HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-09-22
1685 CROSSTOWN BOULEVARD N.W. ANDOVER, MINNESOTA 55304 (763) 755-5100
FAX (763) 755-8923 WWW.ANDOVERMN.GOV
Andover Planning and Zoning Commission
MeetingAgenda
September22, 2026
Andover City Hall
Council Chambers
7:00 p.m.
1.Call to Order
2.Pledge of Allegiance
3.Approval of Minutes –August 25,2026, Regular Meeting
4.Public Hearing: Variance for Accessory Structure Height –15349 7th Ave NW–PID # 19-
32-24-13-0012. (Applicant: Todd Kubes).
5.Public Hearing: Consider an Interim Use Permit–Mining and Land Reclamation –
th
Unaddressedpropertyat the NE quadrant of Prairie Road and 146Lane –PID#25-32-24-
21-0004. (Applicant: Mark Smith).
6.Other Business
7.Adjournment
STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item #3
TO: Planning and Zoning Commissioners
FROM: Peter Hellegers, City Planner
SUBJECT:Approval of Minutes
DATE: September 22, 2026
REQUEST
The Planning & Zoning Commission is requested to approve the August 25, 2026, regular
meeting minutes.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8 PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION REGULARMEETING –AUGUST 25,
9 2026
10
11 The RegularMeeting of the Andover Planning and Zoning Commission was called to
12 order by ChairLoehleinon August 25, 2026, at7:00 p.m., at the Andover City Hall, 1685
13 Crosstown Boulevard NW, Andover, Minnesota.
14
15 Commissioners present:ChairNick Loehlein, Commissioners Scott Hudson, Chuck
16 Naughton, Jonathan Weinhold, Nicole Wicklund, and Ryan
17 Winge.
18
19 Commissioners absent: Commissioner Roger Grout.
20
21 Also present: City Planner Peter Hellegers and Community Development
22 Director Joe Janish.
23
24
25 CALL TO ORDER
26
27 PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
28
29 APPROVAL OF MINUTES
30
31 Motion.The Chairassumed amotion to approve the July 28, 2026,Regular Meeting
32 Minutes as presented. Commissioners Hudson, Naughton, Weinhold, Wicklund, and
33 Winge voted in favor. ChairLoehlein voted present because he had been absent from that
34 meeting. The Motion passed.
35
36 PUBLIC HEARING – CONSIDER A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT (CUP) FOR
37 PLANNING UNIT DEVELOPMENT (PUD) WITHIN SHORELAND FOR WARD
38 LAKE PRESERVE, A 9-LOT SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SUBDIVISION
39 WITH DEVIATIONS RELATED TO LOT WIDTH, BLOCK LENGTH, RIGHT OF
40 WAY WIDTH, TO BE LOCATED AT THE UNADDRESSED PROPERTY AT 17XXX
41 WARD LAKE DRIVE NW; PID 12-32-24-22-0007 – WARD LAKE OF MN, LLC
42 (APPLICANT)
43
44 Community Development Director Janish reviewed the request from Ward Lake of MN,
45 LLC for a Conditional Use Permit for a Planned Unit Development to create Ward Lake
46 Preserve, a nine-lot rural single-family subdivision on approximately 29.97 acres south of
47 Ward Lake.
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 2
1
2 Commissioner Weinhold asked why six lots were proposed at approximately one-half of
3 the standard frontage. Mr. Janish explained that the narrower frontage allowed the same
4 number of lots to be served with less roadway infrastructure. A design meeting the 300-
5 foot frontage requirement had been considered. Still, it required an additional permanent
6 cul-de-sac, increased construction and future maintenance costs, additional snow-removal
7 operations, and potentially greater disturbance.
8
9 Commissioner Winge confirmed that nine lots could be obtained under a design meeting
10 the underlying R-1 standards, but only with additional roadway and a second cul-de-sac.
11 Mr. Janish agreed.
12
13 Chair Loehlein explained that the PUD hearing addressed the requested zoning deviations.
14 In contrast, the following preliminary plat hearing would address whether the plat
15 conformed to the standards established through the PUD.
16
17 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to open the public hearing at 7:25 p.m. Motion carries
18 by unanimous consent.
19
20 Mr. Janish summarized an email from Shelly Golden, 643 170th Lane NW. Ms. Golden
21 expressed concern that the conceptual homes on Lots 3 and 4 had moved closer to her
22 backyard, requiring removal of mature trees and reducing the privacy her family had
23 enjoyed for approximately 21 years. She also objected to widening and paving the existing
24 driveway proposed for emergency access, citing additional tree loss and the possibility of
25 pedestrian or bicycle activity. She asked how much closer the homes would be than under
26 the earlier layout.
27
28 Mr. Janish explained that the proposed homes appeared to be approximately 175 to 200
29 feet from the southern property line, substantially farther than the approximately 40-foot
30 rear-yard setback. He could not provide an exact measurement of the shift from the earlier
31 concept but noted that driveway grades likely influenced the conceptual house locations.
32
33 Ms. Mary Bottineau, 17103 Ward Lake Drive NW, explained that the applicant had
34 worked with her family to relocate the temporary cul-de-sac so it would not interfere with
35 their garage or preclude future development of their approximately 40-acre property to the
36 east. She understood the concerns raised by the southern neighbors. She shared frustration
37 with the required paved emergency route because it would replace a private driveway,
38 remove mature trees that had been in her family for generations, and potentially attract
39 additional activity. She noted, however, that the City Council had already directed that the
40 access be paved and built to accommodate emergency vehicles.
41
42 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to close the public hearing at 7:33 p.m.Motion carries
43 by unanimous consent.
44
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 3
1 Commissioner Winge asked whether Andover had other developments with long cul-de-
2 sacs and paved emergency access routes. Mr. Janish and Mr. Hellegers identified
3 Creekside Meadows as an example.
4
5 Commissioner Naughton asked whether the City had previously approved lot widths near
6 150 or 165 feet in rural developments. Mr. Janish cited Petersen Farms, where
7 approximately 150-foot-wide lots and 1.5-acre lot sizes had been approved without bonus
8 density.
9
10 Chair Loehlein asked whether anything could be done to respond to the Goldens’ privacy
11 concerns. Mr. Janish explained that the conceptual homes were far beyond the minimum
12 setback and that final house plans could potentially be adjusted through garage steps,
13 driveway design, house placement, or landscaping. The applicant’s engineer could provide
14 additional information.
