HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-09-22 WK
ANDOVER CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP MEETING – SEPTEMBER 22, 2026
MINUTES
The Workshop Meeting of the Andover City Council was called to order by Mayor Barthel,
September 22, 2026, 6:00 p.m., at the Andover City Hall, 1685 Crosstown Boulevard NW,
Andover, Minnesota.
Councilmembers present: Rick Engelhardt, Karen Godfrey, Scott Schue, and Jonathan Shafto
Councilmember absent: None
Park and Recreation
Commissioners present: Bruckner Johnson, Jim Lindahl, Kristin Lackie, Shane Stenzel, and
Liza Shafto
Also present: City Administrator, Sarah Cotton
Community Development Director, Joe Janish
Director of Public Works/City Engineer, David Berkowitz
Finance Manager, Lee Brezinka
Others
DISCUSS DOG PARK AT BUNKER HILLS REGIONAL PARK
Mr. Berkowitz stated the City Council requested to discuss the history and status of the dog park
at Bunker Hills Regional Park and reviewed the staff report.
Jeff Perry, Director of Anoka County Parks and Recreation, recognized the social media concerns
that have come forward and noted that those comments have been brought forward to the County
Board. He stated they brought the request for water to the Board two years ago and again recently,
and the Board was still not interested because of the cost.
Andy Soltvedt, Assistant Director of Anoka County Parks and Recreation, provided additional
background information on the creation of the dog park and JPA in 2013. He stated in 2020, they
began to look at additional investments that would make the park a more permanent feature, such
as the lights, which were installed in 2021. He stated they have been focused on how to serve the
user group and maintain operations, providing additional information on maintenance and
operations of the dog park. He noted the most recent improvement was the addition of four waste
stations, which are emptied three times per week. He commented on a recent issue where people
were adding rope lights, solar lights, water jugs, toy bins, etc. He stated a one-month notice was
posted explaining that while they understand the intention, this is a public facility and the items
needed to be removed. He explained the biggest concern with the water jugs is that they could be
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 2
tampered with when unattended, which is a risk to users. He commented if people want to bring
things to use while they are at the park, that is allowed, and they could be shared between users,
but they need to take their items with them when they leave.
Councilmember Schue asked how large the water jugs were. Mr. Soltvedt replied they were five-
to seven-gallon blue camping jugs. It was noted that there were one-gallon jugs strewn about, and
at one point there were 20 different water bowls left around the dog park. He commented their
objective was to clean the park up and keep it maintained to a high standard. A brief review was
provided of the investments that have been made to the facility as well as the options that were
reviewed to bring water to the site and associated costs.
Mr. Perry commented they have not run numbers again on water since 2024, but did not anticipate
those numbers would have decreased and believed that cost would be $175,000 to $200,000.
Councilmember Schue asked about the lighting that is available around the dog park for safety,
noting that comments were made that the solar lights were added by residents to improve safety.
Mr. Soltvedt identified the location of the existing lights. He explained the solar lights were just
decorative lights that were strapped to the fence and did not necessarily increase safety.
Councilmember Schue asked if there are plans to add more lights in the future. Mr. Perry replied
they do not currently have anything planned to light the entirety of the dog park. He stated the rest
of Bunker Hills Regional Park is not lit, so the status of the dog park remains consistent with the
rest of the park. He noted winter trail users within the park choose to use headlamps.
Councilmember Schue stated he agrees that the park should not be lit like a Walmart parking lot
but would be interested in cost projections to add more lights. He recognized that the high cost to
bring water to the site would be cost-prohibitive.
Councilmember Godfrey commented she is a dog owner and member of six different dog clubs.
She stressed the importance of education about dog responsibilities, as users should expect to be
self-sufficient for the care and safety of their dogs. She asked if there is anything in place to solicit
or accept donations, as there are a number of dog clubs and training clubs who might be willing to
donate and offset the cost of additional lighting for safety, if it could be done appropriately and
consistent with the approach of the park. She stated she is not as concerned about water, as
everyone typically carries a water bottle or could bring one.
