HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Packet 102126
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. • ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304 • (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 • WWW.ANDOVERMN.GOV
Andover Natural Resources Commission Workshop Meeting Agenda October 21, 2026
Andover City Hall Conference Room A & B
Call to Order 6:00 p.m.
1. Discuss Development Review Process
2. Review of Robert’s Rules of Order 3. Discuss Focus Areas/Priorities for the Year
4. Adjournment
STAFF REPORT Agenda Item #1
1
TO: Natural Resources Commission CC: David D. Berkowitz, Director of Public Works/City Engineer
FROM : Kameron Kytonen, Natural Resources Technician
SUBJECT: Discuss Development Review Process DATE: October 21, 2026
INTRODUCTION The Natural Resources Commission is requested to discuss the development (e.g. Plat and Commercial Site Plan) review process and the role it may have in this process.
DISCUSSION
Minnesota State Statute requires that the City complete review of development applications within a specified amount of time. As part of the development review process there is a window during which advisory commissions will consider various aspects of the development. The Planning and Zoning Commission is the commission tasked with the review and Public Hearing
process of these development applications, and the Parks and Recreation Commission is tasked
with reviewing any proposed parks and park needs within those developments. The recommendations from those commissions and any public hearing comments are then considered by the City Council, which approves or denies the applications.
The City Planner will be on hand to discuss the general development review process for the City
and to answer questions from the commission. A summary of different types of development application review processes is also attached. ACTION REQUESTED
The Natural Resources Commission is requested to discuss the development review process and
procedures and the role it may have in this process. Attachment:
Development Application Review Procedures
Development Application Review Procedures –
Presentation to the Natural Resources Commission
(10/15/2026) 1. General Information A summary of the types of development applications reviewed by the city is shown in a subsequent section within this packet. Development review applications must complete review consistent
with the “60-day rule” and certain applications may require a public
hearing. Applications are submitted to city staff and required public hearings are held at a Planning Commission meeting. 1. Public Hearing Notification Process
Approximately 10 days prior to the meeting: A Public Hearing Notice
is published in the Anoka County Union Herald, and a notice is also mailed to all property owners within 350 feet of the site in the urban, and within 700-feet of the site if it is rural. This follows the requirements established by Minnesota State Statute for public
hearing notice and notification distances. In addition, the City of
Andover will place a sign stating “Proposed Change” on the site to inform interested residents of the public hearing. The sign has City contact information that residents can call for information on the public hearing.
2. 60-Day Rule Commissioners should generally be aware of Minnesota State Statute 15.99, commonly referred to as the “60-day Rule”, which requires a City to make a decision on all zoning applications within
60-days of the date of submittal, or 120-days if the City issues an
extension. If a City fails to act on the request in that amount of time, the request is automatically approved. The underlying purpose of the rule is to keep governmental agencies from taking too long in deciding on land use issues. City staff monitor each application for compliance and will inform the Commission if its motion, especially
motions to table, may conflict with the rule. 2. Summary of Items Reviewed by the Planning and Zoning
Commission The graphic below, the “pyramid of discretion,” is provided as a way to visualize how much discretion the City has when considering different
types of land use applications. Generally the City has the most
discretion when creating law (the areas in green at the base of the pyramid), some discretion when they are acting in a quasi-judicial role
2
of applying the law (yellow section in the middle of the pyramid), and the least discretion when acting in an administrative capacity.
The Planning Commission does review some items where they are
establishing laws, such as comprehensive plans, amendments and rezonings. However, many of the items reviewed by the Planning and Zoning Commission will be from applying law and will require particular attention to the scope of what can be considered for that item under
City Codes and State Statute.
