Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSeptember 17, 2026 PARK AND RECREATION COMMISSION MEETING – SEPTEMBER 17, 2026 MINUTES The Regular Meeting of the Andover Park and Recreation Commission was called to order by Chair Johnson on September 17, 2026, at 6:00 p.m., at the Andover City Hall, 1885 Crosstown Boulevard NW, Andover, Minnesota. Commissioners Present: Chair Bruckner Johnson, Commissioners Emily Honer, Jim Lindahl, Liza Shafto, Shane Stenzel, and Liliya Ustimchuk Commissioners Absent: Kristin Lackie Also Present: City Planner Peter Hellegers RESIDENT FORUM. No one appeared to address the Commission. AGENDA APPROVAL. Commissioner Stenzel requested the agenda be amended to identify the Tree Lighting Event as Item 6A and add discussion of Tournament Fee Waivers as Item 6B. Motion by Commissioner Stenzel, seconded by Commissioner Honer, to approve the agenda for the September 17, 2026, Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting as amended to include Item 6B, Tournament Fee Waivers. Motion carried on a 6-ayes, 0-nays. APPROVAL OF MINUTES. July 16, 2026, Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Motion by Commissioner Shafto, seconded by Commissioner Honer, to approve July 16, 2026, Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes as presented. Motion carried on a 6-ayes, 0-nays. DISCUSS PINE HILLS NORTH GARAGE CONSTRUCTION Mr. Hellegers reviewed the proposed construction of a storage garage at Pine Hills North. Commissioner Shafto asked whether the building would have electrical service. Andover Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 17, 2026 Page 2 Mr. Hellegers was unsure whether electricity was currently available at the proposed location but said staff could confirm. Mr. Brady Johnson, representing Boreal FC, explained that the organization's current plan is to construct the garage without electricity. He described electrical service as a potential second phase that Boreal FC could pursue with the City in the future. Electricity is not necessary for the building's initial use but could be useful over the long term. Commissioner Stenzel confirmed that Boreal FC would completely fund construction and that ownership of the completed building would transfer to the City because it would be located on public property. He questioned who would ultimately be responsible for ongoing maintenance. Mr. Hellegers explained that the use agreement between the City and Boreal FC would most likely establish maintenance responsibilities. Although the agreement had not yet been drafted or included in the Commission's materials, he anticipated it would address maintenance and other responsibilities associated with Boreal FC's use of the facility. Commissioner Stenzel asked whether Boreal FC would be responsible for such items as damage, graffiti, routine maintenance, and potentially replacement costs during the term of the agreement. He also questioned whether insurance would be required. Mr. Hellegers anticipated those matters would be addressed in the agreement and noted that insurance requirements would be typical for the use of a City facility. Commissioner Stenzel expressed particular concern about the City's long-term responsibility if Boreal FC discontinued operations or no longer used the facility. He noted that soccer associations serving the community have changed over time and questioned whether another association would enter into a new agreement or whether the structure would become part of the City's park inventory. Mr. Hellegers anticipated that if another organization became the primary or exclusive user, the City would likely establish a new use agreement with that organization. Commissioner Stenzel questioned whether an agreement could require removal of the structure if Boreal FC disbanded or ceased using it. He emphasized that while donated improvements can benefit the park system, the City should avoid accepting a structure that could eventually create an unfunded operating and maintenance obligation. He requested consideration of provisions protecting Park and Recreation operating funds from future costs if an association were no longer available to maintain the building. Commissioner Honer asked whether City staff had confirmed that the proposed structure complied with applicable size and construction requirements. Andover Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 17, 2026 Page 3 Mr. Hellegers explained that buildings within parks are treated differently from accessory structures on residential properties. He noted that the Pine Hills North master plan originally contemplated a substantially larger approximately 40-foot-by-40-foot storage building, while the current proposal is considerably smaller. Therefore, the proposed garage fits within the parameters previously contemplated by the park master plan. The structure would also be reviewed for compliance with applicable building codes before construction. Commissioner Shafto asked what City bodies would review and approve the use agreement and whether it would return to the Park and Recreation Commission before proceeding to the City Council. Mr. Hellegers explained that City agreements typically require City Council approval, generally at least through the consent agenda. He