ordinance by the City Council. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) 3. Required Data: Preliminary plat applications shall not be considered complete until the requirements listed on the Preliminary Plat Checklist have been met. The Preliminary Plat Checklist is on file with the City. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) 4. The City staff shall submit a written report to the Planning and Zoning Commission, which shall deal with drainage, streets, and other planning and engineering matters pertinent to said preliminary plat. Said report shall be submitted to the Planning and Zoning Commission prior to the public hearing prescribed in this section. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) 5. Public Hearing Process: Public Hearings shall be held pursuant to Minnesota State Statute 462.358 and according to City Code Title 12-14- 8. At said hearing, all persons interested in the plat shall be heard. (Amended Ord. 314, 10-4-2005; Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) 6. Council Action: a. After the Planning and Zoning Commission acts on the preliminary plat, the Council shall approve, disapprove, or modify the preliminary plat. The date of the meeting shall be at the discretion of the City and in adherence to the 120-Day Rule as defined in Minnesota State Statute 462.358 Subd. 3b. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) b. If the Council should deny the plat, the grounds for any such denial shall be set forth in the proceedings of the Council and reported to the subdivider within fourteen (14) days thereafter. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) c. Approval of a preliminary plat by the Council is tentative only, subject to the compliance with all requirements and recommendations in the preliminary plat resolution as a basis for preparation of the final plat. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) 6. Petition To Rezone: At the time of the filing of the preliminary plat, the subdivider shall submit to the City a petition for rezoning to the proposed future use of said land if the land is not already so zoned. The owner of said land shall join in said petition. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) The following modifications to Title 11, Chapter 3, Section 1: 11-3-1: GENERAL REQUIREMENTS: A. The Planning and Zoning Commission, in its review of a preliminary plat, shall determine whether the proposed subdivision is in conformity with the Comprehensive Plan and shall take into consideration the requirements of the City and the best use of the land. Particular attention shall be given to the arrangement, location and widths of streets, drainage and lot sizes and arrangements. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) B. The preliminary plat shall cover all of the owner's contiguous land or any other property of the owner as deemed necessary by the Planning and Zoning Commission in consideration of rural and urban differences, the zoning ordinance and the Comprehensive Plan. (Amended 9/18/07, Ord. 355) The following modifications to Title 12, Chapter 7, Section 4: 12-7-4: PERFORMANCE STANDARDS: A. Construction and Materials: Every fence shall be constructed in a workmanlike manner. For all fences constructed after the adoption of this title, all posts, supports, and framework shall be placed on the inside of the fence, with the finished side facing the abutting property or street. Chain- link fences shall be constructed in such a manner that the barbed end is at the bottom of the fence. Fences in all districts shall be constructed of materials widely accepted in the fencing industry. No fence may have boards, planks, or panels larger than twelve (12) inches in width except as otherwise permitted by this Chapter.The following materials are expressly prohibited from use as fence materials (Amended Ord. 567; 10/15/24): Plywood boards Canvas Plastic sheeting Metal sheeting including corrugated steel Chicken wire (except for use on permitted chicken coops) Drywall Cardboard Particle board Pallets Chopped wood Netting Paper Reflective surfaces Jersey barriers and similar products Silt fences, snow fences, orange construction fencing and similar materials Any material that is not manufactured or originally intended to be used as fencing Silt fences, orange construction fencing, and similar materials shall only be allowed on construction sites or where deemed necessary to prevent st soil erosion. Snow fences shall only be allowed between November 1 th and April 15. (Amended Ord. 567, 10/15/24) Wire fencing shall only be allowed as part of a panel fence. These fences shall be rigid and self-supporting, without the need for external guide wires or stakes. Wires shall be woven to run horizontal and vertical and be welded at their intersections to form a checkerboard like design. The wire shall utilize gaps that do not exceed four inches by four inches (4” x 4”) in size so as to prevent external footholds and handholds. Each panel shall be framed with wood or decorative metal finishes and be no more than eight feet (8’) in length. Unframed rolls of fencing or unframed fence panels shall be prohibited. The wire fencing material shall be framed on both sides so that the fencing material is centered within the frame. (Amended Ord. 567, 10/15/24) Privacy screens shall be allowed when attached to a permitted chain link fence. Privacy screens must be: Made of a fabric or mesh intended for use as a fence privacy screen. Solid in color, with no patterns or designs. Only black, grey, green, brown, or tan colors are permitted. Taut, securely fastened to the fence according to manufacturer instructions, free from any rips or tears, and otherwise in good repair. Privacy screens shall not exceed the dimensions of the permitted chain link fence to which it is attached. The installation of privacy screen(s) requires a fence permit and is subject to review by the Andover Review Committee City Staff. Privacy screens are intended for privacy only and do not fulfill screening obligations as established in City Code 12-14-5. (Amended Ord. 579, 7/15/25) The following modifications to Title 12, Chapter 7, Section 7: 12-7-7: APPEALS: The Andover Review Committee of the City shall be and is hereby appointed the Board of Design Control for fences. The Board Andover City Council shall review all Fence Permit applications referred to it by the City of Andover Engineering Department upon a determination that the design, materials, or plan may violate the provisions of this Chapter or in situations where no such determination could be made by the Engineering Department. The Board City Council may approve, conditionally approve, or disapprove the design, materials, or plan of any fence referred to it as it may deem necessary to carry out the purpose and intent of this Chapter. Any person aggrieved by the decision of the Andover Review Committee may take an appeal there from to the City Council. (Amended Ord. 567, 10/15/24) The following modifications to Title 12, Chapter 14, Section 8: 12-14-8: OFF STREET PARKING REQUIREMENTS: E. Design Standards: 9. Curbing: a. All driveways, loading areas, parking areas and storage areas shall be bounded by poured in place concrete curb and gutter for the purpose of traffic control, drainage control, protection of pedestrian movement, protection of landscaped features, aesthetics and maintenance prevention as deemed necessary by the Andover Review Committee City Engineer, except for single- family, two-family, townhouse and quadraminium dwellings. b. The city may exempt curbing where the city has approved future expansion of the parking lot. c. Poured in place concrete traffic safety islands may be required to maintain a safe and orderly flow of traffic within the parking lot and shall be approved by the Andover Review Committee City Engineer. The following modification to Title 12, Chapter 14, Section 15: 12-14-15: VISUAL STANDARDS: B. Prohibited Exteriors: 1. On any non-residential building, the following material shall not be permitted on exterior wall surfaces: a. Aluminum, steel and metal, except as an accent material; b. Common or painted concrete blocks; c. Metal; d. Galvanized steel (see subsection 12-14-17-F of thischapter); e. Structural clay tile; f. Sheet metal, either corrugated or plain (see subsection 12-14- 17-F of this chapter); g. Similar materials. 2. Such materials, however, may be used as an accent material to complement the architectural design and appeal of the building as determined by the Andover Review Committee Building Official. The applicant shall have the opportunity for the City Council to review architectural plans and make a final determination of the materials and design. (Amended Ord. 314 10-4-2005) The following modification to Title 12, Chapter 14, Section 17: 1 12-14-17: RESIDENTIAL BUILDING STANDARDS : All permitted residential structures in RR, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4 and R-5 zoning districts shall meet the following design criteria (Amended Ord. 468, 6-6-17; Amended Ord. 543, 10-18- 22): B.Single-family dwellings other than approved earth sheltered homes shall have at least a 4:12 roof pitch and shall be covered with shingles, tiles, metal roof panels or metal roof shingles. Deviations from these standards, for architectural purposes, may be approved by the Board of Design Control Building Official. With the exception of the edging, trim, coping, and/or flashing, all fasteners shall be concealed so as to not protrude from the roofing material. Corrugated, plain galvanized, or unpainted roofing materials shall be prohibited. This requirement shall not apply to three- season porches, four-season porches, greenhouses and solariums, provided they meet the State Building Code and are approved by the Building Official. (Amened Ord. 543 10-18-22; Amended Ord. 585 2-2-26) The following modifications to Title 12, Chapter 15, Section 3: 12-15-3: PUBLIC HEARING PROCESS: B. Public Hearing 1. A public hearing on an application for Council actions in this chapter shall be held by the Planning and Zoning Commission in accordance with the Minnesota State Statutes. 2. A notice of the time, place, and purpose of the hearing shall be published in the official newspaper of the city ten (10) days prior to the day of the hearing. 3. Property owners and occupants within three hundred fifty feet (350’) of subject properties located inside the Municipal Urban Service Area (MUSA) (based on the City’s most current version of Anoka County Property Records) shall be notified in writing. 4. Property owners and occupants within seven hundred feet (700’) of subject properties located outside the MUSA (based on the City’s most current version of Anoka County Property Records) shall be notified in writing. 5. The notification distance shall be measured from the perimeter of the subject property. Property owner notifications shall be sent by mail. Failure by any property owner or occupant to receive such notice shall not invalidate the proceedings. 6. Staff shall have discretion to expand the notification area on a case-by-case basis. 7. The hearing may be continued from time to time in the event the Planning and Zoning Commission needs additional information from the applicant or other sources to make its decision. 8. The Planning and Zoning Commission recommendation shall be presented to the City Council. 9. The City Council shall make the final decision on the proposed action (Amended Ord. 342, 3-6-07) 1 See also title 9, chapter 1 of this code. The following modifications to Title 12, Chapter 15, Section 4: 12-15-4:COMMERCIAL SITE PLAN REVIEW: G. Review: Complete applications shall be reviewed by the Andover Review Committee (ARC) City Staff for compliance with applicable regulations. ARC City Staff shall provide review comments to the applicant within two weeks of receipt of a complete application. H. Revision: The applicant shall make all necessary revisions to comply with the review comments of ARC City Staff and all applicable regulations. The applicant shall then resubmit the commercial site plan to the City. The applicant shall also be required to respond in writing to each review comment to describe how the comment was addressed on the commercial site plan. I. Continuation to Compliance: The review and revision process described above shall continue until ARC City Staff finds the commercial site plan in compliance with all applicable regulations and all other approvals have been granted. J. Approval: Once the proposal has been found to be in compliance with ARC City Staff comments, applicable regulations and all other required approvals have been granted, the applicant shall provide two complete full size and two complete half size plan sets to the City to be signed. A signed plan set shall be returned to the applicant. A signed plan set shall be retained by the City. No building permit shall be issued prior to approval of the commercial site plan. K. Appeal: Any person aggrieved by a decision of ARC related to a Commercial Site Plan shall be entitled to appeal to the City Council within thirty (30) days of the decision by filing a notice of appeal. The Community Development Department shall schedule a date for hearing before the City Council and notify the aggrieved person of the date. The Commercial Site Plan decision of ARC shall not be voided by the filing of such appeal.Only after the City Council has held its hearing will the Commercial Site Plan decision of ARC be affected. L. Revisions and Amendments: Administrative approval of minor changes to an approved commercial site plan may be authorized by the Community Development Department upon review and approval by ARC. Proposed changes that involve expansion in the use of the property or other substantial modifications to the approved commercial site plan shall follow the procedures described in this section. The following modifications to Title 12, Chapter 15, Section 5: 12-15-5: AMENDMENTS: A. In accordance with the provisions of Minnesota statutes, the governing body may, from time to time, adopt amendments. Amendments to the text may be initiated by the City Council, Planning and Zoning Commission, property owner, or resident. Staff shall review all proposed amendments and make recommendations to the Planning and Zoning Commission. All proposed amendments shall be referred to the Planning and Zoning Commission prior to adoption, and the Planning and Zoning Commission shall hold a public hearing on the proposed amendment. The public hearing shall be held in accordance with Chapter 12-15-3. Fees shall be charged according to the most current fee schedule. The final decisions regarding amendments shall rest with the City Council. (Amended Ord. 8, 10-21-1970, Amended Ord. 314 10-4-2005) B. Relation to Comprehensive Plan: It is the policy of the City of Andover that the enforcement, amendment, and administration of this Chapter be accomplished consistent with the recommendations contained in the City Comprehensive Plan, as developed and amended from time to time by the Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council. The Council recognizes the City Comprehensive Plan as the official policy for the regulation on land use and development in accordance with the policies and purpose herein set forth. In accordance with Minnesota Statutes Chapter 473, the City will not approve any rezoning or other changes in these regulations that are inconsistent with the City Comprehensive Plan. Proposed changes to the City Comprehensive Plan shall have a public hearing per the process in Chapter 12-15-3. (Amended Ord. 314 10-4- 2005) The following modifications to Title 12, Chapter 15, Section 8: 12-15-8:INTERIM USE PERMITS: D. Standards: The Planning and Zoning Commission shall recommend an interim use permit and the Council shall issue such interim use permit only if it finds that such use at the proposed location: 1. Will not create an excess burden on parks, streets, and other public facilities; 2. Will not be injurious to the surrounding neighborhood or otherwise harm the public health, safety, and general welfare; 3. Will not have a negative effect on values of property and scenic views; 4. Will not impose additional unreasonable costs on the public; 5. Will be subjected to, by agreement with the owner, any conditions that the City Council has deemed appropriate for permission of the use, including a condition that the owner may be required to provide an appropriate financial surety to cover the cost of removing the interim use and any interim structures upon the expiration of the interim use permit. The following modifications to Title 12, Chapter 15, Section 9: 12-15-9: VARIANCES: E. Procedure: The procedure for granting variances is as follows: 1. Request for Variance; Fee: A person desiring a variance shall fill out and submit to the Community Development Director a request for variance 1 application form together with a fee as set forth by ordinance. (Amended Ord. 407, 6-21-11) 2. Planning and Zoning Commission Review: A public hearing shall be held by the Planning and Zoning Commissionas provided in City Code 12-15-3. The Planning and Zoning Commission shall make a recommendation to the City Council based upon the provisions of City Code 12-15-9. (Amended Ord. 407, 6-21-11) 3. City Council Action: The City Council may grant the variance based upon the provisions of City Code 12-15-9. (Amended Ord. 407, 6-21-11) The following modification to Title 12, Chapter 15, Section 10: 1 See subsection 1-7-3 of this code. 12-15-10: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS AND APPEALS ESTABLISHED: B.Appeals Authorized: A property owner or aggrieved person may appeal any order, requirement, permit, decision or interpretation of the text of this title, or any determination as to the location of the boundary of a zoning district as shown on the zoning map, or any determination by the Zoning Administrator Community Development Director or city employee administering zoning, building or related controls. The City Council shall determine, in harmony with the general purposes of this title and the Comprehensive Plan, by resolution, all appeals. (Amended Ord. 407, 6- 21-11) The following modifications to Title 13, Chapter 1B, Section 6: 13-1B-6:REVIEW AND RECOMMENDATIONS: A. Andover Review Committee (ARC) City Staff Review: All proposed lot splits shall first be reviewed by ARC City Staff. The applicant shall make modifications based upon ARC’s City Staff comments and then resubmit for consideration at a Public Hearing for conducted by the Planning and Zoning Commission. For lot splits that do not create parcels less than 10 acres in size, and do not require public improvements (i.e. new roadways, construction of roadways) ARC the Community Development Department shall provide approval or denial of said splits administratively. The following modification to Title 13, Chapter 3, Section 10: 13-3-10: REVISIONS AND AMENDMENTS: Administrative approval of incidental changes in the PUD may be authorized by the City Planner upon review and approval by ARC. Such administrative approvals shall not substantially alter the character of the approved PUD and shall be limited to landscaping (not including quantity reduction), color schemes (not including materials), association documents, fencing, entrance monuments and decks. Changes in uses or development/design standards must be submitted for a full public hearing review process. (Amended Ord. 314, 10-4-2005 STAFF REPORT Agenda Item #5 TO: Planning and Zoning Commissioners CC: Joe Janish, Community Development Director FROM: Peter Hellegers, City Planner th SUBJECT: (Continued from the October 27Planning and Zoning Commission meeting): Consider Ordinance Amendments to Title 12 related to definition changes/deletions/additions (Duplex, Triplex, and Quadrominium; Dwelling, Duplex; Dwelling Two Family; Kitchen Facilities; Accessory Apartment; etc.); requiring a Conditional Use Permit for accessory apartments; not allowing water connections to guest houses; removal of Dwelling Units of Employees on Premises in Residential Districts; removal of Dwelling Units in Commercial Industrial Districts – City of Andover (Applicant). DATE: November 10, 2026 INTRODUCTION The Planning Commission is requested to continue a discussion from their October 27, 2026, meeting on proposed changes to City Code, including: Section §12-2-2 regarding definition changes; Section §12-11 regarding accessory apartments; Section §12-14-2 regarding guest houses; Sections §12-14-13 and 12-14-14 regarding dwelling units of employees in residential districts and dwelling units in commercial industrial districts; and Section §12-14-17 regarding Residential Building Standards. UPDATE Public Hearing / Planning Commission Meeting – October 27, 2026 th At the meeting on October 27 Planning Commissioners had questions on several different definitions and what the amendments would accomplish, such as: what is the distinction between a home addition and accessory apartment?, what is the point of the kitchen facilities definition?, and is a guest house without water really just a bunk house (if so maybe just eliminate the section). There was no one that came forward to speak to the items at the public hearingprovided any comments or provided any written comments. The Commission asked staff to review the proposed amendments and bring the item back to the Commission and continued the discussion to a future meeting. The following discussion items look at changes to the definitions, modifications to the land use chart, and other zoning sections dealing with accessory and other apartments in City Code. 1 The Andover City Council reviewed the proposed amendments at the City Council Workshop on September 22, 2026. BACKGROUND The Building Department periodically receives inquiries from property owners looking to add secondary living spaces (such as in-law suites or basement apartments) to single-family homes. However, our current code lacks a clear definition for internal accessory apartments, leading to uncertainty during permit reviews. Historically, the city has required direct access between conditioned living spaces. Under this practice, residents could not exit the home, pass through an unconditioned area, or travel through a garage to reach the accessory apartment. DISCUSSION ITEMS 1) Proposed Definition Changes (City Code Section §12-2-2) This first discussion item is in regard to some proposed changes to definitions from Section 12-2-2 of the City Code. Definitions for Accessory Apartment and Dwelling Unit have been th modified from what was shown in the staff report for the October 27 meeting. The new Accessory Apartment definition now states that it does not include a dwelling unit that requires an entrance separate from the single-family dwelling; so there must be access to the Accessory Apartment from inside of the single-family dwelling (i.e., a door between the two units). This provides a distinction between an accessory apartment, an accessory dwelling unit (which is detached), and a duplex or twin home. The revised definition also provides a distinction between a simple living space addition and an Accessory Apartment based on the intended use of the space. The Dwelling definition has been modified to incorporate kitchen facilities definition that was discussed at the last meeting. The proposed modification to the definition of Guesthouse is shown in this section and discussed in more detail in discussion item three. The existing definition of Family has been included for the Commission’s reference. The Commission should discuss whether they agree with the proposed definition additions, deletions, and modifications. Definitions: Accessory Apartment: A second dwelling unit located within or added to an existing single- family detached dwelling and intended for occupancy by an individual or family, other than the owner or main tenant of the existing single family detached dwelling, and provided: it has a passageway, door, or direct connection from the single-family dwelling to the second dwelling unit without having to traverse outdoors or through an attached garage. It shall not include a dwelling unit that requires an entrance separate from the single-family dwelling to access the unit. An Accessory Apartment shall not exceed 900 square feet and shall be served by the same driveway and utilities serving the single-family dwelling. Duplex, Triplex, and Quadrominium: Means a single dwelling structure on a single lot, containing having two, three, or four dwelling units respectively, being attached by common walls, and each of which is designed or could be utilized as a separate residence. unit equipped with separate sleeping, cooking, eating, living space, and sanitation facilities. Dwelling, Duplex: A building designed as a single structure, containing two separate living units, each of which is designed to be occupied as a separate, independent permanent residence. 2 Dwelling Two Family: A building designed with two separate dwelling units intended for occupancy by two families. A principal dwelling unit that contains an accessory apartment is not considered a two-family dwelling. (See also Dwelling, Duplex or Dwelling, Twin Home). Dwelling, Attached (Single-Family): A dwelling attached to one or more dwellings by common walls or floors (see Performance Standards in Chapter 13 14 of this title). Dwelling Unit: A residential building or portion thereof, containing kitchen facilities, sleeping quarters, living space, and sanitation facilities, intended for occupancy by an individual or family, but not including hotels, motels, boarding or rooming houses, tourist homes or trailers. It shall include manufactured homes. Family: A. An individual or two (2) or more persons related by blood, marriage or adoption living together; or B. A group of not more than five (5) persons who need not be related by blood, marriage or adoption, living together as a single housekeeping unit in a dwelling unit, exclusive of usual servants. Garage, Private: A detached or attached accessory building or carport, which is used primarily for storing passenger vehicles or trailers. Guesthouse: An accessory building detached from the principal building where accommodation for sleeping is provided but no kitchen facility or bathroom facility is provided. Kitchen Facilities: are defined as kitchen amenities that could be used for food preparation, including but not limited to facilities such as full-sized refrigerators, kitchen sinks, stoves, and ovens. Appliances such as microwaves, mini-refrigerators, and/or coffee and tea appliances do not constitute “Kitchen Facilities” for purposes of this definition. 2) Accessory Apartments Land Use (City Code Section §12-11) Discussion item two is whether Accessory Apartments should be listed on the Land Use Chart as permitted, prohibited, or conditionally permitted uses. The proposed amendment below would add Accessory Apartments into the Land Uses Chart in Section 12-11 as Conditional Uses in all residential land use districts. The Commission should discuss whether this is the correct way to classify these land uses. Dwellings Excerpt from Land Use Chart ( shown with Accessory Apartments): DWELLINGS RR R-1 R-2R-3R-4 R-5MPZ M-1 M-2 M-3 Accessory Apartments C C C C C C C C C C Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) C C X X X X X X X X Manufactured homesand modular homes located in manufactured X X X X X X X PUD PUD PUD home parks. Multiple dwellings X X X X X X PUD PUD PUD PUD Relocated dwellingunits in C C C C C C C C C C compliance withCityCode 9-11 3 Single-familyresidentialbuildings P P P P P PUD P PUD PUD PUD (detached) Single-family residentialbuildings (attached)andtownhouses/twin XXXXXXPPUDPUDPUD homes Sacred Communities meeting Minnesota State Statute and City P P P P P P P P P P 5 Code requirements. Temporary Family Health Care X X X X X X X X X X Facility Two-familyhomeconversions (splits) in compliance with City Code X X X X X X X C C C 12-12-1 3) Proposed Changes for Other “Apartments” (City Code Sections §12-2-2, 12-14-12, 12- 14-13, 12-14-14, and 12-14-17) Finally, discussion item three is in regard to changes related to other “apartments” discussed in the Zoning Code. These include Guesthouses (12-14-12), Dwelling Units of Employees on Premises in Residential Districts (12-14-13), Dwelling Units in Commercial and Industrial Districts (12-14-14), and Residential Building Standards (12-14-17). The Commission should discuss whether they agree with the proposed changes. Modifications to Guesthouses A guesthouse is currently defined under City Code 12-2-2, and that definition would also need to th be modified to be consistent with the proposed changes to Section 12-14-12. At the October 27 meeting the Commission questioned if changes are to be made to the Guesthouses section then would it be appropriate to have this renamed as Bunkhouses or justdelete the Guesthouse provisions altogether. The Commission should indicate whether they modifications are acceptable, they should be renamed as Bunkhouses, or the sections should be deleted. 12-2-2: DEFINITIONS GUESTHOUSE: An accessory building detached from the principal building where accommodation for sleeping is provided but no kitchen facility or bathroom facility is provided. 12-14-12: GUESTHOUSES: A. Guesthouses, for the purpose of this title, shall be an accessory building detached from the principal building where accommodations for sleeping are provided but no kitchen or bathroom facilities are provided. Guesthouses are not considered a separate dwelling unit and shall not be allowed a water connection. The intended use is for persons visiting the occupants of the principal building and shall not be used as a rental property. (Amd. 4/18/06, Ord. 325A) B. Guesthouses shall be permitted in all single-family residential districts, shall be located at the required depth of the rear yard or more from the principal building, and shall conform to the side yard requirements for the principal building. (Amended Ord. 8, 10-21-1970) 4 Dwelling Units for Employees in Residential or Commercial/Industrial Locations There are two sections in City Code which discuss dwelling units for employees which do not appear to have been used. The Commission is asked to consider removing these two sections from City Code. 12-14-13: DWELLING UNITS OF EMPLOYEES ON PREMISES IN RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS: A. Accessory Uses and Structures: The dwelling units of employees on premises in residential districts, for the purposes of this title, shall be an accessory use, and if located within a separate structure, such structure shall be an accessory structure. B. Compliance with District Provisions: Dwelling units shall conform to the provisions applicable to the district in which located except as herein modified. C. Location: 1. Detached dwelling units shall be a distance from the principal structure equal to the sum of the required rear yard and one-half (1/2) the required front yard for the principal structure. 2. Detached dwellings shall not be located less than the required side yard for the principal building to any lot line. D. Parking Lot Required: All dwelling units shall have a designated off-street parking lot. (Amended Ord. 8, 10-21-1970) 12-14-14: DWELLING UNITS IN COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL DISTRICTS: A. Accessory Use; Compliance with District Provisions: Dwelling units for the watchman and family shall be considered as accessory uses and shall conform to all applicable regulations for the district in which located except as herein modified. B. Restrictions And Requirements: 1. A dwelling unit in the commercial district located in a commercial structure shall not occupy the front half of the ground floor or basement. 2. A dwelling unit in a commercial or industrial building shall not contain more than one bedroom. 3. No detached dwelling unit shall be permitted in the commercial or industrial districts. 4. A dwelling unit which is a part of the principal building shall be provided with one outside entrance. (Amended Ord. 8, 10-21-1970) 5 Clarification on Additions th At the meeting on October 27there were questions about what constituted an accessory apartment versus a typical addition. As staff and the City Attorney worked through the definitions it became clear that an additional clarification statement would need to be added with regard to additions and the correct place for that clarification was not within the definitions themselves. Section 12-14-17 provides performance standards for residential buildings that are not located in multifamily residential zoning districts (R-1 thru R-5 zoning). Section 12-14-17-I has been added to clarify that living space additions cannot be separated from the dwelling by a garage. This language clarifies that an addition separated from the dwelling by a garage would not be considered an accessory apartment or an addition to the living space of the dwelling unit. 1 12-14-17: RESIDENTIAL BUILDING STANDARDS: All permitted residential structures in RR, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4 and R-5 zoning districts shall meet the following design criteria (Amended Ord. 468, 6-6-17; Amended Ord. 543, 10-18-22): A. All structures shall have permanent concrete or treated wood foundations that will anchor the structure, which comply with the State Building Code as adopted in Section 9-1-1 of this code and which are solid for the complete circumference of the house. Except, four- season porches may be constructed without the permanent foundation, provided the porch does not exceed a maximum coverage of twenty percent (20%) of the footprint of the habitable portion of the principal structure. B. Sixty percent (60%) of a residential structure shall have a minimum width of twenty-four feet (24'). Width measurements shall not take into account overhangs or other projections. Such width requirement shall be in addition to the minimum area per dwelling requirements of Section 12-3-5 of this title. C. Single-family dwellings other than approved earth sheltered homes shall have at least a 4:12 roof pitch and shall be covered with shingles, tiles, metal roof panels or metal roof shingles. With the exception of the edging, trim, coping, and/or flashing, all fasteners shall be concealed so as to not protrude from the roofing material. Corrugated, plain galvanized, or unpainted roofing materials shall be prohibited. This requirement shall not apply to three-season porches, four-season porches, greenhouses and solariums, provided they meet the State Building Code and are approved by the Building Official. (Amened Ord. 543 10-18-22) D. All single-family dwellings shall have roof overhangs that extend a minimum of one foot (1') from all the walls of the structure unless the style of the house dictates otherwise and said plan is approved by the Building Official prior to any permits being granted. E. All single-family structures must be built in conformance with Minnesota statutes sections 327.31 to 327.35 or the State Building Code as adopted in Section 9-1-1 of this code. 6 F. Any metal siding upon single-family residential structures shall have horizontal edges and overlapping sections no wider than twelve inches (12"). Sheet metal siding shall not be permitted in such districts. G. All exterior construction, including finish and the final grading, shall be completed in accordance with plans and specifications within one year following date of permit issuance. All existing buildings not meeting the provisions of this title shall comply within one year following adoption of this title. (Amended Ord. 8, 10-21-1970; amd. 2003 Code) H. On attached single-family dwellings, such structures shall not exceed two (2) stories in height, excluding the basement. I. Additions to a single-family dwelling, intended to provide additional living space, shall not be separated from the single-family dwelling by a garage or other parking structure. (footnote: 1 See also title 9, chapter 1 of this code). BUDGET IMPACT None. ACTION REQUESTED Continue discussion on the proposed amendments and provide recommendations to City Council on proposed changes. Attachment(s): None. 7