(Creating Law)
1. Comprehensive Plan
A Comprehensive Plan is a “road map” for the community. This
document establishes the vision and goals for the future of the community and City Code is required to be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. As the City of Andover is part of the seven-county metropolitan area, our Comprehensive Plan is also required
to be consistent with Metropolitan Council (Met Council) Policy
Statements and guidance from the Met Council. This plan provides the foundation for all land use regulations in the city. Overall the information within a Comprehensive Plan follows three
basic questions:
3
a. What is the state of the community today? b. What should the community be like in the future? c. How will the community get there? 2. Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Most Comprehensive Plan Amendments (CPA) involve changes to the Future Land Use Map. This map provides a land use designation for each property in the city. These designations regulate the types of activities that can occur on a property; such as residential, commercial, or industrial development. In other cases, a CPA may
involve a change to the text of the plan to more accurately reflect changing times and conditions. Criteria for the review of these amendments are provided in Chapter One of the Comprehensive Plan.
STATE LAW: All Comprehensive Plan Amendments require a 4/5ths
vote of the City Council to be approved rather than a
simple majority. Comprehensive Plan Amendments
also must be approved by the Metropolitan Council. 3. Zoning Ordinance This is a tool to implement the comprehensive plan. Zoning is a method of establishing a land use pattern by regulating how land is used by owners/renters. Zoning ordinances include area standards (size, setbacks, height, etc.), various zoning districts (residential,
commercial, industrial) with standards and allowed uses within those zoning districts. 4. Zoning (City Code) Amendment City Code amendments typically involve changes to the text of the
City Code. These requests can be initiated by an applicant or the city. In many cases changes to existing regulations are made to reflect changes in times and conditions or to address situations that have not previously been contemplated. 5. Rezoning Rezoning is a change (amendment) to the city’s official zoning map. These change the zoning district of one or more properties. Zoning districts prescribe land uses that are allowed as well as dimensional standards for lot size, building setbacks and other items as detailed
in Title 12 of the City Code.
STATE LAW: When property is rezoned from residential to commercial or industrial, a two–thirds majority of all members of the city council is required. Other zoning
changes only require a simple majority, and rezoning
4
should be consistent with the comprehensive plan land use map. (Applying Law)
6. Sketch Plan (review only – no formal action) A sketch plan allows input from the Commission on a conceptual development proposal. The purpose is to allow a discussion between the Commission and applicants to help determine whether
a concept has merit and what types of adjustments are needed
before proceeding to a formal recommendation by the Commission. This is an inexpensive way to determine if what a person is asking for is viable.
Ghost Plat
A “Ghost Plat” is not an application type, but it is related to the process of sketch planning and property subdivision. When a property is proposed for a new subdivision City Code requires that the development plan show a “ghost plat” onto adjacent
properties that have not been developed. A “ghost plat” is a
reference to a conceptual development layout for surrounding properties that is used to show how the properties around a proposed development could develop, and that the proposed development still leaves options for those adjacent properties.
7. Preliminary Plat Preliminary plats involve the subdivision of one or more properties into more than two properties. These items are more complex than lot splits and require additional application materials including a
grading plan, storm water management plat, geotechnical report,
and tree protection plan. City Code Title 11 provides specific regulations for preliminary plats. 8. Conditional Use Permit (CUP)
Conditional use permits (CUP’s) are required for land uses that have
the potential for adverse impacts on adjacent properties. CUP’s allow the city to place reasonable conditions on the approval of a project to mitigate these impacts. In some cases, with sufficient findings, the Commission can recommend denial of a CUP if
reasonable conditions are deemed not to be sufficient to adequately
address adverse impacts on adjacent properties. The burden of proof is the applicant’s responsibility. The criteria for considering conditional use permits are provided in City Code 12-15-7.
Criteria for granting Conditional Use Permits (CUP):
5
a. In granting a Conditional Use Permit, the City Council shall consider the advice and recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Commission and:
i. The effect of the proposed use upon the health, safety, morals, and general welfare of occupants of surrounding lands.
ii. Existing and anticipated traffic conditions, including
parking facilities on adjacent streets and land. iii. The effect on values of property and scenic views in the surrounding area, and the effect of the proposed use on
the Comprehensive Plan. 9. Interim Use Permit (IUP) The purpose and intent of an Interim Use Permit (IUP) is a temporary use of property until a particular date, until the
occurrence of a particular event, or until zoning regulations no longer permit it. IUP’s include uses such as mining, home occupations, interim performance standards (for the Hughs/Westview area), land
reclamation, storage of construction highway materials, subordinate classroom structures, and other uses that the City establishes a sunset clause, a date of expiration. The criteria for considering interim use permits are provided in City Code 12-15-8.