Councilmember Shafto asked if the County has pursued grant opportunities for park
improvements. Mr. Soltvedt stated there are some grants that could be explored, noting that
sometimes there are other clauses and requirements that come with those grant dollars. Mr. Perry
commented a lot of existing grant funds have been invested in the park since its creation in 2013.
Councilmember Godfrey asked if there is an annual report of expenses for the park. Mr. Berkowitz
confirmed that staff does receive that report each year.
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 3
Councilmember Godfrey commented it would be helpful for all three parties of the JPA to better
understand the operating costs and funding sources. She reiterated the additional opportunities
that could be pursued through the use of grants and/or donations.
Councilmember Schue commented users of the park are seeking improvements, but also recognize
the rising costs of taxes. He agreed with Councilmember Godfrey that there could be an
opportunity to engage those raising the concerns to contribute towards the funding. He stated they
need to be responsive to the citizens who are interested in improving the quality of life in the park.
Councilmember Shafto noted a concern that he has received related to shade and asked if shade is
available at the park. Mr. Perry provided information on vegetation management that occurred,
which was a visual change for park users. He stated they planted 28 different pathway trees and
any trees that did not survive the summer will be replaced this fall.
Councilmember Shafto asked if most dog parks are lighted all the way through. Councilmember
Godfrey replied she has been to dog parks in many states and they are usually not lit. She stated
the lighting provided at this location is one of the better-rounded offerings that she has seen.
Councilmember Schue asked how many dog parks the County is responsible for. Mr. Perry replied
this is the only one, noting that the other was at Locke Park in Fridley but has been turned over to
the City of Fridley.
DISCUSS SUNSHINE PARK SKATE PARK IMPROVEMENTS
Mr. Berkowitz stated the City Council and Park and Recreation Commission are requested to
discuss the Sunshine Park Skate Park Improvements. He reviewed the staff report and draft
concept.
Councilmember Godfrey commented that benches seem to be missing for observers. Mr.
Berkowitz acknowledged that seating has been discussed. It was noted that kids were sitting on
the trash cans, and if they install benches, they need to think about how to prevent them from
becoming features of the skate park.
Mayor Barthel suggested placing the benches a bit further away in the grass. He stated when he
drives by, he often notices people sitting in the grass, so it would be nice to have some type of
seating.
Commissioner Johnson asked if there was any consideration to move the bowl to the south end
rather than placing it on the north. He explained if it is placed on the southern side, they could
take advantage of the elevation change. He had concerns with the northern location and proximity
to the trail. Mr. Berkowitz stated staff actually made that suggestion, but the consultant felt that it
was better to keep features together, noting that this would be the most cost-effective method. He
noted a split rail fence could be placed to prevent any misuse of the trail as well.
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 4
Councilmember Schue asked for more information related to the discussion of concrete versus
modular. Mr. Berkowitz stated a lot of the discussion was to get rid of the modular elements and
build a concrete facility, as it holds up longer-term. He noted the modular elements allow changes
to be made more easily as trends change. He stated most of the parks are now concrete because of
the longevity and reduced maintenance needs.
Commissioner Lackie stated there was also discussion about lighting and asked for information on
that element. Mr. Berkowitz stated that lighting was brought up as part of the
expansion/replacement of the shelter. He stated there are currently no plans for lighting, as lighting
brings a new component for injury. He stated in order to provide sufficient lighting, they would
most likely exceed the thresholds at the property line.
Commissioner Lindahl stated he could not recall a request for lighting and would not support that
request.
Commissioner Shafto stated when they spoke with students at the skate park, it was requested to
have seating options, not just for sitting but as a place to put their bags. She stated another request
was for water. She asked if there is water at the park and/or whether they would consider adding
water to the park. Mr. Berkowitz replied there is no water at this park. He commented on a nearby
well that is used for irrigation but noted that there is a water line under Crosstown Boulevard and
they could price out the option for water at this park.
Mr. Berkowitz confirmed he received the input he needed for this item.
2027 SPECIAL REVENUE, DEBT SERVICE, CAPITAL PROJECTS, ENTERPRISE &
INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS BUDGET DISTRIBUTION AND DISCUSSION
Mr. Brezinka provided background information on the 2027 Proposed General Fund Budget,
which was preliminarily adopted at the September 1, 2026 Council meeting. He stated this item
will focus on all other City fund budgets and provided an overview of his staff memorandum.
Councilmember Shafto asked for more information on the miscellaneous $40,000 within the
charitable gambling fund. Mr. Brezinka explained that part of that is for the contribution to
Alexandra House. He explained typically the contribution is split between the charitable gambling
fund and general fund, but if there are sufficient funds, the entire contribution would come from
the charitable gambling fund.
Councilmember Schue asked for more information about the forestry fund and its revenue source.
Mr. Brezinka explained that a DNR grant shows as revenue, and if a grant is not received, the
revenue for that fund would show as zero.
Mayor Barthel asked if the PR fund would be eliminated once the funds are fully expended. Mr.
Brezinka confirmed that is the future intent.
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 5
Councilmember Schue asked if there are targets for the funds that would be proposed for a rate
increase. Mr. Brezinka explained how the rates are determined in order to fund future
improvement needs.
DISCUSS 2027 GO STREET RECONSTRUCTION BONDS
Mr. Brezinka stated the City is proposing a street reconstruction bond to fund upcoming road
projects, as outlined in the approved 2027-2031 Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) and the draft
2027 Operating Budget and Levy. He provided an overview of his staff report.
The Council agreed they should begin the process to issue the bonds.
Councilmember Godfrey asked for more information on the cost to issue the bonds. Mr. Brezinka
provided those details.
Mayor Barthel asked and received confirmation that this would be the last round of street
reconstruction bonds.
DISCUSS DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL AT 15532 NIGHTINGALE STREET NW
Mr. Janish stated the Council is requested to review and provide direction related to potential
development at 15532 Nightingale Street NW. He provided an overview of his staff report.
Councilmember Godfrey asked why flag lots have not been permitted. Mr. Janish explained a flag
lot creates a narrower section at the road that would not meet the Code requirement and a larger
portion behind that. He explained how that design impacts the layout of multiple homes.
Mayor Barthel asked if it would be possible to split the property into two lots with a split driveway
off Raven Street. Mr. Janish explained they would need to get the frontage off Raven Street or
th
155, so some type of cul-de-sac would need to be constructed and identified where that could
happen.
Mayor Barthel invited the applicant to address the Council.
Mark Katzenberger introduced himself and stated they would like to purchase the back half of the
property. He stated the existing resident would remain in his home on a five-acre lot, and they
would propose dividing the remaining property as proposed. He noted the existing resident is
willing to sign something stating that he would not further subdivide his remaining five acres.
th
Matt Barker stated their first hope was to have a driveway off 155 with shared access for two lots
but found out that was not an option. He commented that a cul-de-sac is very expensive, at
$150,000 to $170,000, which led them to think of another concept that could work and support
that infrastructure cost.
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 6
Councilmember Schue asked if there are other people in mind for the other homes proposed to be
constructed. Mr. Katzenberger stated he would be building a home and the Barkers would be
building a home. He commented they would prepare the third lot with area for a home to be
constructed and that lot would be sold. Mr. Barker explained the third lot would help to offset the
cost for the cul-de-sac construction.
Mr. Janish noted he is looking for input on the three questions in the staff report and began with
the proposed 2.5-acre lot size.
Mayor Barthel stated the only way that this proposal would meet the 2.5-acre lot size requirement
and still fit within the Code would be to consider the five-acre parcel as part of the development.
Councilmember Godfrey commented the five-acre parcel would be part of the Planned Unit
Development (PUD), which would then result in a total of four units. She stated the alternative
would be a shorter cul-de-sac and two lots instead of three.
Councilmember Schue stated he likes larger lot sizes but recognized that the cul-de-sac is a high
cost.
Councilmember Shafto asked if all the homes in the surrounding area are 2.5 acres in size. Mr.
Janish reviewed the lot sizes around the acre of discussion. He provided additional information
about what would be allowed on a two-acre lot versus a 2.5-acre lot in terms of accessory
structures.
Councilmember Shafto stated he could live with lots under 2.5 acres for this proposal.
Mayor Barthel stated the City holds all developers to a standard of 2.5 acres in size as an average.
He did not believe the property to the east would be part of the consideration, as this would be a
lot split with development occurring on the west half of the property.
Councilmember Godfrey asked about the location of the driveway for the east side of the property.
Mayor Barthel replied that it is off Nightingale Street.
Mayor Barthel noted another long cul-de-sac would be a lot for the City to plow.
Councilmember Schue asked if the City has had any similar requests of this nature, where a portion
of the property is being split for development, but the existing home remains on a portion of the
property. Mr. Janish commented there have been splits in the urban area but could not recall a
similar situation in the rural area. He explained that a cul-de-sac would be needed in order to
create additional lots on this property, as the requirement for frontage cannot be met to allow
another driveway.
Councilmember Godfrey recognized that this is not just an issue of frontage and access but also
density.
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 7
Councilmember Schue commented the cul-de-sac is a high cost and recognized that adding a third
lot helps to defray the cost of that infrastructure.
Councilmember Shafto commented a third lot also helps the City, as that will help to reduce the
overall maintenance costs that will be needed for the cul-de-sac.
Councilmember Schue stated he partially agrees with the comments of the Mayor but noted the
cul-de-sac would be required whether there are two or three lots, and there will be maintenance
costs for that. He stated for that reason, he can support three lots.
Councilmember Godfrey asked at what point the City breaks even on a cul-de-sac, recognizing
that there are maintenance needs but revenue is generated from an additional property. Mr.
Berkowitz agreed that additional tax base would be generated from a third property and
assessments would then be split between three properties rather than two properties.
Mayor Barthel stated the assessment would remain the same to the City, as 25 percent of the project
cost is assessed to residents and the remaining 75 percent is funded by the City. He noted the
benefit would be to the residents on the cul-de-sac, as that 25 percent would be split between three
residents rather than two.
Councilmember Godfrey noted the City is also generating additional tax revenue off a third
property. She recognized this is a tough decision but reiterated that they are at the point in
development where every decision will continue to be difficult. She stated they do not want to
make decisions that they cannot administer reasonably and consistently, but they also need to be
aware of the challenges and be flexible.
Councilmember Shafto asked how much of the cul-de-sac would be cut off if there were only two
lots. Mr. Janish stated with two lots, they could have 160-foot lot widths.
Mr. Berkowitz stated even if the cul-de-sac were reduced, that would only reduce that cost by
$20,000, and the cost would still be $150,000 for the cul-de-sac.
Councilmember Shafto commented he could support two-acre lot sizes.
Mayor Barthel confirmed four members of the Council in support of two-acre lot sizes. He moved
to the second question related to the use of a deed restriction for future subdivisions, explaining
the resident on the east side would need to add the requirement to his deed that the lot could never
be split.
Mayor Barthel confirmed full Council support for the requirement of a deed restriction preventing
future subdivision. He moved to the topic of emergency access road versus flag lot. He explained
a cul-de-sac exceeding 500 feet in length requires an emergency access road.
Councilmember Shafto confirmed that, as drafted, the cul-de-sac length would be 500.2 feet, which
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 8
is just over that threshold.
Mayor Barthel noted the City has required every developer to put in an emergency access for a
cul-de-sac exceeding 500 feet. He recognized that a cul-de-sac would still be needed, even if they
had flag lots, as there is not enough frontage for a driveway. He was unsure if there would be any
other way to create an emergency access other than coming off Nightingale Street.
Councilmember Shafto stated he does not see the risk difference from a cul-de-sac going to the
left or the road going to the right, which dead-ends. Mayor Barthel stated the last developer who
was required to have an emergency access also pointed out that dead-end, and the Council made
it clear that a previous Council allowed that and the new Council is not allowing those exceptions.
Councilmember Shafto stated if they are doing emergency access, that would be a benefit to every
property to the east as well. Mayor Barthel agreed, if the emergency access comes from
Nightingale Street. He stated the developer would need to get rights from the property owner to
the east to put that access in.
Councilmember Shafto referenced the location of the ditch and noted the emergency access would
then need to come from south of the existing home. He stated he does not love that there is no
emergency access going to the west, but recognized that was a past Council decision.
Ms. Cotton asked if the cul-de-sac to the west is temporary. Ms. Janish replied it is not, explaining
that it is a permanent cul-de-sac which terminates that rural development. He stated the length of
that is roughly one-quarter mile.
Councilmember Shafto stated it is 500 feet exactly and there does not appear to be a practical
location for an emergency access. He stated if the Fire Department does not have concerns with
the cul-de-sac, he would not require an emergency access. Councilmember Godfrey agreed as the
length is right at the threshold.
Mr. Janish provided additional clarification on the property lines and cul-de-sac location and
length, noting it would actually exceed 500 feet. He stated based on the information they have, he
would estimate the length to be around 700 feet.
Councilmember Schue stated it would then be beyond 500 by more than just a couple of feet.
Councilmembers Shafto and Godfrey stated they would then have to rethink their positions. It was
confirmed that in order for the cul-de-sac to remain under 500 feet, the flag lots would be required.
Councilmember Godfrey stated if the cul-de-sac is going to exceed 500 feet, an emergency access
would be needed.
Mayor Barthel referenced the earlier comment that an emergency access could benefit the existing
homes to the west and stated he does not want to place the burden on Mr. Sather to provide
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 9
emergency access to those properties that already exist. He stated the emergency access would
only be for the three new properties being discussed.
Councilmember Shafto stated if it was constructed, it would seem that it would become an
emergency access for the other properties as well by nature. Councilmember Schue agreed.
Councilmember Godfrey was unsure how that would help the properties to the west, as the road is
already there. Mayor Barthel explained if a tree blocked Raven Street and homes were on fire,
emergency responders could use the emergency access to get through.
Councilmember Schue stated while it would still provide benefit to others, they would not be
making this decision based on that fact. He stated the cul-de-sac would exceed 500 feet, so an
additional access would be required.
Councilmember Shafto commented if the cul-de-sac were reduced to 500 feet and only two homes
were constructed, he would not be concerned with requiring an emergency access.
Mayor Barthel confirmed the support of the full Council to require an emergency access for a cul-
de-sac length over 500 feet.
Mr. Janish moved to the topic of flag lots.
Councilmember Godfrey commented she would not have a problem with flag lots and would hope
the developer would do everything they could to position the homes in a way that they would still
be staggered and would not be directly in front of or behind their neighbor. She stated she has
seen flag lots in other communities that have been well done.
Councilmember Shafto stated from a practical standpoint, it would seem there is still the same
emergency access problem, as lot three would have a long driveway. He commented that
aesthetically he does not have a big issue with it.
Mayor Barthel stated he does not favor flag lots. He stated the Council needs to be cautious
because if the Council agrees to flag lots, the plan could then come back with 60-foot frontage for
the lots.
Councilmember Godfrey stated she would not be as concerned with the frontage, but with the
layout of the homes on the lots. Mr. Janish noted a sketch plan would need to be provided for this
process, which would allow additional input and feedback. She stated she is receptive to the
concept of a flag lot, depending on how the rest of the property is utilized.
Councilmember Shafto stated he shares a similar sentiment to Councilmember Godfrey and could
support it for this property.
Councilmember Engelhardt stated he can support the flag lots.
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 10
Councilmember Schue stated he agrees with Mayor Barthel on this issue. Mayor Barthel stated
his concern is with the front footage.
Mayor Barthel confirmed there are three members of the Council in support of the flag lot concept
for this property.
Mayor Barthel briefly recessed the meeting at 8:06 p.m.
Mayor Barthel reconvened the meeting at 8:11 p.m.
DISCUSS ACCESSORY APARTMENT AND “OTHER APARTMENTS”
Mr. Janish stated the Council is requested to review and provide direction related to Accessory
Apartments and “Other Apartments”, and reviewed the staff report.
Councilmember Godfrey noted that older homes sometimes had stairs and a separate entrance and
asked if that definition would include an entrance from an attached garage. She explained many
people enter their homes only through the garage even though they have a front door. Mr. Janish
provided different examples of home layouts as to what would be allowed or disallowed per the
definition.
Mayor Barthel stated he agrees with the definition. He stated if there is a separate entrance, the
unit can then be rented out, so an accessory apartment would then need to use the same access. He
confirmed the support of the full Council in agreement with the definition of accessory apartment.
Mr. Janish asked for thoughts about the updates to a duplex and combining those items. Mayor
Barthel stated he also likes that definition and confirmed the full support of the Council.
Mr. Janish stated now that they have defined accessory apartments, they need to decide whether
they want to allow them, conditionally allow them, or allow them through an Interim Use Permit
(IUP).
Mayor Barthel stated he would support requiring a Conditional Use Permit (CUP), as that allows
an additional layer of review and detail to be provided. He confirmed the full support of the
Council to require a CUP.
Mr. Janish provided additional information on “other apartments” and their requirements, such as
accessory dwelling units (ADUs) and guest houses.
Mayor Barthel stated they should define kitchen facilities given the last discussion on that topic.
Ms. Cotton asked if a bathroom would be allowed in a guest house. It was the consensus of the
Council that a water connection should not be allowed for a guest house.
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 11
Mr. Janish reviewed the next item related to employees on premises, and it was the consensus of
the full Council to remove that from Code. He moved to dwelling units at commercial facilities
and used the example of mini-storage facilities that have a residential unit for the property
manager. It was the consensus of the full Council to remove that allowance.
Councilmember Shafto asked if a guest house should be conditionally permitted. Councilmember
Godfrey noted a building permit would still be required and did not want to overcomplicate things.
Mr. Janish noted they will most likely be making amendments to shoreland definitions after
receiving information from the DNR. He stated within the shoreland district, they do allow for a
guest cottage, which is really an ADU in the shoreland district but has a maximum size of 700
square feet. He stated they have asked the DNR if they can increase the allowed size to 900 square
feet to match the regulations for an ADU. The full Council agreed with the allowed size change
to 900 square feet. He provided a brief overview of some of the changes being considered for the
shoreland ordinance in order to remain compliant with the DNR.
OTHER TOPICS
Mr. Berkowitz noted that tonight in the Council Chambers there is a public hearing being held to
consider a request for an IUP to haul dirt into a property and encouraged the Council to pay
attention to that item and the input received as the request moves forward, providing a brief
overview.
Ms. Cotton noted on the Mayor and City Council webpage, there is a new feature that would allow
a resident to email all members of the Council in one email. She stated that Councilmembers can
respond to the resident, but cannot respond to all.
Mr. Janish commented the Petersen family is looking at the large agricultural building on the
property, attempting to convert that into a residential accessory structure. He stated the centerpiece
could then be sold off with that building as a residential property where a new home could be
constructed.
FUTURE AGENDA ITEM REQUESTS
Councilmember Schue stated he is interested in getting more information in the future on the poll
pads and paper ballots as discussed recently by ACEIT.
Mayor Barthel noted there are not three votes to bring that topic forward.
Councilmember Godfrey commented she just finished her training as an Election Judge and
commented that paper rosters are available in every precinct as a backup.
Mayor Barthel commented he has been approached by a few business owners who follow the rules
and do not place signs within the right-of-way. He stated he has noticed signs in the right-of-way
Andover City Council Workshop Meeting
Minutes – September 22, 2026
Page 12
all over town. He recognized that the signs are currently not allowed, but he would like to see
more enforcement, such as potentially fining those businesses that place their signs in the right-of-
way.
Mr. Berkowitz asked if the City would have the ability to remove signs in the County right-of-
way.
Mayor Barthel confirmed he had support from the Council to add that topic to a future agenda.
COUNCIL COMMITTEE UPDATES
No comments.
ADJOURNMENT
Motion by Shafto, Seconded by Schue, to adjourn. Motion carried unanimously. The workshop
meeting adjourned at 8:48 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Amanda Staple, Recording Secretary