was uncertain whether similar use agreements had historically returned to the Park and Recreation Commission. If the Commission wanted to review the agreement, however, it could direct staff to do so. Commissioner Shafto explained that because the Commission was being asked to recommend approval of the garage to the City Council, she wanted to ensure the Commission had addressed the issues falling within its responsibilities. Mr. Hellegers agreed that Commissioners had identified several legitimate park-related concerns, including maintenance, future use of the facility, and what would occur if the association were no longer the user. He indicated those concerns could be forwarded to Parks staff for consideration while the association developed the use agreement. Commissioner Honer questioned pedestrian access to the proposed building, noting that the plans did not appear to show a sidewalk or other defined route between the parking area and garage. She asked whether additional improvements would eventually be necessary to move equipment and supplies conveniently between the fields and storage facility. Mr. Hellegers agreed that the materials did not identify an access route and indicated staff could follow up on the issue. Commissioner Honer recommended considering access before the City Council enters into the final agreement. Commissioner Lindahl noted that irrigation lines may also be within the construction area and asked whether relocation would be the builder's or the City's responsibility. He also suggested landscaping or vegetation along the eastern side of the garage to help screen the structure from neighboring residential properties. Mr. Hellegers confirmed that landscaping was not shown on the current plans and agreed that the proposed building would be relatively exposed toward the residential property to the east. Andover Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 17, 2026 Page 4 Chair Johnson emphasized that despite the questions raised, he viewed the proposal as a positive partnership. He appreciated an athletic association investing its own resources in a facility that supports activities occurring on City fields but believed the long-term details should be carefully considered before the City agrees. The Commission discussed whether it was comfortable recommending the garage while forwarding its concerns to the City Council and appropriate staff for consideration through the use agreement. Commissioners generally supported proceeding with the project provided the issues identified during the discussion were considered as the agreement was finalized. Motion by Commissioner Honer, seconded by Commissioner Stenzel, to recommend the City Council approve the proposed Pine Hills North Garage Construction, with consideration of the concerns identified by the Commission regarding the use agreement, maintenance and future responsibility for the structure, access, and other related issues. Motion carried on a 6-ayes, 0-nays. DISCUSS TREE LIGHTING FESTIVAL Mr. Hellegers reviewed plans for the 2026 Tree Lighting Event, which will be held Friday, December 4, 2026. Commissioner Honer explained that she volunteered on the Tree Lighting Committee the previous year and found it to be a well-organized group that required relatively little assistance from her. She enjoyed participating and volunteered to serve again but was also willing to allow another Commissioner to participate if someone else was interested. Commissioner Stenzel noted that he had served on the committee in previous years and had intended to participate the previous year but could not attend the meetings. He encouraged Commissioner Honer to continue serving. He recalled earlier Commission discussions about placing and planting a permanent tree for the event and confirmed that the tree had since been planted. Chair Johnson felt the previous year's event had an appropriate number and variety of activities. He identified one logistical issue involving the band, which had apparently expected a stage or different performance area but was provided a tent in a grassy area. He suggested that the planning committee clarify expectations with performers in advance to avoid similar confusion. Commissioner Lindahl identified sound as another recurring concern. He noted that the large crowd and open setting made it difficult for attendees to hear the Mayor's remarks and the countdown to the tree lighting. He recommended that the committee consider a sound system that could project throughout the event area so everyone could hear and participate. Andover Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 17, 2026 Page 5 Mr. Hellegers asked whether Commissioners wanted to recommend any additional activities for the event. Commissioner Honer felt the previous year's event provided a good balance of activities and options for attendees. Commissioner Shafto recalled that the previous year appeared to be the first time the Fire Department and City coordinated a collection of donated goods and gifts as part of the event. She felt the activity worked well, attracted participation, and should be continued in 2026. The Commission expressed general satisfaction with the existing event format. It did not recommend additional activities beyond