Review Criteria: a. The Planning and Zoning Commission shall recommend an interim use permit, and the Council shall issue such interim use permit only if it finds that such use at the proposed location:
i. Will not create an excess burden on parks, streets, and other public facilities; ii. Will not be injurious to the surrounding neighborhood or otherwise harm the public health,
safety, and general welfare;
iii. Will not have a negative effect on values of
property and scenic views;
iv. Will be subject to, by agreement with the owner,
any conditions that the City Council has deemed appropriate for permission of the use, including a condition that the owner may be required to provide an appropriate financial surety to cover the
6
cost of removing the interim use and any interim structures upon the expiration of the interim use permit.
b. Termination. An interim use permit shall terminate upon the occurrence of any of the following events, whichever occurs first;
i. Five (5) years from the date of approval; or
ii. The date or event stated in the permit; or
iii. An amendment to the City Code that either no longer allows the interim use or now permits the interim use; or iv. The use has been discontinued for six months. 10. Variance
Variances are essentially a waiver of a specific City Code requirement that may be granted when unique circumstances are demonstrated by the applicant. The Commission is asked to compare an applicant’s request to the Zoning Code and the criteria of City Code §12-15-9 to determine if a recommendation of approval
or denial is appropriate. Review Criteria: a. Variance shall only be permitted when they are in harmony with
the general purposes and intent of the official control and when
the variances are consistent with the comprehensive plan. b. Variances may be granted when the applicant for the variance establishes that there are practical difficulties in complying with
the official control. “Practical difficulties,” as used in connection
with the granting of a variance, means: i. The property owner proposes to use the property in a reasonable manner not permitted by an official control;
Means the landowner would like to use the property in a
particular reasonable way but cannot do so under the
current ordinance. It does not mean that the land cannot be put to any reasonable use without the variance.
For example, if the variance application is for building too
close to a lot line, or does not meet the required setback,
the focus of the first factor is whether the request to place a building there is reasonable.
7
ii. The plight of the landowner is due to circumstances unique to the property not created by the landowner;
The uniqueness generally relates to the physical
characteristics of the property. iii. The variance, if granted, will not alter the essential character of the locality;
Will the resulting structure be out of scale, out of place or
inconsistent with the surrounding area? iv. Economic considerations alone do not constitute practical difficulties.
Economic considerations can be considered, however,
cannot be the sole factor. 11. Planned Unit Development (PUD)
CITY CODE 13-3-1: PURPOSE: The purpose of a Planned Unit Development (PUD) is to encourage more efficient allocation of density and intensity of land use
where such arrangement is desirable and feasible by providing the means for greater creativity and flexibility in environmental design than provided under the strict application of this code. It must be demonstrated to the satisfaction of the City Council that a higher quality development will result than could be otherwise achieved through strict application of this code.
(Ord. 298, 8-4-2004) 13-3-6: ZONING AND SUBDIVISION STANDARDS AND REQUIREMENTS: All standards and provisions relating to an original zoning district shall apply, unless otherwise approved as part of the PUD. All standards may be
modified or waived provided the applicant demonstrates harmony with the purpose of the PUD and the findings described in Section 13-3-9 of this chapter. (Ord. 298, 8-4-2004) If the PUD does not change the underlining zoning, then the standards
still apply. For example in the R-1 Single Family-Rural zoning district, the
following are lot standards:
• Lot size of 2.5 acres
• Lots 300 feet wide at the front yard setback line
• Lot depth of 150 feet
• Density of 0.4 units per acre
13-3-9: FINDINGS REQUIRED: In order for a PUD to be approved, the City shall find that the following are present:
8
A. The proposed development is not in conflict with the goals of the Comprehensive Plan of the city.
B. The proposed development is designed in such a manner as to form a desirable and unified environment within its own boundaries. C. The proposed development demonstrates how each modified or
waived requirement contributes to achieving the purpose of a PUD.
D. The PUD is of composition, and arrangement that its construction, marketing, and operation are feasible as a complete unit without dependence upon any subsequent unit. (Ord. 298, 8-4-2004)
13-3-11: DESIRABLE PUD DESIGN QUALITIES: The following design qualities will be sought in any PUD:
A. Achieves efficiency in the provision of streets and utilities and preserves area to achieve the elements of design qualities described in this chapter. • Minimizing soil disturbances for the construction of roadways?
• Minimizing impacts to wetlands?
• Openness to modifying design standards, such as street width,
setbacks, lot dimensions, lot sizes?
B. Provides convenient and safe access for vehicles and pedestrians
and all types of activity that are anticipated to be a part of the proposed development.
• Review of access into and out of the development?
• Review of multimodal traffic within the development?
• Review of multimodal traffic to connect to existing amenities? C. Provides a buffer between different uses, adjacent properties,
roadways, between backyards of back-to-back lots.
• Tree stand preservation?
• Landscaping plans?
• Restrictive Easements?
• Home Owners Association (HOA)? D. Preserves existing stands of trees and/or significant trees.
• Tree stand preservation?
• Moving roadways to avoid trees or significant trees?
• Smaller lots than the 2.5 acres are considered in order to place a
roadway in an area to preserve trees?
9
E. Provides considerable landscaping treatments that complement the overall design and contribute toward an overall landscaping theme.
• Additional trees for each lot?
• Monument entrances?
• Rain gardens?
F. Preserves significant usable space on individual lots or through the provision of open space within the development.
• R-1 zoning requires a total of 8,600 square feet of upland (3,600 sq ft for home and 5,000 square feet for primary and secondary
septic location); would a half (.5) acre of upland or more per lot
be considered “significant usable space?
• If a developer could provide more upland per lot vs. 8,600 square feet, would council consider a smaller lot than 2.5 acres?
• If a developer provided open space either as HOA owned or
provided additional parkland or preserve to the City, would
council consider smaller lots than 2.5 acres?
• Clustering? G. Provides an attractive streetscape through the use of undulating topography, landscaping, decorative street lighting, decorative mailbox groupings, retaining walls, boulders, fencing, area
identification signs, etc.
• If “Undulating topography” creates lots that are less than 2.5
acres, is that acceptable?
• If minimizing the impact of construction creates smaller lots, is
that acceptable? H. The proposed structures within the development demonstrate quality architectural design and the use of high-quality building materials for unique design and detailing.
• Custom home sites?
• Limitations on building materials?
• Color restrictions?
• Home style restrictions (ramblers, two story, patio/slab, etc.)? I. The lasting quality of the development will be ensured by design, maintenance and use guidelines established through an owners’
association. (Ord. 298, 8-4-2004).
• If the HOA restricts uses that the City Code allows, is that
acceptable?
• Limit home occupations?
10
• Not allow for accessory structures, additional limits on accessory structures size,
• Restrict parking in driveways?
• Require additional landscaping?
• Other code restrictions?
13-3-12: APPROVAL OF PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT: The developer must demonstrate that the amenities and qualities of the Planned Unit Development are beneficial and in the public interest to allow the
development to be approved. A substantial amount of the design
qualities identified in Section 13-3-11 of this chapter shall be found to be present in order to approve a PUD. The amount of amenities and type of qualities that constitute an acceptable PUD are at the sole discretion of the City Council to determine. (Ord. 298, 8-4-2004)
11
General Applications Process
12
Making Recommendations
Based on Findings of Fact
Working with municipal land use regulations can be difficult for both city
officials and residents. Sometimes cities need to make controversial
decisions, and no matter what the result, someone will be unhappy. An important part of the process is developing and adopting written “findings of fact” that explain the decision. Carefully and thoughtfully developing written findings of fact can help solve a contentious problem because it
forces officials to focus their review on the merit of an application. It also
produces a record that makes it easier for a court to uphold the decision if it is challenged. This is especially important when making a recommendation to deny an application. Findings of fact should explain to the reader how and why the City reached its decision and should: 1. Identify the relevant legal criteria, such as City Code or
Comprehensive Plan requirements. 2. Explain the relevant facts relating to the particular application. 3. Apply those facts to the legal criteria. For example, a finding of fact for denial could be: City Code 12-3-5
requires a minimum lot size in the R-4 zoning district of 11,400 square
feet. The proposed application is proposing a minimum lot size of 8,000
square feet. Since the proposed application is located in the R-4 zoning
district and does not meet the minimum lot size established by City Code
12-3-5, the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends denial to the City
Council. Please keep in mind that the findings must be facts, and not opinion or hearsay. For example, if the Commission wanted to recommend denial of
an application but as part of the application a traffic study was conducted showing that the amount of traffic created would not burden adjacent streets, the Commission should not cite traffic concerns as a finding for its recommendation of denial as the facts would not support its recommendation. Additionally, the findings should only relate to items
under the City’s jurisdiction. For example, denying a proposed residential development out of concern that it could increase classroom sizes at a school is not a good finding of fact as schools are outside of the City’s jurisdiction. The same is true for private utility infrastructure such as power or natural gas. Resident opposition alone also cannot be a reason
for denial.
City staff are available during the meeting to assist with creating findings
of fact. Through its recommendation, the Commission can also allow City staff to review the entirety of a meeting and produce findings to be forwarded to the City Council based off the Commission’s discussion.
13
Processes Which Are Not Part of the Planning
Commission Review
1. Environmental Reviews The State of Minnesota has standards under which environmental review must be completed based on the type, size, and location of the development. These environmental reviews do not approve or deny a
development; they are used to determine potential environmental
impacts and potential mitigation measures. Environmental reviews include; Environmental Assessment Worksheet (EAW), Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), and Alternative Urban Areawide Review (AUAR).
2. Final Plat The Final Plat is the formal document that will record the subdivision of property. This process takes the Preliminary Plat that has been approved and puts the plat into recordable format. At the time of Final
Plat the document will be reviewed for consistency with the approved Preliminary Plat and any changes required as part of that process. Once the plat has been checked and approved by Council it will be signed and then recorded at Anoka County.
3. Dedication of Easement Some easements are allowed to be dedicated through the platting process and depicted on the plat (i.e., Drainage and Utility easements). The easement dedication process applies to other easements which need to be dedicated separately (i.e., conservation
easements, ditch, trail, vehicle maintenance access) or may be dedicated after the property has been platted. The easement dedication process involves a deed/agreement, legal description, and survey of the easement area.
4. Vacation of Easement Should an easement need to be removed, the easement vacation process requires a public hearing at the City Council preceded by notice as required by law. The vacation is similar to the easement dedication with the legal description and survey of the property to be
vacated.
G:/Planning\Planning Commission/Planning Commission Training/P&Z Procedures – Revised 2026
STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item #2
1
TO: Natural Resources Commission CC: David D. Berkowitz, Director of Public Works/City Engineer
FROM : Kameron Kytonen, Natural Resources Technician
SUBJECT: Review of Robert’s Rules of Order DATE: October 21, 2026
INTRODUCTION At the September 30 meeting, meeting laws and Robert’s Rules of Order were briefly discussed. The Commission is requested to continue this discussion.
BACKGROUND This is a new commission in the City. Staff will go into further details of meeting laws and Robert’s Rules of Order. This will help prepare for future meetings.
ACTION REQUESTED
It’s requested that the Commission continue discussion of Robert’s Rules of Order. Attachment: Robert’s Rules handout
STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item #3
1
TO: Natural Resources Commission CC: David D. Berkowitz, Director of Public Works/City Engineer
FROM : Kameron Kytonen, Natural Resources Technician SUBJECT: Discuss Focus Areas/Priorities for the Year
DATE: October 21, 2026
INTRODUCTION As a newly formed commission, it’s requested the Commission begin discussing focus areas and
priorities for the year.
BACKGROUND The Commission has a list that had been drafted by members of the former Nature Preserve Commission to consider.
ACTION REQUESTED It’s requested that the Commission discuss focus areas and priorities for the year.
Attachment:
Possible NRC Mission Goals and Objectives