15
16 Commissioner Winge remained concerned that the substantial frontage deviation appeared
17 primarily financial and that removing one or two lots might preserve more trees and
18 reduce grading. He recalled asking during the sketch-plan review to see an alternative
19 design and did not believe that request had been fully answered.
20
21 Commissioner Weinhold shared concerns regarding the lot-width deviation and the paved
22 emergency access. He asked whether the gate, HOA maintenance, and other controls
23 would adequately discourage misuse of the route and protect neighboring privacy. Mr.
24 Janish confirmed the route would be paved to support expensive fire apparatus safely and
25 would be maintained by the nine-lot HOA. Existing neighboring properties would not be
26 required to join the HOA.
27
28 Chair Loehlein observed that PUDs should produce a better development than a
29 conventional “pan of brownies” layout. He believed the proposal offered low-impact
30 design and significant open space but acknowledged that reducing frontage from 300 feet
31 to 165 feet was substantial. Mr. Janish noted that the site’s basic acreage calculation could
32 permit approximately 11.9 lots. At the same time, only nine were proposed, although
33 actual layout feasibility would still depend on wetlands, floodplain, roads, and other
34 constraints.
35
36 Commissioner Hudson emphasized that the lots remained large, generally ranging from
37 approximately 2.5 to more than four acres, and contained substantial upland area. He was
38 comfortable with the reduced frontage and considered concerns about widespread misuse
39 of an HOA-owned emergency trail unlikely.
40
41 Motion by Commissioner Winge, seconded by Commissioner Weinhold, to recommend
42 the City Council deny the PUD. Motion failed on a 3-ayes (Winge, Weinhold, Naughton),
43 3-nays (Loehlein, Wicklund, Hudson) vote.
44
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 4
1 At the Commission’s request, Mr. Bob Molstad of Sathre-Bergquist, 14000 25th Avenue,
2 Suite 120, Plymouth, appeared on behalf of the applicant. He confirmed that an earlier
3 nine-lot concept met the R-1 lot-width standards by adding a second permanent cul-de-
4 sac. The current design retained nine lots but reduced roadway, grading, and long-term
5 public maintenance. He also confirmed that the street and cul-de-sac had been shifted to
6 protect the eastern property owner’s garage and future development options.
7
8 Mr. Janish clarified that two lots on a permanent cul-de-sac may have 160-foot frontage
9 under the existing R-1 standards, while the other lots in the earlier concept met the 300-
10 foot requirement. The alternative therefore could have been approved without a PUD
11 frontage deviation, but it would require more pavement and would more directly affect the
12 Bottineau property.
13
14 Commissioner Wicklund observed that the applicant had worked with neighboring owners
15 and City staff, reduced infrastructure, preserved future access to the eastern property, and
16 proposed fewer lots than the mathematical maximum. She suggested the applicant contact
17 the Goldens and consider additional or more mature landscaping to restore privacy.
18 Mr. Molstad agreed to contact the Goldens during the following week and discuss possible
19 mitigation.
20
21 Commissioner Hudson summarized the central choice as whether the City preferred the
22 current plan or an otherwise compliant plan with another permanent cul-de-sac, additional
23 pavement, more maintenance, and a greater impact on the eastern property. Following that
24 explanation, Commissioner Winge indicated he had been persuaded that the current design
25 was the better alternative.
26
27 Motion by Commissioner Hudson, seconded by Commissioner Winge, to recommend the
28 City Council approve the Conditional Use Permit for a Planned Unit Development within
29 shoreland for Ward Lake Preserve, subject to the conditions contained in the draft
30 resolution. The motion carried 4-2 (Naughton, Weinhold).
31
32 PUBLIC HEARING – CONSIDER A PRELIMINARY PLAT FOR WARD LAKE
33 PRESERVE, A 9-LOT SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SUBDIVISION TO BE
34 LOCATED AT THE UNADDRESSED PROPERTY AT 17XXX WARD LAKE DRIVE
35 NW; PID 12-32-24-22-0007 – WARD LAKE OF MN, LLC (APPLICANT)
36
37 Community Development Director Janish reviewed the preliminary plat for Ward Lake
38 Preserve. He explained that the plat contained the same nine lots, roadway system,
39 temporary cul-de-sac, emergency access, conservation easement, stormwater facilities,
40 private wells and septic systems, and conceptual home locations discussed under the PUD.
41 Because the Commission had recommended approval of the PUD deviations, the
42 preliminary plat was consistent with the proposed development standards.
43
44 Commissioner Winge requested that the applicant later provide the earlier concept
45 showing the second permanent cul-de-sac as a point of reference.
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 5
1
2 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to open the public hearing at approximately 8:14 p.m.
3 Motion carries by unanimous consent.
4
5 No one from the public spoke, and the previously submitted email had been directed
6 specifically to the PUD hearing.
7
8 ChairLoehlein assumed a motion to close the public hearing at approximately 8:15 p.m.
9 Motion carries by unanimous consent.
10
11 Motion by Commissioner Hudson, seconded by Commissioner Winge, to recommend the
12 City Council approve the preliminary plat for Ward Lake Preserve. The motion carried on
13 a 4-2 (Naughton, Weinhold) vote.
14
15 PUBLIC HEARING – CONSIDER A COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT
16 (CPA) FOR THE “FIELDS OF ANDOVER” (PARCEL IDENTIFICATION
17 NUMBERS LISTED BELOW) TO: (1) ADD THE MASTER PLANNED AREA (MPA)
18 FUTURE LAND USE DISTRICT INTO THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. (2)
19 CHANGE THE FUTURE LAND USE DISTRICT OF THE PARCELS FROM RURAL
20 RESERVE RESIDENTIAL (RRR) TO MPA, (3) CONSIDER AN EXPANSION OF
21 THE METROPOLITAN URBAN SERVICE AREA (MUSA) BOUNDARY TO
22 INCLUDE THE PARCELS, AND (4) TO ADD THE PARCELS INTO SEWER
23 STAGING FOR 2026-3030.
24
25 Parcel Identification Numbers (“Fields of Andover”): (Agenda Items 6 through 8)
26
27 28-32-24-22-0001 21-32-24-24-0001 21-32-24-22-0003 28-32-24-32-0003
28 21-32-24-34-0003 22-32-24-22-0019 21-32-24-22-0008 21-32-24-34-0001
29 21-32-24-43-0001 21-32-24-12-0001 21-32-24-22-0004 28-32-24-22-0004
30 21-32-24-42-0001 21-32-24-21-0002 16-32-24-33-0004 21-32-24-31-0002
31 16-32-24-34-0001 16-32-24-43-0001 21-32-24-13-0001 21-32-24-44-0001
32 16-32-24-44-0001 15-32-24-33-0030 28-32-24-23-0002 21-32-24-41-0024
33 21-32-24-11-0003 16-32-24-33-0003 29-32-24-41-0003 28-32-24-21-0001
34 21-32-24-23-0001 16-32-24-33-0005 28-32-24-12-0003 29-32-24-14-0029
35
36 City Planner Hellegers reviewed the request from Artemis Development for a
37 Comprehensive Plan Amendment affecting approximately 808 acres consisting of 32
38 parcels. The amendment would establish a new Master Planned Area future land-use
39 designation, redesignate the property from Rural Reserve Residential to Master Planned
40 Area, extend the Metropolitan Urban Service Area boundary, and place the property
41 within the 2026-2030 sewer-staging period.
42
43 Mr. Hellegers explained that the Rural Reserve designation had preserved the area for
44 future urban development until master planning and municipal utilities became feasible,
45 and noted that the Commission reviewed a sketch plan in June 2025 and the City Council
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 6
1 adopted the Final Alternative Urban Area-wide Review and mitigation plan in June 2026.
2 Approval of the amendment would not authorize construction, as additional approvals
3 would be required for zoning, a master Planned Unit Development, and preliminary and
4 final plats. The development is anticipated to build out over approximately ten to fifteen
5 years, with the entire site placed in the 2026-2030 sewer-staging category to avoid
6 repeated Comprehensive Plan amendments while allowing the City Council to retain
7 authority over actual development phasing.
8
9 Commissioner Hudson asked how remaining Rural Reserve parcels outside the 808-acre
10 project could be developed later. Mr. Hellegers explained that a property added to the
11 current development might require renewed environmental review or inclusion in the five-
12 year AUAR update. A separate smaller proposal would still require its own
13 Comprehensive Plan amendment, MUSA extension, zoning, and development approvals.
14
15 Commissioner Weinhold asked whether showing the entire area in the 2026-2030 sewer
16 stage meant it would be completely developed by 2030. Mr. Hellegers and Mr. Janish
17 explained that the staging designation allows development to begin during that period and
18 does not require completion. The anticipated buildout remained approximately ten to
19 twelve years.
20
21 Commissioner Winge asked how the proposal related to the City’s temporary development
22 moratorium within portions of the existing MUSA. Mr. Janish explained that the
23 moratorium concerned capacity at the outer branches of the existing sewer system. The
24 Fields of Andover proposal was specifically exempt because its new sanitary sewer would
25 connect directly to the major interceptor near Crooked Lake and Bunker Lake Boulevard,
26 effectively connecting to the trunk rather than relying on multiple existing neighborhoods.
27
28 Chair Loehlein summarized that the Rural Reserve had been set aside for eventual urban
29 development when utilities and coordinated planning became practical. Mr. Hellegers
30 agreed that the application represented the stage anticipated by the existing
31 Comprehensive Plan.
32
33 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to open the public hearing at approximately 8:30 p.m.
34 Motion carries by unanimous consent.
35
36 Mr. Brent Miller, 3140 149th Avenue NW, supported the Comprehensive Plan change but
37 expressed concern about private well quality during construction and dewatering, traffic
38 on 149th Avenue, and assumptions used in the AUAR traffic study. He noted that the
39 traffic model assumed an Andover Boulevard extension through property not included in
40 the project. He asked the City to balance the developer's rights with the long-term impacts
41 borne by existing residents.
42
43 Ms. Lynette Bauers, 14570 Jonquil Street NW, asked how the 100-year floodplain would
44 be protected. She described seasonal standing water in the area and worried that filling or
45 construction could redirect water toward existing homes. She also asked that traffic counts
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 7
1 be conducted while school was in session because school employees, students, and related
2 traffic materially affect Round Lake Boulevard.
3
4 Mr. Donald Bauers, 14570 Jonquil Street NW, asked whether the five homes at the end of
5 Jonquil Street that currently use septic systems would be required to connect to the
6 proposed sewer. He also questioned how homes could be built on peat and flood-prone
7 land and described canals and pumping historically used to manage farm drainage.
8 Mr. Matt Voorhees, 3120 153rd Avenue NW, asked where residents could review the
9 AUAR and traffic studies, whether development would proceed from south to north,
10 where primary street connections would be located, and whether nearby existing homes
11 would be required to connect to sewer.
12
13 Mr. Don Mowery, 14561 Kerry Street NW, described difficulty entering Round Lake
14 Boulevard from South Coon Creek Drive and asked whether a traffic signal or other
15 intersection improvement was planned. He also asked where development entrances
16 would be located.
17
18 Mr. Terry McDonald, 14459 Kerry Street NW, described limited sight distance, roadway
19 curvature, and high speeds at South Coon Creek Drive and Round Lake Boulevard. He
20 asked the City to address intersection controls and safe access before adding substantial
21 traffic.
22
23 Mr. Hellegers summarized three written comments. Kyle and Jenny Elm, 3222 143rd
24 Avenue NW, objected to a possible trail connection across South Coon Creek into a trail
25 and utility easement along their backyard and asked the Commission to deny the requests.
26
27 Mr. Joe Churchich, 2410 151st Avenue NW, opposed high-density urban development,
28 preferred ten-acre lots with wells and septic systems, and cited wildlife, school capacity,
29 infrastructure, population growth, and housing-supply concerns.
30
31 Mrs. Mary and Mr. Bob Harrell, 14955 Ivywood Street NW, requested additional
32 mitigation and buffers wider than 50 feet where necessary.
33
34 Mr. Jake Waleschof Artemis Development, 10850 Old County Road 15, Plymouth,
35 explained that the project had been under review since June 2022 and that the current
36 meeting was the sixteenth public meeting, including two open houses. He outlined the
37 remaining process: agency coordination, individual neighbor meetings, preparation of a
38 master PUD, another public open house, preliminary and final plats, construction plans,
39 and later planning for the commercial and higher-density areas.
40
41 Mr. Walesch explained that the future master PUD would establish the final street and lot
42 layout, parks, trails, public and private amenities, more than 400 acres of open space, edge
43 buffers and landscaping, stormwater and drainage systems, and the phasing schedule. He
44 stated that homes were not planned in the lowest southern flood-prone area; that area
45 would remain open space and could support floodplain mitigation or a wetland complex.
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 8
1
2 Mr. Walesch stated that the developer had committed to installing a traffic signal on
3 Round Lake Boulevard with the first phase of development, even though traffic warrants
4 might not otherwise require the signal until later phases. He agreed to meet directly with
5 residents regarding trail alignments, buffers, landscaping, drainage, and property-specific
6 concerns.
7
8 Mr. Janish explained that well impacts are monitored through construction and dewatering
9 plans. If anticipated impacts are identified, mitigation is arranged in advance; if
10 unanticipated impacts occur, the entity causing the impact is responsible for correction.
11 He also clarified that the proposed sanitary sewer was not intended to serve the Jonquil
12 Street homes. The project sewer would cross South Coon Creek Drive and extend north
13 into the development. Existing nearby residents had not been proposed for connection.
14
15 Mr. Janish explained that the City’s past practice is to discuss utility extensions with
16 neighborhoods when streets are reconstructed. Municipal sewer is generally not extended
17 to large existing lots without neighborhood support because the Metropolitan Council
18 expects urban density where sewer is provided.
19
20 Mr. Hellegers stated that the Final AUAR, appendices, traffic study, and supporting
21 reports were available on the Planning Department page of the City’s website.
22
23 Ms. Lynette Bauers, 14570 Jonquil Street NW, clarified that the five properties in her area
24 are each less than one acre and already receive City water service but use individual septic
25 systems. She explained that sewer was not extended to the five homes when the area was
26 originally developed because doing so would have required a lift station and was not
27 financially practical. She questioned whether the smaller lot sizes could affect whether the
28 properties might eventually be required to connect to municipal sewer.
29
30 Mr. Janish again confirmed that the Fields of Andover sewer was not designed to serve
31 those properties.
32
33 The Planning Commission took a brief recess at 9:05 p.m. and reconvened at 9:15 p.m.
34
th
35 Mr. Laura Miller, 3140 149Avenue NW, asked whether residents could obtain
36 information from the developer’s presentation, particularly the project layout and
37 development timeline.
38
39 Mr. Walesch confirmed that the information could be provided and agreed to follow up
40 with residents.
41
42 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to close the public hearing at approximately 9:18 p.m.
43 Motion carries by unanimous consent.
44
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 9
1 Additional discussion addressed expected construction timing, the location of the initial
2 signal, traffic analysis during later plats, drainage, floodplain protection, wetland
3 permitting, school and service capacity, trails, wildlife, and buffering. Staff and the
4 applicant repeatedly emphasized that detailed alignments and mitigation would be
5 addressed through the master PUD and subsequent plats, not conclusively through the
6 Comprehensive Plan amendment.
7
8 Commissioner Winge clarified that his concern about wells extended beyond construction
9 dewatering. He asked whether increased municipal pumping for approximately 1,500 to
10 1,600 new homes could affect private wells elsewhere in Andover. Mr. Walesch explained
11 that preliminary utility studies identified a possible need for additional water capacity
12 when development was somewhat more than halfway built. Still, additionalstudy and a
13 separate public process would occur before any new municipal well or capacity expansion.
14
15 Chair Loehlein emphasized that the amendment was an important step but not final
16 approval of the development. Future meetings would address street locations, signals,
17 drainage, buffers, utilities, parks, trails, and adjacent-owner concerns. He thanked
18 residents for their professional participation and the applicant for continued public
19 engagement.
20
21 Commissioner Winge asked whether any Commissioner could identify a reason not to
22 proceed. Commissioner Weinhold responded that the developer and City had been
23 proactive, had acknowledged unresolved issues, and had established future processes to
24 address them. ChairLoehlein agreed, noting that the land had long been reserved for
25 eventual urban development and that mitigation would continue through later approvals.
26
27 Motion by Commissioner Hudson, seconded by Commissioner Naughton, to recommend
28 the City Council approve the Comprehensive Plan Amendment for the Fields of Andover
29 as written. The motion carried unanimously.
30
31 PUBLIC HEARING – CONSIDER THE ADOPTION OF THE MASTER PLANNED
32 ZONING DISTRICT (MPZ)
33
34 Community Development Director Janish reviewed proposed City Code amendments
35 establishing the MPZ Master Planned Zoning District to implement the new Master
36 Planned Area designation and provide standards for a coordinated mix of residential and
37 commercial uses, open space, trails, stormwater improvements, and community amenities.
38 The proposed district would require a minimum 50-foot buffer adjacent to lower-intensity
39 residential districts, with specific treatments determined through the future master PUD.
40 Internal streets could utilize a 52-foot right-of-way with parking limited to one side to
41 maintain adequate travel width, and the required soil-correction depth could be reduced
42 from 110 to 85 feet to avoid unnecessary fill and costs. The district would establish an
43 overall residential density of approximately 3.5 to 4.5 units per acre and accommodate a
44 variety of detached and attached housing types and lot widths.
45
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 10
1 Mr. Janish also reviewed proposed standards for setbacks, lot dimensions and coverage,
2 garages, building heights, accessory structures, common space, and other development
3 requirements, explaining that the code would establish overall development standards. At
4 the same time,the future master PUD would determine the location of housing types and
5 detailed site design.
6
7 Commissioner Winge asked whether purchasers would be informed about the limits of
8 corrected soil. Mr. Janish confirmed that the City would retain approved grading and soil-
9 correction plans and make them available during future permit reviews and property
10 transactions.
11
12 Chair Loehlein asked why the draft referred to a PUD for multiple dwellings. Mr. Janish
13 explained that multiple dwellings on one parcel would need to be identified in the overall
14 master PUD. Chair Loehlein emphasized that the objective was one comprehensive master
15 PUD rather than repeated smaller PUDs requesting deviations from the newly adopted
16 standards.
17
18 Commissioner Winge asked whether parking would be formally restricted to one side of
19 the narrower streets. Mr. Janish confirmed that one side would need to be signed for no
20 parking. Commissioner Winge cautioned that parking can become difficult in higher-
21 density neighborhoods and should receive careful attention during the master plan.
22
23 Chair Loehlein asked whether the wider clear lane could function informally as additional
24 space for bicycles. Mr. Janish explained that the City did not have a complete-streets
25 policy for the proposal, but fewer parked vehicles would incidentally provide more
26 operating room for bicyclists and pedestrians. The primary reason for the design was
27 emergency-vehicle access.
28
29 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to open the public hearing at approximately 10:06 p.m.
30 Motion carries by unanimous consent.
31
th
32 Mr. Brent Miller, 3140 149 Avenue NW,supported the 50-foot perimeter buffer. He
33 suggested expressing lot widths as ranges to preserve flexibility if housing products
34 changed during the ten-plus-year buildout. Mr. Janish explained that the listed dimensions
35 were minimums. A product shown on a 40-foot lot could be placed on a 42-or 44-foot lot,
36 provided the development remained within its approved density.
37
38 Mr. Jason Hoosier, 3241 152nd Lane NW, asked whether police, fire, and emergency
39 services could adequately serve the additional population. Mr. Janish explained that
40 current station locations could provide acceptable response times. The staffing level and
41 number of apparatus or law-enforcement personnel would be policy and budget decisions
42 for the City Council as development occurred.
43
44 Chair Loehleinassumed a motion to close the public hearing at approximately 10:10 p.m.
45 Motion carries by unanimous consent.
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 11
1
2 Commissioner Winge asked why front-yard setbacks were reduced while street width was
3 also narrowed. Mr. Janish explained that placing homes closer to the street can create
4 neighborhood interaction and a stronger sense of community. It can also visually narrow
5 the corridor and encourage slower vehicle speeds.
6
7 The Commission reviewed several technical corrections and wording changes contained in
8 the proposed ordinance. Members generally agreed the revisions were consistent with the
9 district's intent and relied on staff’s detailed review.
10
11 Motion by Commissioner Weinhold, seconded by Commissioner Wicklund, to
12 recommend the City Council adopt the Master Planned Zoning District ordinance as
13 written. The motion carried unanimously.
14
15 PUBLIC HEARING – CONSIDER REZONING THE “FIELDS OF ANDOVER”
16 PARCELS (PARCEL IDENTIFICATION NUMBER LISTED IN PREVIOUS ITEM)
17 FROM RURAL RESERVE(RR) TO MPZ
18
19 Community Development Director Janish reviewed the request to rezone the 32 Fields of
20 Andover parcels from Rural Reserve to the newly proposed Master Planned Zoning
21 District. He explained that the rezoning was contingent upon City Council approval of the
22 Comprehensive Plan Amendment and adoption of the MPZ ordinance. Parcels outside the
23 application area would remain Rural Reserve.
24
25 Commissioner Hudson asked what would happen if the proposed development did not
26 proceed after the amendments were adopted. Mr. Janish confirmed that the
27 Comprehensive Plan designation and zoning would remain in effect for future
28 development unless later amended.
29
30 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to open the public hearing at approximately 10:18 p.m.
31 Motion carries by unanimous consent.
32
th
33 Mr. Brent Miller, 3140 149 Avenue NW,supported the rezoning. He recognized the long
34 history of reserving the area for growth, the rights of the affected property owners, the
35 City’s responsibility to plan for infrastructure, and the developer’s record of creating
36 residential neighborhoods. He preferred the proposed residential master plan to more
37 intensive land uses that could otherwise be permitted or proposed.
38
39 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to close the public hearing at approximately 10:20 p.m.
40 Motion carries by unanimous consent.
41
42 Chair Loehlein emphasized that the rezoning was not being treated as a rubber-stamp
43 action. It followed years of planning, environmental review, public meetings, and
44 extensive discussion earlier that evening.
45
RegularAndover Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
Minutes – August 25, 2026
Page 12
1 Motion by Commissioner Weinhold, seconded by Commissioner Hudson, to recommend
2 the City Council approve the rezoning of the Fields of Andover parcels from Rural
3 Reserve to Master Planned Zoning, contingent upon approval of the related
4 Comprehensive Plan Amendment and zoning ordinance. The motion carried unanimously.
5
6 OTHER BUSINESS
7
8 Community Development Director Janish reported that the City Council had approved the
9 Conditional Use Permit reviewed at the Commission’s previous meeting and that activity
10 had begun on the project.
11
12 Chair Loehlein thanked staff for preparing and presenting the extensive reports, maps,
13 ordinance language, and supporting information.
14
15 ADJOURNMENT
16
17 Chair Loehlein assumed a motion to adjourn. Hearing no objection, the motion carried by
18 unanimous consent, and the meeting adjourned at approximately 10:23 p.m.
19
20 Respectfully Submitted,
21
22
23 Sue Osbeck, Recording Secretary
24 TimeSaver Off Site Secretarial, Inc.
STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item #4
TO:Planning and Zoning Commissioners
CC:Joe Janish, Community Development Director
FROM:Peter Hellegers, City Planner
SUBJECT:Public Hearing: Variance Requestfor Accessory Structure Height
th
15349 7AvenueNW, PID #: 19-32-24-13-0012, (Applicant: Todd Kubes).
DATE:September 22, 2026
INTRODUCTION
Consider a request for a3.5-foot variance to allow an accessory structure to be taller than the
th
principal structure for the property at 15349 7Avenue NW(“subject property”).
Figure 1-Location of Subject Property
BACKGROUND
What is a Variance?
A variance is a way that cities may allow for an exception to part of an ordinance for a
specific property. A variance is generally for dimensional standards such as setbacks or height
limits and allows the landowner to deviate from a dimensional rule thatwould otherwise
apply. Minnesota State Statute and City Code provide specific review criteria the City must
consider when reviewing a variance request, and thecriteria areincluded later in this report. If
a variance is approved it becomes a property right which runs with the land.
Zoning and Location
The subject property is located within the R-1: Single Family Rural ResidentialZoning
District. Abutting properties to the north, east, and southare also located in the R-1Zoning
1
th
District. Properties across 7Avenue to the west are in the R-2 Zoning District. The subject
rdth
property is generally located north of 153 Avenue NW, east of 7 Avenue NW, south of
th
155 Avenue NW, and west of Hopi Street NW.
Public Hearing Notice
Public hearing notices were sent to the owners of properties within 700 feet of the subject
property and published in the City’s official newspaper, the Anoka County Union Herald, and
a sign was placed at the subject property.
DISCUSSION
The applicants are requesting a 3.5-foot variance from the accessory structure height
requirements established by City Code § 12-6-3: Accessory Structure Height. The property is
a 5-acre parcel that is zoned R-1. Under § 12-6-3 the maximum building height states that
“…no residential accessory structure shall exceed the building height of the principal
structure,…”. The principal structure at the subject property is an earth-sheltered home with
only the south/southeast portion of the home accessible to measure where the building has a
height of approximately 17.5 feet. Most of the street side of the property is also screened
from the street by the same hillside that surrounds the principal structure. The proposed
accessory building would be located further away from the street than the principal structure
and is proposed to have a height of approximately 21 feet which is consistent with the height
of other residential buildings in the area.
Figure 2 – Approximate Location of Proposed Accessory Structure
The following table compares the maximum accessory structure height established by City
Code relative to the variance request.
Variance Request
City Code Principal Requested Variance
RequirementStructure Accessory Request
HeightStructure
Height
Accessory
Building Same as house17.5 ft21 ft 3.5 ft
Height
Review Criteria
City Code 12-15-9 establishes review criteria for considering variance requests and states that
variances shall only be permitted when they are in harmony with the general purposes and
intent of the official control and when the variances are consistent with the comprehensive
plan. Variances may be granted when the applicant for the variances establishes that there are
practical difficulties in complying with the official control. “Practical difficulties” as used in
connection with the granting of a variance, means:
1. The property owner proposes to use the property in a reasonable manner not permitted
by an official control.
2. The plight of the landowner is due to circumstances unique to their property not
created by the landowner.
3. The variance, if granted, will not alter the essential character of the locality.
4. Economic considerations alone do not constitute practical difficulties.
The City Council may also impose reasonable conditions on the granting of a variance
request. Conditions must be related to and must bear a rough proportionality to the impact
created by the variance.
As practical difficulties must be established by the applicants, some materials submitted by
the applicants are attached for review in support of their request (see attachment 4-5).
Analysis of Variance Request
A building permit for the “earth home” on the subject property was approved in 1981. The
hillside on the subject property also screens nearly all the property from the adjacent street.
The survey provided by the applicant shows that the proposed garage would be located behind
the house and would meet all required minimum setback requirements.
Minimum Setbacks
City Code Requirement Proposed
Front Setback Same as house / 60 ft 365 ft
Side Setback 5 ft50 ft / 195 ft
Rear Setback 5 ft 252 ft
The height of the proposed accessory building, at approximately 21 feet, appears to be
consistent with the height of pitched roof residential buildings and accessory structures to the
north and south of the subject property.
City staff have informed the applicants that practical difficulties need to be established for
variance cases and that the City would need to review the application against those practical
difficulties provisions. The applicants’ responses from their application are below:
1. The property owner proposes to use the property in a reasonable manner not permitted
by an official control.
The current home is an earth home, which means it doesn’t have a standard pitched
roof. The request is to have up to a 21-foot-tall garage. The garage will be 365 feet
from the roadway with a lot elevation change of approximately 14 feet within the first
90 feet of the lot.
2. The plight of the landowner is due to circumstances unique to their property not
created by the landowner.
The home is an earth home and doesn’t have a standard pitched roof making the
height lower than typical homes. The proposed accessory structure would be 365 feet
from the roadway.
3. The variance, if granted, will not alter the essential character of the locality.
The 21-foot height is typical of the adjacent property garages. It is 365 feet from the
roadway, and 49 feet from the property line to the south.
4. Economic considerations alone do not constitute practical difficulties.
Height request is not to save money, it would actually cost more.
ACTION REQUESTED
The Planning and Zoning Commission is requested to:
1. Conduct a public hearing on the proposed request, and
2. Compare the variance requests with the review criteria of City Code 12-15-9 and make
a recommendation to the City Council based on findings of fact.
Staff have drafted the attached resolutions for approval or denial of the variance request.
Specific findings related to the variance criteria need to be adopted by the City Council when
they approve or deny the request.
Attachment(s):
4-1: Draft Resolutions of Approval and Denial
4-2: Location Map
4-3: City Code Excerpt - § 12-6-3 – Accessory Structure Height
4-4: City Code Excerpt - § 12-15-9 – Variances
4-5: Applicant’s Responses, Plans, and Survey
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RESOLUTION NO. RXXX-26
A RESOLUTION APPROVING VARIANCES FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT
th
15439 7AVENUE NW; PID# 19-32-24-13-0012 LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
(See attached legal description)
th
WHEREAS, Todd Kubes is the owner of a parcel of land located at 15349 7 Avenue NW,
Andover, Minnesota with Parcel ID Number 19-32-24-13-0012; and,
WHEREAS, Todd Kubes applied to the City for a variance to the accessory structure height
on the subject property; and,
WHEREAS, the proposal would vary from City Code 12-6-3: Accessory Structure Height in
that it would allow an accessory structure that is approximately 3.5 feet taller than the
principal structure (house), and,
WHEREAS, the principal structure on the property is an earth sheltered home with one
exposed side, and,
WHEREAS, staff has reviewed the variance request; and,
WHEREAS, pursuant to published and mailed notice thereof, the Planning and Zoning
Commission held a public hearing on September 22, 2026;
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommends to the City Council approval
of the variance request; and,
WHEREAS, the City Council completed a review of the variance request along with the
recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Commission and all materials provided
including review of the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting; and,
WHEREAS, the City Council agrees with the recommendation of the Planning and Zoning
Commission and approves the variance request to allow an accessory building height that
exceeds the height of the principal building height by three and a half (3.5) feet; and,
WHEREAS, based on the criteria for granting a variance under City Code 12-15-9, the City
Council finds the following findings of fact to support the approval of the variance request:
1. The property owner proposes to use the property in a reasonable manner not permitted
by an official control. The request is for an accessory building that is consistent with
the height of other structures in the area.
2. The plight of the landowner is due to circumstances unique to their property, not
created by the landowner. The principal structure is an earth sheltered home and height
is limited due to the earth sheltered design which creates the plight of the landowner.
3. The variance, if granted, will not alter the essential character of the locality. There are
other properties with accessory structures of similar heights to the one requested in the
general area where the property is located.
4. Economic considerations alone do not constitute practical difficulties. The practical
difficulties are due to the earth-sheltered design of the principal structure which does
not allow for a standard measurement for building height and limits the accessory
building height allowance below what might be found on a typical home with a gable
or hip roof in that general area.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Andover
hereby approves the variance request with the following conditions:
1. All necessary permits shall be obtained from any agency having an interest in
improvements constructed on the property.
2. The proposed accessory building shall be for residential use only; not business uses.
3. Pursuant to City Code 12-15-9-E-6, if the City Council determines that no significant
progress has been made within the first twelve (12) months after the approval of the
variance, the variance will be null and void.
th
Adopted by the Andover City Council this 6day of October 2026.
CITY OF ANDOVER
Attest: ________________________________
Jamie Barthel – Mayor
_______________________________
Michelle Hartner – City Clerk
EXHIBIT A
th
Legal description for 15349 7Avenue NW (19-32-24-13-0012):
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RESOLUTION NO. RXXX-26
A RESOLUTION DENYING VARIANCES FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 15439
th
7AVENUE NW; PID# 19-32-24-13-0012 LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
(See attached Exhibit A for legal description)
th
WHEREAS, Todd Kubes is the owner of a parcel of land located at 15349 7 Avenue NW,
Andover, Minnesota with Parcel ID Number 19-32-24-13-0012; and,
WHEREAS, Todd Kubes applied to the City for a variance to the accessory structure height
on the subject property; and,
WHEREAS, the proposal would vary from City Code 12-6-3: Accessory Structure Height in
that it would allow an accessory structure that is approximately 3.5 feet taller than the
principal structure (house), and,
WHEREAS, the principal structure on the property is an earth sheltered home with one
exposed side, and,
WHEREAS, staff has reviewed the variance request; and,
WHEREAS, pursuant to published and mailed notice thereof, the Planning and Zoning
Commission held a public hearing on September 22, 2026;
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommends to the City Council denial of
the variance request; and,
WHEREAS, the City Council completed a review of the variance request along with the
recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Commission and all materials provided
including review of the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting; and,
WHEREAS, the City Council agrees with the recommendation of the Planning and Zoning
Commission and deniesthe variance request to allow an accessory building that exceeds the
height of the principal building height, with a maximum height of 21 feet; and,
WHEREAS, based on the criteria for granting a variance under City Code 12-15-9, the City
Council finds the following findings of fact to support the denial of the variance request:
1.
2.
3.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Andover
hereby deniesthe variance request for an accessory structure taller than the principal structure.
th
Adopted by the Andover City Council this 6day of October 2026.
CITY OF ANDOVER
Attest: ________________________________
Jamie Barthel – Mayor
_______________________________
Michelle Hartner – City Clerk
EXHIBIT A
th
Legal description for 15349 7Avenue NW (19-32-24-13-0012):
STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item # 5
TO: Planning and Zoning Commissioners
CC: Joe Janish, Community Development Director
FROM :Aidan Breen, Associate City Planner
SUBJECT:Public Hearing: Consider an Interim Use Permit –Mining and Land
Reclamation – Unaddressed property at the NE quadrant of Prairie Road
th
and 146 Lane – PID # 25-32-24-21-0004. (Applicant: Mark Smith).
DATE: September 22, 2026
INTRODUCTION
The applicant is requesting an Interim Use Permit (IUP) to accumulate a roughly 70,000
cubic yard stockpile of topsoil that would be located on the eastern portion of the
unaddressed property at the northeastern corner of the intersection of Prairie Road and
th
146 Lane NW (PID: 25-32-24-21-0004). This temporary stockpile would be utilized by
the builder for future grading of a potential development at the site. The applicant is
requesting a 5 year permit to accumulate soil as it becomes available during that time,
with an option to extend the permit in the future. This site previously had a similar IUP
for land reclamationfrom 2019-2024, but ultimately fill was not hauled onto the property
at that time.
DISCUSSION
On August 18, 2026, City staff and other public entities received a complaint that many
truckloads of dirt were being brought to the subject property. Staff inspected the property
and observed the amount of fill to exceed the minimum requirement for an Interim Use
Permit. Since the applicant is proposing land reclamation in excess of 400 cubic yards, an
IUP is required pursuant to City Code 12-13-1 and 12-13-2. Staff notified the property
owner via email on August 18, 2026 of this requirement. The applicant stopped hauling
material at that time and submitted an IUP application, which was found to be complete
th
on September 4, 2026.
In their application materials, the property owner has provided a general map of the
proposed storage area and silt fencing. City Engineering staff are reviewing the proposal.
After initial review, staff recommended a condition for the IUP that would ensure all
stockpiles are kept at least fifty feet (50’) from all wetlands and adjacent properties.
Erosion control will be required, including silt fencing and establishing vegetation within
seven (7) days of inactivity, consistent with NPDES standards, as this site is within one
(1) mile of an impaired waterway (Coon Creek). The applicant will be required to comply
with all staff comments.A draft resolution of approval containing proposed conditions
1
may be found attached to this report. If the Commission determines that restrictions
greater than required by City Code and State Statute are needed, they may recommend
those conditions to the City Council as part of the IUP.
The applicant is requesting a term of five (5) years for their IUP, the maximum allowed
under City Code 12-15-8-E. This would give flexibility to accumulate fill material over
time as it becomes available. At the expiration of the IUP if the applicant would like the
stockpile to remain on the property, they would need to apply for a new IUP and obtain
City Council approval.
Type of Fill Permitted
The stockpile will be comprised of clean compactible soil to be delivered to the site when
available. The applicant indicates that this soil may be used to prepare the property for
future development.
Hours
Hauling would be intermittent at the site, always within the proposed timeframe of 7a-8p
Monday through Friday and Saturday 8a-6pm. The applicant’s proposed hours would
comply with City Code 5-6-3 which regulates hours for construction activities.
Haul Route
The applicant provided a map showing the haul route to the site from Prairie Road. The
applicant will be required to remove any material that accumulates during ancillary use of
the local roadways. Streets adjacent to the stockpile shall be swept clean, daily, if
necessary, as hauling occurs.
Erosion Control
Silt fencing will be required around the stockpile at all times to control any erosion. The
applicant will be required to ensure proper vegetation (seeded/sodded) across the
stockpile within 7 days of inactivity.
Coordination with other Agencies
The applicant is responsible to obtain all appropriate and necessary permits (such as but
not limited to the Coon Creek Watershed District, NPDES, etc.).
Public Notice
In accordance with the City Code, public hearing notice is published in the Anoka
County Union Herald. City Staff sent mailed notice to properties within 700 feet of the
subject property using GIS data provided by Anoka County. In addition, two signswere
posted advertising the public hearing; one near the existing driveway on the southeast
th
corner of the property, and another near the intersection of Prairie Road and 146 Lane
NW.
REVIEW CRITERIA
Interim Use Permit Standards
City Code 12-15-8-D provides the following general review criteria to consider when
granting an IUP. In granting an Interim Use Permit, the City Council shall consider the
recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Commission and:
The Planning and Zoning Commission shall recommend an interim use permit, and the
Council shall issue such interim use permit only if it finds that such use at the proposed
location:
1. Will not create an excess burden on parks, streets, and other public facilities;
The excavation and land reclamation will not create an excess burden on parks or
other public facilities. The applicant’s materials show that fill would be hauled in
th
on Prairie Road to access the site at 146 Lane NW. Due to the intermittent
nature of the hauling, it is not expected that city streets or nearby park facilities
will be meaningfully impacted.
2. Will not be injurious to the surrounding neighborhood or otherwise harm the
public health, safety, and general welfare;
The applicant shall establish vegetation and ensure proper erosion control to the
satisfaction of the City Engineer. The applicant is required to observe all noise
and similar type regulations during operation.
3. Will not have a negative effect on the values of property and scenic views;
The stockpile will be temporary and is intended to facilitate possible future
development of the site. It is not anticipated that the stockpile will have a negative
effect on the values of property or scenic views.
4. Will not impose additional unreasonable costs on the public;
The applicant is required to obtain all necessary permits. Any material that falls
outside of the property line or right-of-way is the responsibility of the applicant to
remove. If the stockpile remains past the expiration date of the IUP, the applicant
will need to seek a new IUP or remove the stockpile from the property at their
cost.
5. Will be subjected to, by agreement with the owner, any conditions that the City
Council has deemed appropriate for the permission of the use, including a
condition that the owner may be required to provide appropriate financial surety
to cover the cost of removing the interim use and any interim structures upon the
expiration of the interim use permit.
ACTION REQUESTED
The Planning and Zoning Commission is requested to hold a public hearing and make a
recommendation to the City Council regarding the interim use permit request.
Attachment(s):
1) Draft Resolution of Approval
2) Draft Resolution of Denial
3) Applicant Narrative
4)Applicant Maps (Stockpile location, wetlands, haul route)
5) Public Comments – None as of 09/18/26
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RESOLUTION NO. RXXX-26
A RESOLUTION GRANTING AN INTERIM USE PERMIT FOR MINING AND
LAND RECLAMATION AT THE UNADDRESSED PROPERTY WITH PID# 25-32-
24-21-0004, LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS:
THAT PRT OF N1/2 OF SEC 25 T32 R24 LYG WLY OF BLK 2 SMITHS
ROLLING OAKS, NLY OF 146TH LN NW & ELY OF PRAIRIE RD; EX N
321.44 FT THEREOF; ALSO EX RDS; SUBJ TO EASE OF REC
WHEREAS, the applicant requested an Interim Use Permit for the mining and land
reclamation of up to 70,000 cubic yards of soil pursuant to Andover City Code 12-13-1
and 12-13-2 ; and
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing on September
22, 2026; and
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission finds the request would not have a
detrimental effect upon the health, safety, and general welfare of the City of Andover;
and
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed the request and has
determined that said request meets the standards of City Code 12-15-8 for Interim Use
Permits; and
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommends to the City Council
approval of the interim use permit.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Andover
hereby approves the interim use permit to allow for the mining and land reclamation of
up to 70,000 cubic yards of soil on said property with the following conditions:
1. Applicant shall address all staff comments related to the Interim Use Permit
and all applicable permits to the satisfaction of the City.
2. Soil shall not be placed within wetland, floodplain, or right-of-way areas
without first obtaining any required approvals.
3. No grading/stockpiles shall occur within 50 feet of wetlands or adjacent
property lines or right-of-way unless approved by the City Engineer.
4. Any material intended to be used for grading purposes for future development
and construction on the subject property must be clean, granular fill with
minimal organic material, suitable for construction of building pads and road
right of ways.
5. Slopes shall not exceed 3 to 1 ratios.
6. Silt fencing and any other erosion control measures as deemed necessary by
the City Engineer shall be installed and maintained around the exterior of the
stockpile.
7. Hours of operation shall be restricted to the normal construction hours as
regulated by City Code 5-6-3.
8. The applicant will be required to seed the site as per NPDES permits and
seed/hydro mulch the stockpile toensure proper vegetation to the satisfaction
of the City Engineer.
9. The applicant shall be responsible for the cleaning of material (soil, sand, etc.)
from the public roadways as needed (may require multiple times a day), with a
minimum of daily cleaning when the site is active.
10. All appropriate permits shall be obtained from any agency that may have an
interest in the site including but not limited to NPDES, Coon Creek
Watershed District, Minnesota Pollution Control Agency.
11. All material shall be utilized in compliance with the City requirements.
12. Any future mining or land reclamation with fill in excess of 400 cubic yards
shall require a new IUP.
13. Permit shall expire on October 6, 2031.
th
Adopted by the City Council of the City of Andover on this 6 day of October 2026.
CITY OF ANDOVER
____________________
ATTEST: Jamie Barthel, Mayor
_
Michelle Hartner, City Clerk
CITY OF ANDOVER
COUNTY OF ANOKA
STATE OF MINNESOTA
RESOLUTION NO. RXXX-26
ESOLUTION DENYING AN INTERIM USE PERMIT FOR MINING AND LAND
A R
RECLAMATION AT THE UNADDRESSED PROPERTY WITH PID# 25-32-24-21-
0004, LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS:
THAT PRT OF N1/2 OF SEC 25 T32 R24 LYG WLY OF BLK 2 SMITHS
ROLLING OAKS, NLY OF 146TH LN NW & ELY OF PRAIRIE RD; EX N
321.44 FT THEREOF; ALSO EX RDS; SUBJ TO EASE OF REC
WHEREAS, the applicant requested an Interim Use Permit for the mining and land
reclamation of up to 70,000 cubic yards of soil pursuant to Andover City Code 12-13-1
and 12-13-2; and
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing on September
22, 2026; and
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission finds the request would have a
detrimental effect upon the health, safety, and general welfare of the City of Andover;
and
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed the request and has
determined that said request does not meet the standards of City Code 12-15-8 for
Interim Use Permits; and
WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommends to the City Council
denial of the interim use permit.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Andover
hereby agrees with the recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Commission and
denies the interim use permitrequest; for the following reasons:
1.
2.
3.
th
Adopted by the City Council of the City of Andover on this 6 day of October 2026.
CITY OF ANDOVER
____________________
ATTEST:Jaime Barthel, Mayor
_____________________
Michelle Hartner, City Clerk