addressing the logistical concerns regarding the performance area and sound system and continuing the successful activities from the previous year. TOURNAMENT FEE WAIVERS Commissioner Stenzel explained that Commissioners recently received requests to waive tournament fees, including one involving an organization for which fees had previously been waived and another separate request. He recalled that the Commission had discussed the issue previously and believed the City should establish a consistent policy governing fee waivers, particularly for adult athletic activities. Chair Johnson emphasized that his concern was not with the organizations requesting the waivers and noted that he had supported the requests. Rather, he was concerned that without established criteria, individual decisions could appear arbitrary or inconsistent. He wanted the Commission to have clear standards for determining when a waiver is appropriate so it treats similar applicants consistently. Commissioner Stenzel also cautioned against creating a precedent in which nonprofit status alone effectively results in automatic waiver of City fees. He believed waivers could be appropriate in legitimate circumstances. Still, he wanted criteria in place to protect park resources and ensure adult activities did not receive preferential treatment at the expense of youth programs or other park users. He suggested that the City Council, staff, and legal counsel could help determine appropriate standards. Commissioner Shafto requested that any policy also establish the appropriate procedure and timeline for submitting waiver requests. She noted that the recent requests required action on a short timeline when the Commission was not scheduled to meet before the events occurred. She believed applicants should clearly understand how far in advance they must submit a request and how it will be reviewed and approved. Andover Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 17, 2026 Page 6 Commissioner Stenzel agreed and suggested that requests might reasonably be required 30 or 60 days in advance, along with whatever eligibility criteria the City ultimately establishes. Motion by Commissioner Stenzel, seconded by Commissioner Shafto, to request that the City Council or staff draft a policy establishing criteria and procedures for fee waivers for adult athletics. Motion carried on a 6-ayes, 0-nays. OUTSTANDING ITEMS Mr. Hellegers reviewed the Outstanding Items as of September 17, 2026. Mr. Hellegers reported that playground equipment for the Andover Station North and Creekview Crossings replacements had been delivered, with installation anticipated during September or October. Mr. Hellegers reported that staff are working with American Ramp Company on a draft design and layout for the skatepark improvements, which will be presented for public comment. The City Council established a total project budget of $400,000, including design, replacement of existing ramps, and a new concrete feature. Of that amount, $250,000 will come from the Park Dedication Fund for new improvements. Design development and public input will occur during the fall and winter, with construction anticipated to begin in spring 2027. Mr. Hellegers reported that trail replacement work at Kelsey Round Lake Park was underway and expected to be completed during the fall. Benches for the Tom Anderson Trail were on order and anticipated to be installed in late 2026 or early spring 2027. The City contracted with Connexus Energy for Sunshine Park parking lot lighting, with installation expected before winter. Engineering design work had begun for paving the Hawkridge Park parking lot, although construction had been moved to 2027. Mr. Hellegers reported that construction of the new Coon Creek trail segment was complete, and staff were working on final documentation for Minnesota Department of Natural Resources grant funding. Staff also submitted an Active Transportation Funding Grant application for the proposed trail addition along Crosstown Boulevard between Xeon Street and Prairie Road. Commissioner Stenzel returned to the skatepark project and questioned the review process. He recalled receiving an email regarding a City Council meeting scheduled for the following Tuesday and asked whether that meeting was intended to address the skatepark design. He noted that projects involving Park Dedication funds and design decisions have traditionally been presented to the Park and Recreation Commission for review before proceeding to the City Council. Given that $250,000 in Park Dedication funds was proposed for the skatepark improvements, he questioned why the design had not first been brought to the Commission. Andover Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 17, 2026 Page 7 Mr. Hellegers did not know why the project had been routed differently from the Commission's customary process. He understood the matter would be discussed at the upcoming City Council work session but agreed that if normal practice was to obtain Commission review first, he could not explain why that step had not occurred. Commissioner Stenzel requested an explanation, preferably by email before the Tuesday City Council meeting. He expressed concern that the process appeared to be changing in an area for which the Commission traditionally had responsibility, particularly when Park Dedication funds and park design were involved. Commissioner Lindahl noted that recent staff transitions may have contributed to changes in timing and procedure. Commissioner Stenzel acknowledged the transition but pointed out that the Commission was meeting that evening. He believed the skatepark design could have been added to the September 17 agenda, allowing the Commission to review the concepts before the City Council considered the matter the following Tuesday. He remained concerned about spending Park Dedication funds without following the normal review process. Mr. Hellegers explained that permanent staff expected to attend future Commission meetings had not yet begun doing so and suggested the transitional period may have contributed to the situation. Once staffing stabilized, he anticipated projects would return to the Commission's normal review process. Chair Johnson requested that the City Council be informed before its Tuesday meeting that the Commission believed the customary process had been deviated from. He wanted Councilmembers to be aware of the concern before determining whether to proceed with discussion of the skatepark project. Commissioner Stenzel questioned whether the Tuesday meeting was formally noticed as a joint City Council and Park and Recreation Commission meeting or whether Commissioners had been invited to attend. Commissioners did not recall receiving a joint meeting agenda. He said inviting Commissioners to provide comments at a City Council meeting was not equivalent to formal review by the Park and Recreation Commission. He believed bypassing the Commission's formal consideration would be inconsistent with its role, particularly given the amount of Park Dedication funding involved. Commissioner Shafto asked whether the Commission could recommend that the City Council postpone its discussion until the Park and Recreation Commission had an opportunity to review the project formally. Chair Johnson reiterated that his immediate priority was ensuring the City Council understood the Commission's concern before beginning its discussion. He recognized that Andover Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 17, 2026 Page 8 the City Council ultimately had authority to determine whether to proceed but wanted the procedural issue clearly communicated. Mr. Hellegers confirmed that the Commission's concerns would be forwarded to the City Council. He also agreed to clarify whether the upcoming meeting was intended to be a formal joint meeting or simply a City Council meeting to which Commissioners had been invited. Commissioners noted that a formal joint meeting would ordinarily need to be noticed accordingly. CHAIR’S REPORT Commissioner Honer reported that she participated in a QCTV interview at Andover Station North Park near the end of July. Representatives from Andover, Champlin, Anoka, and Ramsey were each provided approximately four minutes to discuss their communities. She highlighted the work and accomplishments of the Andover Park and Recreation Commission. She added that QCTV indicated it would be interested in considering future opportunities to film or promote City events. Commissioner Lindahl noted that football and other fall activities were underway and that children and families were actively using the City's parks. Commissioner Ustimchuk reported receiving requests from residents for permanent pickleball nets at Crosswoods Park because the existing net was flimsy and allowed balls to pass underneath. Residents also requested pickleball striping on the tennis court, and she asked that the 2027 budget consider those improvements. She also relayed requests for information regarding the proposed pickleball courts at Oak View Middle School, including when the project would begin and whether the courts would be available for public use. Commissioner Stenzel recalled that plans for pickleball courts near City Hall were on hold pending decisions about developing the remaining property. He noted that the Commission had previously discussed concepts for that area, but future improvements would depend upon the City's overall development plan. Commissioner Lindahl clarified that the school, not the City, proposed the Oak View Middle School courts. He recalled previous Commission discussion on whether those courts could serve community pickleball needs, but noted concern that the property belongs to the school and may not provide the same level of public access as a City park facility. Commissioners noted that daytime access is particularly important because many pickleball players use courts in the morning and midday. Andover Park & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Minutes – September 17, 2026 Page 9 Commissioner Stenzel complimented City staff on the condition of the parks despite recent staffing changes and drought conditions. He had visited several parks and felt they continued to be maintained at a high standard. ADJOURNMENT. Motion by Commissioner Stenzel, seconded by Commissioner Shafto, to adjourn the meeting at 6:39 p.m. Motion carried on a 6-ayes, 0-nays. Respectfully Submitted, Sue Osbeck, Recording Secretary TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc.