Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSeptember 22, 2026 PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING – SEPTEMBER 22, 2026 The Regular Meeting of the Andover Planning and Zoning Commission was called to order by Chairperson Loehlein on September 22, 2026, at 7:00 p.m., at the Andover City Hall, 1685 Crosstown Boulevard NW, Andover, Minnesota. Commissioners present: Chairperson Nick Loehlein, Commissioners Roger Grout, Chuck Naughton, Jonathan Weinhold, Nicole Wicklund, and Ryan Winge. Commissioners absent: Scott Hudson. Also present: City Planner Peter Hellegers and Associate City Planner Aidan Breen. CALL TO ORDER PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE APPROVAL OF MINUTES Motion. The Chair assumed a motion to approve the August 25, 2026, Regular Meeting Minutes as presented. The Motion passed by unanimous consent. th PUBLIC HEARING – Variance for Accessory Structure Height – 15349 7 Avenue NW – PID #19-32-24-13-0012. (Applicant: Todd Kubes) City Planner Peter Hellegers reviewed a request from Mr. Todd Kubes for a 3.5-foot variance to allow a proposed accessory structure at 15349 7th Avenue NW to exceed the height of the principal structure. The approximately five-acre property is located in the R- 1 Single Family Rural Residential Zoning District. The proposed accessory structure would have a maximum height of approximately 21 feet. Chair Loehlein opened the public hearing at 7:08 p.m. Mr. Todd Kubes, 15349 7th Avenue NW, explained that he had lived on the approximately five-acre property for seven years and wanted to construct a detached garage to accommodate several personal vehicles. He described himself as a car enthusiast Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 2 and noted that he had previously operated an automobile business in Coon Rapids but was now somewhat retired. He would use the proposed garage strictly for his personal vehicles and related activities. Mr. Kubes explained that one reason for constructing the garage was to have space to store and work on a vehicle belonging to his father. He hoped the garage would give them an opportunity to spend time together working on cars. He also wanted sufficient interior height to install an automotive lift so he could perform routine maintenance, including oil changes and work underneath vehicles. Mr. Kubes noted that accessory structures are common on the surrounding developed properties, including some buildings containing loft areas. He was not seeking a loft or similar additional living space. His existing accessory building has approximately 10-foot walls and is already full. The additional height was needed to make the new garage functional for the proposed automotive lift. Commissioner Grout asked Mr. Kubes to address the variance criterion regarding economic considerations and whether the requested height was intended to reduce construction costs. Mr. Kubes explained that the proposed design would cost more because he intended to coordinate the garage's appearance with the residence. The siding, windows, doors, roofing, and other exterior elements would be selected to complement the house. He emphasized that he was not requesting a variance to build a cheaper structure. The proposed garage would be approximately 100 to 150 feet from the house and oriented at approximately a 90-degree angle. He wanted the two buildings to appear compatible when viewed from the driveway. No additional members of the public spoke regarding the request. Chair Loehlein closed the public hearing at 7:14 p.m. Commissioner Weinhold asked whether the residence's earth-sheltered design was essentially the reason a height variance was required. Mr. Hellegers agreed that it was a significant factor. A more conventional split-level, two-story or similarly designed residence in the R-1 District would generally provide sufficient principal-building height to accommodate the proposed accessory structure. Because most of the applicant's residence is within the hill, the measurable height is limited to approximately 17 feet on the exposed side. That unusual configuration caused the proposed garage to exceed the principal structure's height. Chair Loehlein asked whether staff knew approximately how many earth-sheltered homes existed in Andover, noting the importance of considering whether approval could create implications for future variance requests. Mr. Hellegers explained that staff had not previously been aware of earth-sheltered residences within the City but learned through review of the application that at least two existed. Staff did not believe this was common Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 3 and had not previously encountered an accessory-building height request resulting from an earth-sheltered residence. Commissioner Wicklund asked whether staff had received any written comments regarding the variance. Mr. Hellegers confirmed that no comments had been submitted. Commissioner Winge reviewed the variance criteria and found the request reasonable. He noted that the property owner sought to use the property in a reasonable manner, that circumstances unique to the property existed, that the proposed variance would not alter the essential character of the locality, and that the request was not based solely on economic considerations. He believed the requested accessory building was reasonable for the property. Motion by Commissioner Winge, seconded by Commissioner Wicklund, to recommend the City Council approve the variance request allowing the proposed accessory structure to exceed the height of the principal structure by approximately 3.5 feet, with a maximum height of approximately 21 feet. Chair Loehlein agreed with the result but emphasized the importance of connecting the practical difficulty to the earth-sheltered home. City Code establishes accessory-building height limitations for a reason, and approval should not imply that any property owner could obtain additional accessory-building height merely by requesting it. He viewed the unusual design and measurable height of the earth-sheltered residence as the distinguishing circumstance supporting the variance. Commissioner Naughton agreed. He believed it was important for the record to establish that the request involved a unique circumstance associated with the earth-sheltered residence rather than creating an expectation that accessory-building height variances would routinely be granted. The proposed approval resolution similarly identified the earth-sheltered residence and its unusual method of measuring building height as the circumstances creating the practical difficulty. The motion carried unanimously. Chair Loehlein noted that the request was tentatively scheduled for City Council consideration on October 6, 2026. He reminded the applicant and the public that the Planning and Zoning Commission was a recommending body and that the City Council would take final action. PUBLIC HEARING – Consider an Interim Use Permit – Mining and Land th Reclamation – Unaddressed Property at the NE Quadrant of Prairie Road and 146 Lane – PID #25-32-24-21-0004. (Applicant: Mark Smith) Associate City Planner Breen reviewed a request from Mr. Mark Smith for an Interim Use Permit (IUP) for mining and land reclamation on an approximately 35-acre unaddressed Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 4 parcel at the northeast quadrant of Prairie Road and 146th Lane NW. The applicant proposed accumulating approximately 70,000 cubic yards of soil primarily on the eastern portion of the property for possible future residential development. The requested IUP would remain in effect for five years, with the option to seek an extension in the future. Commissioner Wicklund sought clarification regarding language requiring the applicant to obtain appropriate permits. Mr. Breen explained that City Engineering was familiar with many outside-agency requirements, but the individual agencies ultimately determine whether their permits apply. The applicant would be responsible for determining and obtaining all permits required for the work. Chair Loehlein asked how the applicant would know which permits were needed. Mr. Breen explained that staff would help determine the permits required. Commissioner Wicklund asked whether the City had a system in place to notify different departments of the application. Mr. Breen explained that the City Engineering Department does coordinate these types of projects with other agencies. Commissioner Weinhold asked for clarity on what defines clean, compatible soil and, if the City is conditioning the silt fencing to be installed, how long the City is giving the applicant to keep the fencing up. Mr. Breen believed that the report meant to state “clean, compactible soil”. He explained that City Code permits a maximum of five years for the silt fence. The applicant anticipated obtaining material intermittently as suitable fill became available rather than purchasing and hauling the entire 70,000 cubic yards at one time. Staff understood that the activity would therefore occur intermittently throughout the permit period. Commissioner Naughton questioned the history of the previous IUP, the amount of material already delivered, the site condition, erosion controls, and whether the silt fence identified in the applicant's materials had been installed. Mr. Breen explained that the application materials showed a proposed silt-fence location and indicated that fencing was installed, but City staff had not personally verified its installation. Photographs subsequently submitted by members of the public did not appear to show silt fencing. Chair Loehlein opened the public hearing at 7:57 p.m. Mr. Mark Smith, 2120 Otter Lake Drive, Lino Lakes, explained that he had owned the property for some time and previously held an IUP for the site. He had not realized the previous permit had expired and would otherwise have attempted to extend it. Mr. Smith explained that City engineers had contacted him regarding sewer and water improvements approaching the property. He therefore began preparing the parcel for future development. A wetland delineation had been performed, and a Technical Evaluation Panel involving wetland-review agencies was expected to inspect the delineation flags later that week. He explained that silt fencing installation was delayed Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 5 because he was advised to wait until the wetland boundaries were verified so the fencing would not have to be relocated. Mr. Smith described previous plans to obtain excess fill from other development projects. One project was expected to generate approximately 30,000 cubic yards of material that could be transported to the subject property, but site conditions changed, and the material was needed elsewhere. He explained that suitable fill can be difficult and expensive to obtain and that opportunities to acquire material sometimes arise unexpectedly and require a quick decision. He estimated that portions of the subject property would need to be raised approximately five to seven feet for future development. He maintained that accumulating material over time would make future development more economically practical than purchasing all necessary fill at market prices. He anticipated future residential development once sewer and water became available. Mr. Smith discussed his approximately 40 years of development experience and projects he had completed in Andover and other communities. He maintained that the material had value and would ultimately benefit the property regardless of whether he personally completed the future development. Because the property is within the MUSA and municipal utilities are anticipated, he believed he or a future owner would eventually develop it. He also maintained that he monitored fill material because unsuitable material would create problems when building on the site. He described other projects where fill was compacted and stabilized as work progressed and indicated that he intended to follow similar procedures at the subject property. Mr. Breen then summarized written comments received from adjacent property owners, the Hoernemann family. The comments strongly opposed the IUP and alleged that material recently delivered to the site included roadway-demolition debris, asphalt, concrete, and utility materials rather than clean soil. The submitted materials included photographs of the site and equipment and questioned whether the site was being used for activities beyond the proposed land reclamation. The comments also raised concerns regarding the absence of visible silt fencing, proximity to wetlands, erosion and runoff, compliance with the previous IUP, the nature of the material already delivered, and the lack of a defined future development proposal. Chair Loehlein emphasized that the Commission had reviewed the detailed written comments. He clarified, however, that several requested enforcement actions contained in the correspondence were outside the Planning and Zoning Commission's authority. That evening, the Commission's responsibility was to recommend the IUP to the City Council. City staff handled code-enforcement matters administratively. Ms. Jean Carlstrom, 14941 Butternut Street NW, explained that she had lived in the area for approximately 36 years and had witnessed extensive changes as Andover developed. She was particularly concerned about preserving the remaining natural areas and wetlands. She regularly traveled past the subject property and opposed activities that could disturb the wetlands or the site's natural condition. Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 6 Mr. Allan Newcomb, 280 146th Lane NW, explained that a drainage ditch from the subject property crossed his property. He wanted to understand what was occurring at the site and asked the City to ensure that runoff remained safe, and that hazardous or inappropriate material did not enter the drainage system. Mr. Smith returned to the podium for additional questions. Commissioner Winge asked whether soil borings had been performed to determine whether the property was physically and financially feasible for residential development. Mr. Smith responded that soil studies were completed, including information obtained from a previous owner. He noted that some information indicated sand beneath areas that mapping identified differently. He also explained that City staff and engineers estimated that approximately 13 to 14 acres could potentially be built on. He reiterated that the wetland delineation was underway and that the Technical Evaluation Panel was scheduled to inspect the site. Once the wetland boundary was confirmed, the silt fencing could be placed appropriately. Commissioner Winge questioned the lack of erosion controls already in place and noted that silt fencing could be installed and later moved if necessary. He also raised concerns regarding the applicant's proposed stabilization schedule compared with applicable environmental requirements. Mr. Smith acknowledged the concern and indicated that the site would be stabilized before City Council consideration. He explained that he had delayed fencing because he expected the wetland delineation process to move more quickly and did not want to install fencing only to relocate it shortly thereafter. Commissioner Winge emphasized that his questions were intended to determine whether sufficient assurances existed that he would follow the permit commitments. Mr. Smith responded that he had developed numerous lots in Andover and believed his prior projects demonstrated that he followed through on development requirements. He acknowledged that the present situation had not proceeded as intended and expressed frustration that the wetland and planning processes had taken longer than anticipated. Chair Loehlein questioned how the previous IUP had been allowed to expire given Mr. Smith's extensive development experience and familiarity with City processes. Mr. Smith reiterated that he had not realized the permit had expired and that opportunities to acquire needed material can arise quickly. The Commission and applicant continued discussing the distinction between the existing material already placed on the property and the prospective request for permission to bring additional material to the site. Concerns included the lack of a detailed future development plan, the quantity and character of fill, wetland protection, erosion controls, the duration of the requested IUP, possible effects on neighboring property, haul routes and public streets, and the ultimate disposition of as much as 70,000 cubic yards of material if development did not occur. Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 7 Mr. Breen explained that the property previously had an IUP allowing a substantial amount of fill from 2019 through 2024. He noted that land-reclamation permits can involve varying levels of grading detail depending on the circumstances. In this instance, staff believed the general stockpile plan, proposed depth, and required erosion-control measures could provide a basis for review. The anticipated process could also involve placing and compacting fill incrementally over time. The Commission discussed whether to require a financial surety to guarantee removal or correction of the stockpile if the project did not proceed. Mr. Breen explained that requiring financial security sufficient to remove tens of thousands of cubic yards could be prohibitively expensive. The City had generally relied on permit conditions, inspections and enforcement rather than requiring a bond covering the entire potential removal cost for a stockpile of this magnitude. Mr. Smith maintained that removal of the fill was unlikely because suitable fill added value to a property that would eventually require substantial grading for development. He believed any future developer would benefit from having the material available. Chair Loehlein closed the public hearing at 8:47 p.m. Commissioner Grout discussed what an "interim" use means in the context of the request. The property had already been subject to a five-year IUP from approximately 2019 through 2024, and the Commission was now being asked to recommend another five-year permit that potentially could be extended again. He questioned whether an activity potentially spanning approximately 10 to 15 years remained consistent with the concept of an interim use. Commissioner Grout also distinguished between two separate issues before the City: the applicant's request for prospective permission to stockpile material and concerns regarding activity that had already occurred. He understood that enforcement regarding previous activity was primarily a staff responsibility rather than a Planning and Zoning Commission function. He did not want concerns about past enforcement to obscure the Commission's responsibility to evaluate the pending IUP according to the applicable criteria. Mr. Breen agreed. He explained that the matter initially came to staff's attention through a code-enforcement complaint. The City's general approach to code enforcement is to obtain compliance and remedy violations rather than immediately pursue punitive action. The Commission's role was to evaluate the IUP application. Staff would separately determine how existing site conditions and previously delivered material should be addressed through the code-enforcement process. Commissioner Weinhold expressed significant concern regarding photographs submitted as Exhibits B1 and B2. He noted the site's proximity to Prairie Knoll Park, where families play football, soccer, sled, and other recreational activities. He was particularly troubled by the appearance of the fill and its relationship to nearby wetlands. Although he Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 8 understood Mr. Smith's explanation regarding delays and staffing issues, he believed the existing conditions required prompt attention and questioned what conditions could adequately ensure the situation was corrected. Commissioner Winge agreed that the property's history was relevant when considering whether commitments associated with a new permit would be fulfilled. Although the Commission was not concerned with past activity, he believed past performance could inform expectations about future compliance. Commissioner Winge also expressed concern that no sufficiently defined future development plan had been presented. Without greater assurance that residential development would proceed within five, ten, or even 15 years, he was concerned the property could function primarily as a long-term stockpile for material generated elsewhere. Commissioner Winge reviewed the IUP approval criteria individually. He questioned whether approximately 5,000 truckloads associated with 70,000 cubic yards of material could create an excessive burden on public streets. He also questioned the potential environmental effects and whether the proposed operation could injure the surrounding neighborhood or public health, safety, and welfare. A large stockpile could affect scenic views, and significant truck traffic could potentially affect public infrastructure. Mr. Breen clarified that the proposed haul route utilized the existing driveway from 146th Lane and did not show trucks traveling through mapped wetland areas. Commissioner Winge noted that the maps initially raised concerns about the relationship between the driveway and wetlands, and staff reviewed the location on the exhibits. Mr. Breen further clarified that City Code did not require a stockpile IUP to be tied to an approved future development plan. The City had considered other stockpile applications for purposes unrelated to immediate development. While Commissioners could consider the information provided in evaluating the applicable IUP criteria, the applicant was not legally required to present a ready-to-construct subdivision plan simply to request the stockpile permit. Motion by Commissioner Winge, seconded, to recommend the City Council deny the Interim Use Permit for mining and land reclamation on the unaddressed property at the northeast quadrant of Prairie Road and 146th Lane NW, PID #25-32-24-21-0004. Commissioner Naughton discussed the difficulties inherent in evaluating development- related impacts. Development inevitably burdens roads, land, and natural resources, and the City must allow reasonable room for those impacts. However, he remained concerned that the current application did not provide sufficient safeguards or certainty. The photographs and information regarding runoff and site conditions were troubling. He specifically questioned whether the Commission could make the finding contained in the proposed approval resolution that the request would not have a detrimental effect on the health, safety, and general welfare of Andover. Based on the information presented, he Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 9 was not comfortable making that finding. Although he believed the property was likely to develop eventually and recognized that fill would probably be required, he concluded that the IUP should not be recommended at that time. Commissioner Grout similarly indicated that he could support the general concept of developing the parcel and could envision an IUP supporting that development. He was concerned that the present request appeared premature. Because the applicant indicated that the immediate opportunity for incoming material had passed, he preferred that the applicant return after additional safeguards were established, the intended use of the property was clearer, and the Commission had more complete information upon which to evaluate a new IUP request. Commissioner Winge suggested that a surety could address the Commission's concerns. He indicated that if an applicant came forward with a more developed plan, acknowledged the earlier permit's expiration, and provided stronger assurances for environmental protection and site restoration, he might view the request differently. A surety could potentially provide the City with resources to address erosion control or other site problems if the property owner failed to do so. Mr. Breen reiterated that a surety large enough to guarantee complete removal of approximately 70,000 cubic yards would likely be prohibitively expensive. He also reminded the Commission that the property is within the MUSA and guided for Transitional Residential development, demonstrating the City's expectation that the property could eventually develop. However, neither the Comprehensive Plan nor the IUP regulations established a specific timetable for that development. Following discussion, Chair Loehlein restated that the motion before the Commission was to recommend denial of the IUP. He clarified that an affirmative vote would recommend denial to the City Council. The motion carried unanimously. Chair Loehlein noted that the City Council was tentatively scheduled to consider the request on October 6, 2026. OTHER BUSINESS None. ADJOURNMENT Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to adjourn the meeting at 9:09 p.m. Motion carries by unanimous consent. Respectfully Submitted, Regular Andover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – September 22, 2026 Page 10 Sue Osbeck, Recording Secretary TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc.